You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Widowed Witch’

This year's Tiger Award winner at Rotterdam is a circuitous feminist fable, marking an imperfect but promising debut for Cai Chengjie.

Cai Chengjie
Tian Tian, Wen Xinyu, Wang Qilin

2 hours

There’s a strange blessing in being cursed, it turns out, in “The Widowed Witch,” an uneven but appealingly eccentric fable from Chinese newcomer Cai Chengjie that changes tone seemingly with the turn of the breeze. Alternating between deadpan social satire and ambiguity-riddled mysticism, this story of a serial widow who turns the superstitious suspicions of her community to her advantage nevertheless permits a clear feminist message through its tangle of styles, genres and even visual textures — as color creeps in and out of the black-and-white proceedings, seemingly in tune with the heroine’s state of mind. A well-received winner of the top prize at the Rotterdam Film Festival, Cai’s film nonetheless will be more readily embraced by further fest programmers than international distributors — for whom its opaque storytelling and heightened performance style mark it as challenging fare.

Though billed as a world premiere in Rotterdam, “The Widowed Witch” is in fact a film on its second life: It initially appeared under the title of “Shaman” at China’s independent-oriented Xining First Film Festival last summer. Despite winning top honors there, the film has reportedly since been substantially reedited — though while 20 minutes of screen time were shed in the process, the new cut still feels overly protracted at two hours.

The film’s first half, even with various sidewinding longueurs, is its liveliest, beginning with a cryptic pre-credit prologue that takes some time to settle into real-world sense. In a ravishing, full-color landscape dominated by wintry white, Erhao (Tian Tian) trudges through snowy woodland, relating a mordant tale of her complicity in a childhood tragedy, before being chased and struck down by a tambourine-wielding shaman of sorts. When she comes to, paralyzed and mute in a monochrome world, it seems the preceding scene was a mere hallucination, masking an even grimmer reality: Her injuries stem from an explosion at her illegal fireworks factory, in which her husband was killed.

Erhao has been widowed twice before in tragic circumstances, and it seems the third time is the anti-charm. She’s cold-shouldered by the other residents of her sleepy rural village, who believe her to be a witch, though that doesn’t stop her brother-in-law taking advantage of her prostrate position and raping her — another drastic tonal break, in horrifying first-person view. Though “The Widowed Witch” is spiked with droll comedy, Cai paints a predominantly ugly picture of a society threaded with patriarchal abuse, though Erhao’s acts of retaliation gain her an unexpected form of respect from the enemy: When she slaps one man in the face, he claims she has cured his stiff neck.

Coincidence? Maybe, but Erhao’s savvy enough to capitalize on her alleged powers, as the village’s menfolk swiftly rebrand her “a good witch sent to heal our suffering.” Yet what initially plays as a jaggedly witty, sidelong study of communal customs and psychoses descends into murkier territory in a less engaging second hour, which mixes is-she-or-isn’t-she supernatural musings with a streak of ashier, less accessible political allegory. Tian Tian’s consistently piercing performance gives a throughline to the film, even as its own narrative voice wavers.

If, from this point, “The Widowed Witch” becomes more chore than curio, its formal accomplishments continue to intrigue. Cai and cinematographer Jiao Feng often keep the audience at several arms’ length with their studied, sweeping long shots in conversely tight Academy ratio. Each frame rife with visual tension and detail, sometimes blushing at the edges with faint suggestions of color — a reminder of elusive hope, perhaps, in Erhao’s largely cynical existence. Even the film invites us closer, meanwhile, it finds ways to keep us squinting in scrutiny: In some scenes, faces are obscured by veils of steam, making a veritable netherworld of one woman’s everyday hell.

Film Review: 'The Widowed Witch'

Reviewed at Rotterdam Film Festival (competing), Feb. 1, 2018.

Production: (China) A Beijing Glazed Sky Prods. production. (International sales: Rediance, Beijing.) Producers: Jiao Feng, Hu Xiaotao.

