You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘To the Four Winds’

A tenacious farmer offers clandestine housing and assistance to scores of refugees crossing from Italy in this low-budget documentary.

Michel Toesca
Cédric Herrou, Isabelle Leonardi, Michel Toesca. (French, Italian, Arabic dialogue)

1 hour 40 minutes

It’s rare to find low budget, guerilla-style documentaries at major film festivals in these days of highly polished productions, but “To the Four Winds” hits the right political buttons, especially for France. Using an old DV Cam, Michel Toesca filmed tenacious farmer Cédric Herrou over the course of three years as he welcomed refugees into his corner of the mountainous Roya valley, nestled along the French-Italian border. Clear in its focus on those assisting refugees rather than on the refugees themselves, the documentary charts the resilience of Herrou and a few other unintentional activists as they fight changeable law enforcement in the Alpes-Maritimes department of France’s southeast. “Four Winds” is a natural for human rights festivals and strands.

Most years, single farmer Herrou would be cultivating his olive trees, but beginning around 2015, he realized that scores of refugees, primarily from Africa, were crossing the wild terrain of the Roya valley to get from Italy to France. Initially his efforts at accommodating them for short periods of time were achieved under the radar, but as the numbers increased and the French government flip-flopped on how they were dealing with the crisis, Herrou became more outspoken, not just about the temporary housing he was providing but the assistance he gave in smuggling people across the border.

Obviously the authorities weren’t happy, but there was little agreement on how to enforce ambiguous laws, on top of which the Alpes-Maritimes was treated as a special case. Herrou and his allies targeted one provision in particular, which states that France has an obligation to let unaccompanied minors stay in the country; when the police flouted that stipulation, the activists were able to go to court with legal justification for (some of) their actions.

Toesca began shooting in 2015, gauging reactions to the refugee crisis along the border, but the bulk of “Four Winds,” edited down from more than 200 hours of footage, covers 2017, as legal cases mount. It’s encouraging to see so many locals expressing support for Herrou’s actions, though it’s possible that the director simply chose not to give screen-time to anti-immigrant voices apart from a few at the very start. He doesn’t hide his own involvement, admitting that working on this film makes him feel alive; that’s a legitimate statement, though there’s something a bit off about watching him and Herrou celebrating the happy end of a tense stand-off between police and a refugee family by digging into a large platter of fritto misto. They certainly deserve to rejoice in victory, but one wonders what that refugee family would be eating on the same night.

A couple of refugees are heard, such as a Nigerian man who escaped from Boko Haram, and a pregnant Libyan woman, but a few more such voices would have corrected the nagging impression that Toesca made the film as a big pat on the back to himself and his friend. Without question, Herrou and heroic people like nurse Isabelle Leonardi deserve recognition in their fight to give assistance and dignity to refugees who are systematically abandoned by governments worldwide, yet by offering so little space to the men and women they’re helping, “Four Winds” reduces these stories to a nameless mass, robbing them of their individuality. Video quality fluctuates, as Toesca occasionally inserts footage shot on other devices.

Film Review: 'To the Four Winds'

Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Special Screenings), May 18, 2018. 100 MIN. Original title: Libre.

Production: (Documentary – France) A Jour 2 Fête release of a SaNoSi Prods. production. (International sales: Jour 2 Fête, Paris.) Producer: Jean-Marie Gigon.

Crew: Director, writer: Michel Toesca. Camera (color): Toesca. Editors: Catherine Libert, Toesca. Music: Magic Malik.

With: Cédric Herrou, Isabelle Leonardi, Michel Toesca. (French, Italian, Arabic dialogue)

More Film

  • Photographer: Guy Godfree. In shot: Zoey

    Tribeca Film Festival: 9 Movies to Watch

    The Tribeca Film Festival kicks off on Wednesday with a slate of movies from up-and-coming filmmakers and established directors that tackle hot-button issues such as gun violence, homophobia, and gender discrimination. The annual celebration of film was originally founded by Robert De Niro and producer Jane Rosenthal to encourage people to return to a corner [...]

  • Tribeca Film Festival'Venus in Fur' film

    Tribeca Film Festival: 10 Music Docs We’re Excited to See

    While the Tribeca Film Festival usually has strong music entries, this year has such a bounty that narrowing our top picks down to 10 was a challenge. This year’s offerings range from documentaries on the legendary Apollo Theater, the Wu-Tang Clan and Rolling Stones bassist Bill Wyman to music-adjacent films like Danny Boyle’s “Yesterday” (about [...]

  • Abigail Disney on Bob Iger

    Abigail Disney Calls Robert Iger's Pay 'Naked Indecency' in Op-Ed

    After stirring a flurry of reactions over her Tweets calling out wage inequality at the Walt Disney Co. on Sunday, Abigail Disney, a filmmaker and philanthropist who is the grand niece of Walt Disney, penned an opinion column outlining her arguments against Disney’s pay practices. In her op-ed, which was published in the Washington Post [...]

  • Avengers: Endgame

    'Avengers: Endgame' Surpasses $100 Million in China on Opening Day

    “Avengers: Endgame” is breaking records in China, raking in more than $100 million by evening of its opening day Wednesday – two days ahead of the U.S. – and putting itself firmly on track to become the biggest Hollywood title ever in the Middle Kingdom. About 9 p.m. local time in China, the Marvel finale [...]

  • ‘The Gift: The Journey of Johnny

    Film Review: ‘The Gift: The Journey of Johnny Cash’

    Very much in the manner of an “unplugged” acoustic album that showcases the musicianship of a major artist without distracting flash and filigree, “The Gift: The Journey of Johnny Cash” is a tightly focused yet impressively multifaceted documentary that attempts nothing less than to delve past familiar myths and illuminate the soul of its fabled [...]

  • Emily Morgan Cormac Fox Gregoire Debailly

    European Film Promotion Reveals 2019's Producers on the Move

    Twenty of Europe’s up-and-coming producers are going to Cannes with European Film Promotion. The organization unveiled its latest roster of Producers on the Move on Wednesday, a lineup that features France’s Gregoire Debailly, who produced Jean-Bernard Marlin’s “Sheherazade,” which premiered in Critics’ Week in Cannes last year, and Ireland’s Cormac Fox, who produced Sophie Hyde’s [...]

  • Avengers EndGame Trailer

    ‘Avengers: Endgame’ Tops Studios’ TV Ad Spending

    In this week’s edition of the Variety Movie Commercial Tracker, powered by TV ad measurement and attribution company iSpot.tv, Marvel claims the top spot in spending with “Avengers: Endgame.” Ads placed for the superhero film had an estimated media value of $6.28 million through Sunday for 927 national ad airings on 39 networks. (Spend figures [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content