You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Peacemaker’

A globe-trotting political negotiator hits the world's trouble spots, but the fascination of this doc is that he's brokering peace with his own demons.

James Demo
Padraig O’Malley.
Release Date:
Feb 9, 2018

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt6140144/

Padraig O’Malley, the backroom world-trouble-spot negotiator who’s the title figure of James Demo’s documentary “The Peacemaker,” is a man engaged in a mission so arduous and noble that just hearing about it can put you in an earnest school daze. O’Malley travels around the globe, staging conferences in which he brokers dialogue between the feuding factions of places like Bosnia and Israel and South Africa and Iraq. His approach is therapeutic: Instead of having the two sides of a dispute lock horns and debate their fatal differences, he encourages them to sit down and schmooze; he gets them to humanize each other. (He first attempted this 40 years ago, in response to the cataclysm of the Irish conflict, and lo and behold, it worked.)

In no way does it trivialize the importance of these international upheavals to say that when “The Peacemaker” shows us O’Malley seated at the conference table, surrounded by 20 bureaucratic factional representatives who have agreed, for the moment, to leave aside their rancor, the film generates all the dynamism of a C-SPAN seminar.

What brings a documentary like this one to life is a central character with something going on that’s thornier than his official idealism. Fortunately, that’s Padraig O’Malley. He’s a haunted, contradictory character, to the point that he isn’t just more fascinating than the conflicts he’s trying to solve. The more we get to know him, the more his core motivation — is he an idealist or something else? — becomes the mystery of the film.

O’Malley, now 75, is tall, gaunt, and impressive, a grizzled handsome upstart with a face so dour it can seem possessed. He’s like a James Cromwell character, nursing hidden brooding depths. We learn, early on, that he’s a recovering alcoholic, 13 years sober, and though we see him at an AA meeting, sharing and withholding at the same time, the tales of his drinking trickle into the film only gradually. He has lived, since the early ’70s, in Cambridge, Mass., where he originally came to study economics at Harvard. But he bet his $10,000 Fulbright Scholarship on the 1971 Ali–Frazier fight, and lost. His university became The Plough and Stars, the fabled local tavern, halfway down Mass. Ave. between Harvard and M.I.T., where he drank away his life for decades.

O’Malley describes the entire period as a semi-blackout, dotted with girlfriends and misadventures. But the drinking turned out to be an ironic entry point into what would become his mission.

In 1975, he organized a conference in Amherst with representatives of every faction of the Irish struggle. He brought them to the table, but just as important he brought them to the bar. The drinking was extensive (O’Malley, even in sobriety, claims that if it hadn’t been for the alcohol, he couldn’t have bonded with the participants the way he did), and it introduced what might be called the hangover school of political negotiation. By the end of the conference, says O’Malley, everyone was so worn out from all the boozing that “if you had a Valium and split it with someone, they’d be your friend for life.”

He’s being cheeky, but also not. That conference proved to be a brick in the road toward the fragile peace accord that the Irish have now achieved. And O’Malley was on his way as a negotiator. He’d found his calling. He was shrewd enough to buy a stake in The Plough and Stars, as well as the building that housed it, and that’s how he has financed his missions ever since. But lest the irony of a pub fueling world peace sound incidental, O’Malley admits that his role as a mediator is, in itself, an addiction. That’s where “The Peacemaker” gets into interesting but morally murky terrain.

The movie follows O’Malley around, flashes old photographs of him back when he was a strapping, bushy-haired figure with the glow of a political star (he wore his hangovers well), and gets him to confess some of the things he’s running away from. O’Malley says that if he stops working for so much as three or four hours at a time, “I start to suffer from withdrawal symptoms.” He has a foster daughter, born in Africa, he sees for one month out of the year, but he says that he loves no one; he lives for the work, and admits that it’s a ritualized form of self-denial. Intriguingly, he has conceived his floating Forum for Cities in Transition as a kind of 12-step program for beleaguered nations. “Just as an alcoholic is in the best position to help another,” he says, “one divided society is in the best position to help another.”