Crew: Director, screenplay: Cai Chengjie. Camera (color/B&W): Jiao Feng. Editor: Li Cheng. Music: Jin Weiye, Li Qiang.

With: Tian Tian, Wen Xinyu, Wang Qilin, Wang Fuyou, Yang Shuyou, Gao Pengcheng, Li Wenfu, Zhao Shulin.

More Film

  • Nordic Film Market: New Pálmason, Hákonarson,

    Nordic Film Market Selects Latest Palmason, Hakonarson, Hafstrom, Ganslandt

    The 20th Nordic Film Market in Göteborg, unspooling Jan. 31-Feb 3, will showcase 16 works in progress including Hlynur Pálmason’s “A White, White Day”, Grímur Hákonarson’s “The County”, Mikael Håfström’s “The Perfect Patient” and Jesper Ganslandt’s “438 Days.” Iceland is well represented this year with top directors and festival darlings Pálmason (“Winter Brothers”), Hákonarson (“Rams”) [...]

  • 'All These Small Moments' Review

    Film Review: 'All These Small Moments'

    The magic of writer-director Melissa B. Miller Costanzo’s “All These Small Moments” can be found within the intimacy of the scenarios, the authenticity of her earnest characterizations, and the accessibility of the actors’ honest performances. In her deftly polished directorial debut, Costanzo dovetails the primary story about a teen’s coming of age with a secondary [...]

  • Bruce Tufeld Dead: Hollywood Agent and

    Hollywood Agent and Manager Bruce Tufeld Dies at 66

    Bruce Tufeld, a Hollywood agent and manager who once repped stars like Rob Lowe, Laura Dern, and Kelsey Grammer, died Tuesday in Los Angeles as a result of complications from liver cancer. He was 66. The son of respected television announcer Richard “Dick” Tufeld and Adrienne Tufeld, Bruce began his career as an assistant at ICM [...]

  • Bruce Dern

    Film News Roundup: Bruce Dern's 'The Lears' Bought by Vertical for February Release

    In today’s film news roundup, Bruce Dern’s “The Lears” and “Angels Are Made of Light” are acquired, Cold War drama “Stanley Cage” is launched and a documentary about Madonna’s early music career gets a release. ACQUISITIONS More Reviews Film Review: 'All These Small Moments' TV Review: HBO's 'Brexit' Vertical Entertainment has acquired North American rights [...]

  • Octavia Spencer Bryce Dallas Howard

    Octavia Spencer, Bryce Dallas Howard to Reunite for Comedy 'Fairy Tale Ending'

    Octavia Spencer and Bryce Dallas Howard will reunite for the ensemble comedy “Fairy Tale Ending.” Jim Hecht (“Ice Age: The Meltdown) and Tracy McMillan (“Marvel’s Runaways”) are writing the screenplay. More Reviews Film Review: 'All These Small Moments' TV Review: HBO's 'Brexit' Howard will also produce the Universal movie through her Nine Muses Entertainment alongside [...]

  • Robert Smith, Longtime Executive at DuArt

    Robert Smith, Longtime Executive at New York's DuArt Film Labs, Dies at 88

    Robert Smith, a longtime executive with New York’s DuArt Film Labs, died Jan. 11 in Montvale, N.J. He was 88. Smith spent some 62 years with DuArt, the film processing and post-production facility founded in 1922 in the penthouse of an automobile garage in Midtown. Smith rose to president of DuArt before retiring in 2015. [...]

  • Bird Box

    Los Angeles On-Location Feature Filming Surges 12.2% in 2018

    On-location feature filming in Greater Los Angeles expanded impressively in 2018, gaining 12.2% to 4,377 shooting days, according to FilmL.A. Production activity for feature films rose 15.5% to 1,078 shooting days during the fourth quarter, with 146 days coming from projects receiving California tax credits — including Netflix’s “Bird Box,” Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content