×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Three Identical Strangers’

Tim Wardle's gripping group portrait of triplets reunited at 19 breaks fresh ground in uncovering why they were separated in the first place.

Director:
Tim Wardle
With:
Bobby Shafran, David Kellman, Lawrence Wright.

1 hour 36 minutes

Separated at birth, then reunited at age 19 in 1980, New York triplets Bobby Shafran, Eddy Galland, and David Kellman became the toast of the talk-show circuit after learning that they were long-lost brothers. Though their story received considerable exposure at the time — making them a welcome fixture at Studio 54, landing them a cameo with Madonna in “Desperately Seeking Susan,” and so on — the public tended to focus on the inspirational reunion rather than asking questions about the circumstances of their adoption.

Turns out, the brothers’ story is much bigger and more complicated than anyone imagined, and is only now being properly revealed, thanks to director Tim Wardle’s jaw-dropping decades-later doc “Three Identical Strangers.” A gripping, stranger-than-fiction account of a real-world medical conspiracy, the film begins as a human-interest story and builds to an impressive work of investigative journalism into how and why they were placed with the families who raised them. The truth about the triplets — especially the implications such a case holds for the classic nature-versus-nurture debate — boggles the mind. After all, how often do we encounter three identical young men raised in relatively different social environments?

If you want to save the surprise for the film itself, stop reading now. Shockingly enough, the infants’ separation was no accident, but a carefully orchestrated variable in an elaborate psychological experiment. Behind it all is a plot practically on par with Ira Levin’s “The Boys From Brazil,” a pulp page-turner in which Dr. Mengele and a gang of Nazi scientists try to resurrect Adolf Hitler by not only replicating his DNA but ensuring that the clones are raised by similar parents (a young mother married to a civil servant 23 years her senior), even going so far as to re-create a key trauma in each young boy’s life at age 13 (they do it 94 times, hoping one of the clones will turn out like their beloved Führer). It’s an outrageous concept for a book, but no less loony than what appears to have happened here — even though, in this case, everyone involved was Jewish.

Twin studies can be invaluable for countless reasons, since they’re virtually the only way to isolate the influence of genetics when examining the impact of other variables on two individuals. While it’s well known that Nazi scientists conducted rudimentary twin-based eugenics tests, until now there’s been nothing to suggest an experiment of this scale taking place in the United States — and never a case where the researchers had a hand in separating the subjects for the sake of scientific observation.

Early on, Shafran recounts how he and Galland happened to discover each other’s existence. It’s like a scene out of “The Twilight Zone,” dramatically reenacted using young actors, as Shafran shows up for his first semester at Sullivan County Community College, only to be mistaken for his twin brother. It’s not until the story runs in New York papers that Kellman recognizes that he, too, might be related, leading to a well-publicized reunion.

In addition to two of the brothers, Wardle involves family members and the newspaper reporter who broke the story to retell this chapter in their reunion — all edited at maximum energy to draw audiences in and mask a second major twist. As the triplets’ case starts to look more complicated, Wardle incorporates other twins (notably, two sisters who had been separated by the same Jewish adoption agency, Louise Wise Services) and journalist Lawrence Wright, who had uncovered some of the truth when researching a story about the phenomenon, even interviewing Dr. Peter Neubauer, the psychologist behind the study of which they were all unwitting participants.

The film makes the point that whereas the first wave of coverage around the triplets focused on the brothers’ similarities — the way they completed one another’s sentences, their shared mannerisms, and their matching taste in women — no one seemed to be paying close enough attention to their differences. No one except Neubauer and his staff, who placed the boys in homes with radically different parenting styles and checked in at regular intervals to perform tests tracking the children’s emotional development. Looking at them today, it’s hard to believe they were triplets at all. Brothers, certainly, but not identical siblings.

Even without headings to separate the sections, the well-organized film is clearly divided into distinct chapters, which vary the tone and energy of the documentary enough to keep us riveted — although things start to feel somewhat repetitive toward the end, as rhetorical questions about the ethics of the experiment become the central focus. Would the brothers have led happier lives if they had grown up together? What gave Neubauer or Louise Wise Services the right to play God with their fates? And why is there still such secrecy around the study, the results of which were sealed for decades?

