×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

French Regulator Criticizes Loot Boxes but Says They’re Not Gambling

French organization the Autorité de regulation des jeux en ligne (ARJEL) found that video game loot boxes don’t break the country’s gambling law, according to a 2017-2018 activity report GamesIndustry.biz reports. But, it’s not exactly complimentary toward them either.

Gambling is generally prohibited in France unless it’s expressly permitted by the regulator, according to Baker McKenzie associate Sebastian Schwiddessen, who wrote an analysis of the report. Only three types of online gambling are currently allowed — poker, horse betting, and sports betting. The ARJEL could potentially consider loot boxes gambling too if the items they generate have a real world monetary value, he said, especially if the items are likely to be sold outside of the game. While most publishers explicitly prohibit off-platform trading in their terms of service, the ARJEL said “a certain number of investigations are in progress.”

Like South Korea, the Netherlands and Belgium, the ARJEL began investigating loot boxes after widespread controversy last year over how they’re implemented in video games, especially full-priced AAA titles like “Star Wars Battlefront II” and “Destiny 2.” “Battlefront II” fans were particularly outraged, calling EA’s microtransactions unfair and exploitative. They blasted the publisher on Reddit, giving it the most downvoted comment in the website’s history. EA also reportedly lost an estimated $3.1 billion in stock value at the time. Hawaii state representative Chris Lee allegedly called the game a “‘Star Wars’-themed online casino designed to lure kids into spending money” and introduced legislation that would prohibit selling video games with loot boxes to people under the age of 21.

While loot boxes might not fall under the legal definition of gambling in France, the ARJEL voted for a combined and coordinated action on them. It said they can serve as a gambling “apprenticeship” for young people. It also criticized the fact that minors can play games containing loot boxes without any age verification, and that the random number generator responsible for determining loot box items is not transparent to the player.

But, while the ARJEL’s comments are critical, Schwiddessen said they’re also non-committal and unspecific. “Altogether it is unlikely that any concrete actions will follow,” he said.

More Gaming

  • Revolution Software Announces 'Beyond A Steel

    'Beyond a Steel Sky' Is a Sequel to Classic '90s 'Beneath a Steel Sky'

    Revolution Software’s 1994 adventure game “Beneath a Steel Sky” is getting a sequel, the game developer announced during Monday’s Apple keynote. No, it’s not “Beneath a Steel Sky 2,” but “Beyond a Steel Sky.” It will find lead designer and Revolution head Charles Cecil and artist Dave Gibbons teaming up once more to bring the [...]

  • Apple Announces Gaming Subscription Service

    Apple Announces Gaming Subscription Service Apple Arcade

    Apple detailed its long-rumored gaming subscription service during a special event it held in Cupertino, California Monday. Apple Arcade is the world’s first game subscription service for mobile, desktop and living room, the company said. With a single subscription, you get access to more than 100 new and exclusive games. The games won’t be on [...]

  • 'Raji: An Ancient Epic' mixes tight

    'Raji: An Ancient Epic' mixes tight combat, gorgeous visuals, and Indian culture

    It’s hard to keep count of the number of games based around Greek, Roman, and Japanese mythology. Their histories are so deep and full of tantalizing stories that weave through fact and fiction seamlessly– they make stories flow off the paper. Indian mythology and the thousands of cultural subsets it contains is no different. The [...]

  • EA to Publish New Team-Based Action

    EA to Publish New Team-Based Action Game From Indie Studio Velan

    Independent game developer Velan Studios is working on its first original intellectual property and it will publish it under Electronic Arts’ EA Partners program, the two companies announced on Monday. The new game will release on PC, consoles, and mobile. Velan is promising not only a unique game world, but an “entirely new and entertaining [...]

  • ‘God of War’ Director on Overcoming

    ‘God of War’ Director on Imposter Syndrome, Overcoming Failure, Doubt

    It’s easy to talk about what made 2018’s “God of War” so successful. The PlayStation 4 exclusive was a beautiful game, with an emotional story that transformed Kratos from an angry, two-dimensional anti-hero into an empathetic figure who, at the end of the day, was a father struggling to raise his only son. But perhaps [...]

  • '90s Fighting Series 'Samurai Shodown' Returns

    '90s Fighting Series 'Samurai Shodown' Returns This June

    Fighting game publisher and developer SNK is reviving the 1990s franchise “Samurai Shodown,” it announced on Monday. The weapon-based fighting game returns to PlayStation 4 and Xbox One this June. It’s also coming to Nintendo Switch in Q4 2019, and to PC at a later date. The reboot gives the 2D classic a 3D facelift, [...]

  • Devs From Pakistan, Paraguay, More Share

    Devs From Pakistan, Paraguay, More Share Their #1ReasonToBe in Games Industry

    It’s difficult to count the number of barriers that game developers from outside North America, Western Europe, and Japan face when trying to make a successful indie. Whether it be Argentina or Romania, the infrastructure isn’t there for a lot of countries. Regardless of the game development situation in these countries, people still play games. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content