×

Bethesda Sues Warner Bros., Calls ‘Westworld’ Game ‘Blatant Ripoff’

Bethesda Softworks is suing Warner Bros. Entertainment and Canadian game developer Behaviour Interactive for allegedly using code from its “Fallout Shelter” game to create a new “Westworld” mobile app.

Bethesda filed the suit in a District of Maryland court on Thursday, Jun. 21. It’s accusing Behaviour of breach of contract, copyright infringement, unfair competition, and misappropriation of trade secrets. It’s also suing Warner Bros. for allegedly persuading Behaviour to breach that contract. It now wants both companies to remove each and every version of the “Westworld” mobile game from distribution and to stop developing and supporting it. They are also asking for undisclosed statutory and punitive damages.

Bethesda hired Behaviour in 2014 to work on its “Fallout Shelter” app. “Fallout Shelter” is a free-to-play simulation game where the player builds and manages a post-apocalyptic bunker full of workers. The “Westworld” app similarly allows the player to build their own version of the eponymous theme park and interact with characters from the hit HBO TV show.

In the complaint, obtained by Variety, Bethesda claimed Behaviour and Warner Bros. used its intellectual property without permission to develop a mobile game with the same or substantially similar gameplay experience.

“In so doing, Behaviour breached its contract with Bethesda and utilized its restricted access to Bethesda’s intellectual property, including Bethesda’s copyrighted code, trade secrets, and other rights, to compress its development timeline, reduce costs, and quickly bring the ‘Westworld’ mobile game to market, and offer players the widely popular gameplay experience found in ‘Fallout Shelter,'” the complaint said.

Bethesda points to specific bugs in the “Westworld” app as evidence of stolen code. Those very same bugs are in “Fallout Shelter’s” code, it said. For example, Bethesda claimed the demo version of the “Westworld” game includes a visible software bug that’s also present in an early version of “Fallout Shelter” code Behaviour delivered to Bethesda during its development.

“The ‘Westworld’ game is a blatant rip-off of ‘Fallout Shelter,'” Bethesda said.

Variety contacted Bethesda, Warner Bros., and Behaviour Interactive about the lawsuit. Bethesda issued the following statement:

Bethesda Softworks has today filed a complaint in U.S. District Court against Behaviour Interactive and Warner Bros. for copyright infringement, breach of contract, and misappropriation of its intellectual property. The case arises from Behaviour’s development of a ‘Westworld’ mobile game for Warner Bros. Behaviour had previously worked with Bethesda to develop Bethesda’s hit game, ‘Fallout Shelter,’ and under that contract, Bethesda alone owned all resulting intellectual property, including the game’s copyrighted code.

“Behaviour illegally used the same copyrighted source code from ‘Fallout Shelter’ to develop ‘Westworld,’ and copied Fallout Shelter’s game design, art, animations, gameplay features, and other elements. As a result of Behaviour and Warner Bros’ unlawful conduct, ‘Westworld’ is a blatant ripoff of ‘Fallout Shelter’ with largely superficial, cosmetic changes.

“Bethesda will vigorously protect its legal rights in the valuable intellectual properties it owns, and take legal action whenever those rights are being infringed.”

Warner Bros. and Behaviour Interactive did not immediately respond.

 

 

More Gaming

  • Dara Ó Briain Returns to Host

    Dara Ó Briain Returns to Host British Academy Games Awards

    Comedian Dara Ó Briain will once again host the British Academy Games Awards, BAFTA announced on Wednesday. This will be Ó Briain’s ninth time hosting the ceremony, which takes place on Apr. 4. It will be held at Queen Elizabeth Hall on London’s Southbank for the first time ever. The Irish comedian is perhaps best [...]

  • Valve Retiring Non-Gaming Videos, Video Section

    Valve Retiring Non-Gaming Videos, Video Section From Steam

    The video section of the Steam menu has been retired, and an undisclosed number of non-gaming video will be pulled from the Steam Store due to apparent lack of interest, according to a news update from Valve Tuesday. The video section of the Steam Store had both paid and free content for Steam users, but [...]

  • Fortnite Battle Royale

    'Fortnite' Law Firm Reports Someone Tried to End Dance Lawsuits With Fake Emails

    The law firm representing a number of celebrities who are suing “Fortnite” creator Epic Games reports that someone tried to sabotage the cases by sending fake emails to the U.S. Copyright Office. Pierce Bainbridge Beck Price & Hecht said the following typo-riddled message was sent to the office over the holiday weekend from someone pretending [...]

  • 'Roblox' Digital Civility Effort Teaches It's

    'Roblox' Digital Civility Effort Teaches It's Cool to be Kind

    While the safety of children in online video games remains a top priority in the industry, the massively popular game “Roblox” is also investing it what it believes is another key issue for gaming online: digital civility. “Roblox,” which just surpassed one billion hours of engagement by players, recently hired Laura Higgins, a renowned expert [...]

  • Embark Teases First 'Proper' Game, Future

    Former EA-Exec Söderlund Teases New Studio, First 'Proper' Game

    Former EA-exec Patrick Söderlund hinted at the first game that Embark Studios is working on, as well as other plans for the company and game development, in a Medium post Wednesday. The untitled project will be a co-op, free-to-play game. Few details were revealed, but the action title, which will be developed using Epic’s Unreal [...]

  • 'Magic: The Gathering' World Championship 2019

    'Magic: The Gathering' World Championship 2019 Schedule Announced

    Players of “Magic: The Gathering” and “Magic: The Gathering Arena” can soon compete across seven Mythic Championships to reach the Magic World Championship, Wizards of the Coast announced on Wednesday. The 2019 season kicks off Feb. 22-24 with the first Mythic Championship in Cleveland, Ohio. Winners of each Mythic Championship will get a slot in [...]

  • Discord Partners With 2K To Bring

    Discord Partners With 2K To Bring 'BioShock,' 'XCOM,' Others to Nitro

    Discord is entering a partnership with 2K that will bring several of the publisher’s top-selling titles to Discord Nitro in 2019. The collaboration will include five games at first: “XCOM: Enemy Unknown,” “BioShock Remastered,” “BioShock 2 Remastered,” “Sid Meier’s Civilization IV Complete,” and “Mafia.” “Discord aims to provide players with the best content out there [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content