In the closing minutes, the movie becomes almost oppressively self-righteous, adopting (for lack of a better word) the attitude of the brothers, who have reason to feel violated and want to know to what end their lives were thus manipulated. Hardly anyone here seems to accept that Neubauer’s work — so controversial in retrospect — was the product of an earlier era whose practices gave rise to the trope (which still echoes through film and TV, from “The Shape of Water” to “Stranger Things”) where men in lab coats experiment on that which they do not understand. As the documentary wraps, a new chapter is just beginning — one that involves a legal battle and, with any luck, will answer whether the knowledge gained from the study could possibly be worth the tragedy sustained by its unwitting subjects.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'Three Identical Strangers'

Reviewed at Raleigh Studios, Los Angeles, Jan. 11, 2018. (In Sundance, Miami, Santa Barbara film festivals.) Running time: 96 MIN.

Production: A Neon release of a CNN Films presentation, in association with Channel 4 Television, of a Raw production. Producers: Becky Read, Grace Hughes-Hallett. Executive producers: Dimitri Doganis, Adam Hawkins, Tom Barry, Amy Entelis, Courtney Sexton, Sara Ramsden.

Crew: Director: Tim Wardle. Camera (color/B&W): Tim Cragg. Editor: Michael Harte.

With: Bobby Shafran, David Kellman, Lawrence Wright.

More Film

  • Rocketman

    'Rocketman': Chris Dickens Discusses the Inside Story of Editing 'I'm Still Standing'

    Endings are so important and how the viewer leaves the cinema is crucial. For editor Chris Dickens, finding the perfect ending for “Rocketman” was paramount, but it was also a challenge. Elton John’s hit “I’m Still Standing” was going to end the film with the original idea of going to Cannes to recreate the video [...]

  • A general view of the skyline

    United Media Asia Strikes Deal With Indonesian Giant Kompas Gramedia

    Newly-formed content finance, production and distribution company United Media Asia has struck a first look deal, brokered by Hollywood talent agency CAA, with Indonesian media giant Kompas Gramedia. United has also unveiled its first two feature films. The partnership provides UMA with access to Kompas Gramedia’s media network and its 100,000 pieces of intellectual property, [...]

  • Taron Egerton Fashion

    Taron Egerton's Stylist Used Elton John as Inspiration on Press Tour

    Showstopping looks: For Taron Egerton’s “Rocketman” tour, stylist Gareth Scourfield nodded to Elton John’s iconic wardrobe with bold colors, patterns and silhouettes: “We got a bit more eccentric.” May 16 “Elton is the real original showman,” says Scourfield, who met Egerton through another client, Egerton’s “Rocketman” co-star Richard Madden. “Part of Taron as a man [...]

  • Lupita Nyong'o Us Best Actress

    Looking to Indie and Genre Performances in the Best Actress Oscar Race

    This year’s race for lead actress could yield some surprising nominations, outside of some clear front-runners including Renee Zellweger (“Judy”), Charlize Theron (“Bombshell”), and Scarlett Johansson (“Marriage Story”). It’s been a terrific year for female performances, with a wide selection of talent taking on challenging roles spread over various genres. The recent societal demand toward [...]

  • Stephen Sondheim's 'Follies' in the Works

    Stephen Sondheim's 'Follies' in the Works as a Movie From Heyday, BBC Films

    David Heyman’s Heyday Films, whose credits include “Gravity,” “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” “Marriage Story” and the Harry Potter and Fantastic Beasts franchises, and BBC Films have secured the film rights to Stephen Sondheim and James Goldman’s musical “Follies.” “Follies” will be adapted for the screen and directed by Dominic Cooke, a four-time Olivier [...]

  • Gabrielle Carteris SAG Awards

    Gabrielle Carteris Preps for 26th Annual SAG Awards

    SAG-AFTRA president Gabrielle Carteris is already looking forward to the 26th SAG Awards on Jan. 19, held in its usual location at the Shrine Auditorium in Los Angeles. “One of the best things about the SAG Awards is that it’s a peer-to-peer recognition,” she says. “It’s the highest honor for performers to be recognized by [...]

  • Robert Pattinson The Lighthouse Best Actor

    Best Actor Oscar Race Dominated by Known Faces

    In this year’s Oscar race for the lead actor prize, two of the front-runners represent a pair of films likely to duke it out for best picture: Leonardo DiCaprio, whose fading Western TV star Rick Dalton is the heart and soul of Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood,” and Robert De Niro, who [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content