Sundance Film Review: Charlize Theron in ‘Tully’

Charlize Theron gives a fearless performance as a woman snowed under by motherhood in the third movie from Jason Reitman and Diablo Cody.

Jason Reitman
Charlize Theron, Mackenzie Davis, Mark Duplass, Ron Livingston, Emily Haine, Elaine Tan.
Release Date:
Apr 20, 2018

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5610554/

In “Tully,” the third collaboration between director Jason Reitman and screenwriter Diablo Cody, Charlize Theron plays Marlo, a New York suburban mom with two kids who’s about to give birth to her third. Offhand, it would be hard to think of another movie that dug into the messy, overwhelming, how-the-hell-am-I-gonna-get-through-this? aspects of motherhood the way that this one does.

Theron’s performance is fearless, emotionally raw, and physically intense, rippled with embattled waves of exhaustion and anger. After her infant daughter, Mia, is born, Marlo is still carrying her baby weight (the way that mothers in movies almost never do). But more than that she’s carrying the weight of the world. Theron gives a heroically unglamorous and knife-edged performance, lashing out in ways both big and small. She lets us see how doing so makes perfect sense for a woman who is starting to feel the act of giving life — and sustaining it — draining the life out of her.

Marlo’s husband, Drew (Ron Livingston), is an ineffectual nice guy who does “what he can,” but that isn’t really much. He works hard at his career, helps the other children with their homework, and unwinds playing video games. He’s clueless, like so many husbands, about the way his wife’s existence has turned into a pressure cooker, and Reitman orchestrates an ingeniously extended montage of baby care (the waking and feeding and changing of diapers that’s so constant it begins to feel like a conspiracy of sleep deprivation) to put the audience right in the middle of it.

Enter…the Diablo Cody free spirit. The upstart of wisecracking hellbent feminine moxie. That was Juno, of course, and it was also the messed-up, tart-tongued anti-heroine played by Theron in “Young Adult.” In “Tully,” it is Tully (Mackenzie Davis), a night nanny who’s been offered to Marlo as a gift from her wealthy brother (Mark Duplass). For a while, Marlo resists the offer, but after a few weeks of baby care break her down, she gives in and calls. And the young woman who shows up at the door is like a nanny from heaven.

She’s 26 years old, wise beyond her years, sharp and sexy in a maroon cut-off top, and a supremely vibrant and generous caregiver. The Canadian actress Mackenzie Davis looks, and acts, like some heretofore unheralded relative of Julia Roberts, and she makes Tully’s presence a balm. She looks after the baby at night so that Marlo can slumber, bringing the crying infant to her for breast-feedings (though it’s hard not to notice that the film tiptoes around the possibility of co-sleeping).

She also cleans up the house, engages in a deeply knowing and informed-about-everything brand of millennial repartee, and beams with pleasure as she drops whimsical holistic pensées like “She’ll grow a little overnight. And so will we!” Marlo looks at her and says, “You’re like a book of fun facts for unpopular fourth graders.” Which is, more or less, a fine thing to be, especially if you’re delivering dialogue that carries that Diablo Cody snap.

Tully, for a good while, doesn’t do anything terribly exotic — she’s like an extremely hip postpartum doula. But as her blissed-out ministrations bring Marlo back to life, the audience can’t help but wonder: What’s the catch? Without one, there would be no drama; there would be no movie. Without revealing the catch, I’ll just say that the first clue arrives when Tully volunteers to spice up Marlo’s sex life by sleeping with her husband, and the plan, unlikely as it sounds, works out swimmingly.

Jason Reitman has had a curious career. A decade ago, he had two terrific hits in a row: “Juno” (2007), with its impishly scandalous young heroine, and “Up in the Air” (2009), a bracing romantic fable that took stock of the collapsing middle class from the point of view of George Clooney’s downsizing messenger of bad news. Both films tapped into something and connected, not just at the box office but with the inner spirit of the audience. In the years since, however, Reitman has become a creator of beveled-edge movies that feel like glorified trifles. It’s hard to say what, exactly, is missing, but even though Reitman is working in the humanist tradition of Jonathan Demme, his films have become sincere but minor diversions. And that goes for “Tully” as well.

Theron’s performance is something to see, but apart from that there’s an earnest soft-headedness to “Tully.” Take the character of Marlo’s son, Jonah (Asher Miles Fallica). He’s got some serious issues — he’ll do stuff like relentlessly kick the back seat of the car, or break into hysterical screaming at the sound of a school toilet flushing. Marlo insists that he’s just “quirky,” even when his school pegs him as a problem child; she’s finally forced to withdraw him and move him to a different school. But what’s the film’s attitude? Jonah strikes us as having potential traits of autism, yet through all the arguments about him the word is never mentioned. It’s as if Reitman wants him to be, simply, quirky.