But is that really true? O’Malley has had moments of success — with the Irish conflict, which he knows in his Celtic bones, and in the 2008 Helsinki talks he led about the morass in Iraq. And no one should begrudge any of that. Yet by the end of “The Peacemaker,” the film raises, almost inadvertently, an uncomfortable question: Is O’Malley’s work, for the most part, accomplishing something that’s largely symbolic, because the ultimate purpose of the work is to fill the void in Padraig O’Malley’s soul?

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'The Peacemaker'

Reviewed on-line, Feb. 8, 2018. MPAA Rating: Not rated. Running time: 90 MIN.

Production: A Central Square Films release of a Principle Pictures, Film Independent, HotDocs Forum, LEF, Sundance Institute, JustFilms Ford Foundation, Open Society Foundations, Points North Documentary Film Forum, IFP, Open Society Foundations, Garrett Scott Documentary Development Grant, Tribeca Film Institute production. Producer: James Demo. Executive producers: Stephen Nemeth, Beth Murphy.

Crew: Director: James Demo. Camera (color, widescreen): Beth Balaban, Kevin Belli, James Demo, Mike Hechanova, Sarah Levy. Editor: Erin Casper.

With: Padraig O’Malley.

More Film

  • Film director and scriptwriter Vojtech Jasny

    Vojtech Jasny, Award-Winning Czech Filmmaker, Dies at 93

    Czech filmmaker Vojtech Jasny, director of “All My Good Countrymen,” which won the best director prize at Cannes in 1969, has died. He was 93. According to the Associated Press, Slovacke divadlo, a theatre he frequently visited, said that Jasny died Friday, and a family representative confirmed his death to the CTK news agency. Jasny [...]

  • Noelle Anna Kendrick

    Film Review: 'Noelle' on Disney Plus

    What do you get when you toss together Christmas cheer, Christmas kitsch, a fish-out-of-the-North-Pole setup swiped from “Elf,” and a plot that turns on whether Kris Kringle’s daughter, played as a perky naïf by Anna Kendrick, has what it takes to step into her dad’s snow boots? You get a plastic icicle like “Noelle,” Long [...]

  • Scandalous

    Film Review: 'Scandalous: The Untold Story of the National Enquirer'

    When grocery store shoppers snag a copy of Weekly World News (the rag responsible for the refuses-to-die “Bat Child” hoax), they know they’re getting fake news. But when they pick up the National Enquirer, it’s a far more ambiguous prospect. Enquirer headlines are deliberately provocative, shouting details of the private lives of real people — [...]

  • Cynthia Erivo

    Cynthia Erivo Almost Gave Up Singing to Become a Spinal Surgeon

    Before Cynthia Erivo went on to become a Tony and Grammy winner, she nearly gave up singing to be a spinal surgeon. In her “Variety Studio: Actors on Actors” conversation with Alfre Woodard, the “Harriet” star said she had been singing since she was toddler. Her mother noticed she’d hum while eating her food when [...]

  • Alfre Woodard Cynthia Erivo Variety Actors

    How Cynthia Erivo and Alfre Woodard Found Deeper Meaning in ‘Harriet’ and ‘Clemency’

    Cynthia Erivo (“Harriet”) and Alfre Woodard (“Clemency”) sat down for a chat for “Variety Studio: Actors on Actors.” For more, click here. Cynthia Erivo and Alfre Woodard are at the forefront of this year’s awards conversation for two prestige films directed by black women. In Chinonye Chukwu’s “Clemency,” a movie that won the Sundance Grand [...]

  • Rocketman Taron Egerton

    'Rocketman' Hair and Make-Up Artist Talks Transforming Taron Egerton

    Hair and make-up artist Lizzie Yianni-Georgiou sums up “Rocketman” as the story “of a great icon who hits rock bottom. You see the great things happen and he hits rock bottom. By the end, he’s pulled himself together and he’s still standing.” For the viewer, it’s a rollercoaster ride of emotion, but as Yianni-Georgiou says, [...]


    Box Office: 'Ford v Ferrari' Dashing to No. 1 While 'Charlie's Angels' Flounders

    Christian Bale and Matt Damon’s racing drama “Ford v Ferrari” is set to win the weekend box office by a long shot with an esimated $29 million from 3,528 domestic locations. Elizabeth Banks’ “Charlie’s Angels” reboot could land in a distant second in its debut weekend with about $8.2 million, but the second frame of [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content