You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Third Murder’

Japanese family seriocomedy specialist Hirokazu Kore-eda shifts gears to mixed results with a talky legal investigative drama.

Hirokazu Kore-eda

2 hours 5 minutes

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt6410564/reference

It was probably time for Hirokazu Kore-eda to take a break from the tender seriocomedies about parents and children that have occupied his last decade, given that 2016’s “After the Storm” was a good film — yet also the least of his efforts in that terrain. Still, even those who pine for the chillier tenor and themes of earlier features (like “Nobody Knows,” “Distance” and “After Life”) are likely to greet “The Third Murder” with mixed emotions. This entirely dialogue-driven drama focuses on a mid-career lawyer whose jaded professionalism is shaken when he takes on a client charged with homicide but whose story seems to change with every telling.

Trouble is, that confessional “truth” changes so many times we cease to care what it might turn out to be — and in any case, Kore-eda leaves “whodunit” (let alone why) unanswered here. Ambiguity can be powerful in a mystery, yet “Murder’s” somewhat ponderously literal-minded attention to legal procedure makes that aspect less potent in itself, while the limited psychological insights we get aren’t terribly interesting. Compelling enough while you’re watching it, frustrating then forgettable once it ends, this is a work that wouldn’t command much attention if it came from any other director. Coming from this one, it mostly intrigues as an unexpected if not terribly rewarding change of pace.

After a brief, discreet opening glimpse of the crime in question — one repeated later with key variations, none of which may reflect whatever “really” happened — we meet defense attorney Shigemori (Masaharu Fukuyama), who’s unhappy to be dragged by his older law-practice partner Settsu (Kotaro Yoshida) into a case well in progress. The reason is that older factory worker Misumi (Koji Yakusho) is proving a particularly problematic client: Though he’s confessed to the police, he keeps changing his account of the circumstances that led to his killing the boss who’d fired him for theft.

Popular on Variety

Misumi certainly seems guilty, having already served one long prison sentence for two long-ago murders, and being in need of money to cover purported gambling debts. Yet he exasperates his counsel by “forgetting” or contradicting what he’s said, then making confounding new claims. Is he simply a dim bulb who can’t keep his own story straight? Is he deliberately toying with them out of sheer maliciousness? Or is he trying to hide someone else’s guilt?

Though Shigemori jadedly professes not to care what the actual truth is — the only important thing, he tells a younger colleague, is what works as legal strategy — he nonetheless finds himself in pursuit of just that. His inquiries lead him to try tracking down Misumi’s long-estranged daughter, as well as interviewing the victim’s wife and child. But eventually it appears that the latter two may have, for separate reasons, been involved in the murder. Then there’s the matter of worker exploitation and corrupt business practices at the factory. All the while, with the death penalty hanging in the balance, Misumi keeps revising his narrative, seeming a hapless ne’er-do-well one minute and a Machiavellian schemer the next.

The intricate nature of Kore-eda’s script pulls one along to a considerable degree — there’s hardly 30 seconds here that can be safely ignored without missing some potentially significant new plot wrinkle. But there’s also a dull monotony to a film so entirely driven by verbal testimony, even if the writer-director manages to keep us out of the courtroom proper for the majority of “Murder.” Still, nearly everything here is a matter of interview (with Misumi in prison and witnesses elsewhere) or discussion between lawyers, with flashbacks, dream sequences, etc., providing infrequent and somewhat labored diversion.

Kore-eda has said his primary intent was to “depict the job of a lawyer properly.” But the persnickety attention expended on that is unlikely to gratify viewers not acquainted with the specifics of the Japanese legal and judicial systems. And by using a murder mystery as plot hook, the film inevitably leads us to expect a conventional resolution whose absence irks in this very procedural, somewhat stylistically drab context.

There emerges an attempt at a more accessibly human emotional thread involving paternal guilt: Not only does Misumi lament being a bad/absent father, but divorced Shigemori neglects his own troubled daughter, and the murdered boss’s teenage offspring (Suzu Hirose) turns out to be another kind of victim whose relationship with the killer has its own mysteries. But these elements end up seeming a desultory rehash of Kore-eda’s usual thematic focus on parent-child dysfunction.

Though very well acted by an impressive cast, “The Third Murder” is in the final analysis neither fish nor fowl — a dense puzzle without solution that doesn’t quite make a virtue of being an enigma. It’s hard to imagine Kore-eda making a flat-out abysmal failure, and this certainly isn’t that. But he’s clearly expended a great deal of thought on a project that ultimately feels like an arid experiment, one that leaves little lasting impression as drama, art or intellectual inquiry.