And then there’s Tully. She convinces Marlo to take a night off, driving with her to Marlo’s old stomping ground of Bushwick for a girls’ night out. The two drink bourbon, bang heads in a mosh pit, and wind up in a punk-hellhole bathroom draining Marlo’s breasts of milk, so that she’s not in pain. Women who are mothers may feel like they’ve never seen a scene like this one before; it hits a note of naked truth.

What happens next, however, does not. Reitman and Cody have tried to make a movie that confronts, head on, the secret anguish of motherhood — not just the physical demands and the exhaustion, but the journey that can make mothers, on their darkest days, feel like they’re losing their minds. That’s a daring thing to try to put into a movie, and the filmmakers deserve a salute for it. Yet their strategy proves more audacious than it is convincing. “Tully” has its heart (and many other things) in the right place, but by the end you wish it had an imagination finely executed enough to match its empathy.

Sundance Film Review: Charlize Theron in 'Tully'

Reviewed at Sundance Film Festival (TBA), January 25, 2018. Running time: 94 MIN.

Production: A Focus Features release of a Bron Studios, Right of Way Films, Denver and Delilah Productions prod. Producers: Diablo Cody, A.J. Dix, Helen Estabrook, Aaron L. Gilbert, Beth Kono, Mason Novick, Jason Reitman, Charlize Theron. Executive producers: Jason Blumenfeld, Jason Cloth, David Gendron, Ali Jazayeri, Ron McLeod, Andrew Pollack, Paul Tennyson, Stan Thomas, Dale Wells.

Crew: Director: Jason Reitman. Screenplay: Diablo Cody. Camera (color, widescreen): Eric Steelberg. Editors: Stefan Grube.

With: Charlize Theron, Mackenzie Davis, Mark Duplass, Ron Livingston, Emily Haine, Elaine Tan.

More Film

  • Woolsey Fire Malibu

    Many Malibu Areas Still Off-Limits for Filming After Fire

    The California Film Commission has maintained its ban on filming in several Malibu areas hit by the massive Woolsey fire in Southern California last month. The commission announced Tuesday that due to continued clean-up and repair work along Pacific Coast Highway, permits for filming on the highway are not being issued at this time. PCH [...]

  • Against the Clock

    Film News Roundup: Andy Garcia's Spy Thriller 'Against the Clock' Bought by Gravitas

    In today’s film news roundup, Andy Garcia’s spy thriller is sold, “Battlestar Galactica” gets a screenwriter, and Brooklyn Decker gets an award. ACQUISITION Gravitas Ventures has acquired North American rights to spy thriller “Against the Clock,” starring Andy Garcia, Dianna Agron (“Glee”), and Justin Bartha, Variety has learned exclusively. More Reviews London Theater Review: 'The [...]

  • 'Pacific Rim Uprising' film premiere

    John Boyega in Talks to Star in Legal Drama 'A Naked Singularity'

    “Star Wars” actor John Boyega is in talks to star in the legal drama “A Naked Singularity” with Ridley Scott’s Scott Free Productions on board to produce. The movie is based on Sergio De La Pava’s debut novel, which centers on a successful New York public defender whose life begins to unravel after he loses [...]

  • Penny Marshall Dead Obit

    Remembering Penny Marshall, Who Forged Her Own Path and Paved the Way for Others

    She was a natural comedian — fearless and funny, willing to trade on her natural Bronx brogue to craft a sassy and street-wise character that was tailor-made for sitcoms. But Penny Marshall, who died Monday night at the age of 75, proved throughout her long career that she had so much more in the way [...]

  • Aquaman 2018

    'Aquaman' Outpacing 'Wonder Woman' in Fandango Pre-Sales

    Pre-sales of “Aquaman,” which opens on Thursday night, are outpacing “Wonder Woman” at the same point in the advance ticket sales cycle on online ticketer Fandango. “Wonder Woman” opened with $103 million domestically during the June 2 to June 4, 2017, weekend on its way to a $412 million North American total for Warner Bros. “Aquaman,” [...]

  • European Union Placeholder

    Europe, Hollywood Hail Landmark E.U. Territorial Licensing Agreement

    Industry organizations and major companies in Europe and Hollywood welcomed Tuesday a high-level European Union agreement that in large part preserves producers’ ability to sell movies and TV shows on an exclusive territory-by-territory basis. Territorial licensing is a financial backbone of the film and TV business in Europe. Recognition of such licensing came last Thursday in [...]

  • Box Office: 'Aquaman,' 'Mary Poppins Returns'

    Box Office: 'Aquaman' Battles 'Mary Poppins Returns' in Crowded Holiday Weekend

    It’s the most wonderful time of the year, and the most competitive time at the multiplexes. This weekend sees two very different heroes vying for the box office crown with “Aquaman” and “Mary Poppins Returns” both eyeing sizable debuts. “Mary Poppins Returns” is getting a head start by opening on Wednesday, though estimates show “Aquaman” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content