Film Review: 'The Third Murder'

Reviewed at Palm Springs Film Festival (Modern Masters), Jan. 12, 2018. (Also in Venice, Toronto festivals.) Running time: 125 MIN. (Original title: “Sandome no Satsujin.”)

Production: (Japan) A Film Movement release (U.S.) of a Fuji Television Network, Amuse Inc. and Gaga Corp. production. (International sales: Wild Bunch, Paris.) Producer: Kaoru Matsuzaki, Hijiri Taguchi.

Crew: Director, writer: Hirokazu Kore-eda. Camera (color, widescreen, HD): Mikiya Takimoto. Editor: Kore-eda. Music: Ludovico Einaudi.

With: Masaharu Fukuyama, Koji Yakusho, Suzu Hirose, Yoshida Kotaro, Shinnosuke Misushima, Isao Hashizume, Mikako Ichikawa, Izumi Matsuoka, Yuki Saito.

More Film

  • Robert De Niro, Martin Scorsese and

    Film News Roundup: Leonardo DiCaprio Presenting Robert De Niro SAG Life Achievement Award

    In today’s film news roundup, Leonardo DiCaprio will present Robert De Niro with his SAG Life Achievement Award, the Oliver Sacks documentary finds a home and UCLA’s School of Theater, Film and Television gets a new dean. AWARD PRESENTATION Leonardo DiCaprio has been selected to present Robert De Niro the SAG Life Achievement Award  at [...]


    ‘Karnawal,’ ‘Restless,’ ‘Summer White,’ ‘Firsts’ Win Big at Ventana Sur

    BUENOS AIRES  — With Ventana Sur now firing on multiple cylinders, featuring pix-in post or project competitions for not only art films but also genre pics and animation – two sectors embraced by young creators in Latin America – “Karnawal,” “Restless,” “Summer White” and  “Firsts” proved big winners among Ventana Sur’s arthouse and animation competitions, [...]

  • (center) George MacKay as Schofield in

    From "1917" to "Jojo Rabbit," Composers of Some of the Year's Top Scores Talk Shop

    “1917,” Thomas Newman The 20-year collaboration of director Sam Mendes and composer Thomas Newman has encompassed midlife crisis (“American Beauty”), crime in the Depression (“Road to Perdition”), the Gulf War (“Jarhead”), marriage in the 1950s (“Revolutionary Road”) and two James Bond adventures (“Skyfall,” “Spectre”). Now they’ve tackled World War I, with “1917,” but Mendes’ much-talked-about [...]

  • Billy Magnussen Aladdin

    'Aladdin' Spinoff With Billy Magnussen's Character in the Works for Disney Plus

    Disney is developing a spinoff of its live-action “Aladdin” with Billy Magnussen reprising his Prince Anders character. The unnamed project is in early development for the studio’s recently launched Disney Plus streaming service. Disney has hired Jordan Dunn and Michael Kvamme to write a script centered on the haughty Prince Anders, one of Princess Jasmine’s [...]

  • ROAD TRIP – In Disney and

    Disney Boasts a Bevy of Hopefuls for Oscar's Original Song Race

    When the Academy announces its shortlist for song nominations on Dec. 16, you can be certain that at least one Disney song will be on it and probably more. Disney songs have been nominated 33 times in the past 30 years, winning 12 of the gold statuettes. This year, the studio has at least four [...]

  • Innovative Scores Elevated the Year's Documentaries

    Innovative Scores Elevated the Year's Documentaries

    It’s next to impossible for a documentary score to be Oscar-nominated alongside the dozens of fictional narratives entered each year. But it did happen, just once: In 1975, composer Gerald Fried was nominated for his music for “Birds Do It, Bees Do It,” a documentary on the mating habits of animals. Fried, now 91, perhaps [...]

  • Ron Leibman, Jessica Walter'Mary Stuart' Play

    Ron Leibman, Tony-Winning Actor Known for 'Angels in America' and 'Friends,' Dies at 82

    Ron Leibman, an Emmy-winning actor who garnered a Tony for his work in Broadway’s “Angels in America” and played the father of Jennifer Aniston’s Rachel Green on “Friends,” died on Friday. He was 82. Robert Attermann, CEO of Abrams Artists Agency, confirmed the news to Variety. No further details were immediately available. Leibman, a native [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content