Film Review: ‘The Judge’

Erika Cohn’s documentary is a welcome femme-empowered portrait of an inspirational female Shari’a judge in Palestine.

Erika Cohn
Kholoud Al-Faqih, Sheikh Tayseer Al-Tamimi, Husam Al-Deen Afanah, Yaqoub Shawwa, Imad Ahmad, Reema Shamasneh, Hanan Ashrawi, Tahreer Hammad, Dareen Salhiyeh, Sumayya Irhaimeh, Mustafa Shrateh, Bilal Barghouthi. (Arabic, English dialogue)

1 hour 22 minutes

There are scandalously few female-empowerment documentaries about Arab women that also aim to counter Islamophobia, which is why Erika Cohn’s “The Judge” is a welcome addition. What’s more, it’s impossible not to be impressed by Kholoud Al-Faqih, the arbiter of the title, who together with a colleague became the first female judges in Palestine’s Shari’a courts. Frustratingly however, Cohn’s understandable desire to praise her subject seems to have led her to muddy the timeline of events and downplay the existence of Faqih’s women colleagues. Greater attention to how and when information is revealed would make “The Judge” a far more valuable film, though given the subject’s topicality, there’s every expectation that media attention will be high following its late-April opening.

Women have been judges for criminal cases in Palestine since the 1970s, but Islamic scholars refused to countenance a female judge in the Shari’a courts, where family cases are heard. Enter Faqih, an attorney working with victims of domestic violence, who petitioned the chief justice, Sheikh Tayseer Al-Tamimi, to open the ranks. Arguing that the Hanafi school of Islam doesn’t forbid women from running Shari’a courts, Faqih won Tamimi over, and in 2009 she and Asmahan Al-Wahidi were given positions on the bench.

As with any such revolution, not everyone was pleased. Cohn interviews conservative Islamic scholar Husam Al-Deen Afanah, an outspoken critic explicit in his denunciation of Tamimi’s action, who refuses to accept the Sheikh’s claim that hidebound tradition has blurred the more liberal essence of Shari’a law. While Afanah’s authority holds weight, the prejudice against women in juridical positions goes far beyond one scholar’s rigid pronouncements: Attorneys as well as people on the street (both women and men) largely express the opinion that women are too emotional to be impartial judges (the same argument used in the West a century ago to deny women the vote).

It shouldn’t go without comment that Cohn largely sidelines educated middle-class voices: Her on-the-street interviewees almost all offer parochial opinions about the fitness of women to become judges, contradicting Hanan Ashrawi’s assertion that Palestine long became one of the most forward-thinking societies in the region. It’s unlikely Cohn meant to challenge Ashrawi on this; stacking the deck to build a larger case for community prejudice simply makes the documentary battle lines more exciting.

Tamimi was forced to resign one year after appointing Faqih and Wahidi (the latter never appears on-screen), with the implication that his revolutionary support for these women led to his departure — although he remains an important judicial voice in Palestine. The chief justice who followed, Yousef Al-Dais, appears to have been far less enlightened, sidelining the two female judges by removing their caseloads and reducing them to administrative and contractual work. “It’s a living hell” remarks Faqih, suddenly denied the satisfaction of making a positive difference in women’s lives. Not until 2016 were the women judges able to resume juridical duties, under a new chief justice. Does that mean Faqih had only a desk job for five years?

It’s precisely because “The Judge” succeeds so well in presenting Faqih as an inspirational role model that the corner-cutting of information is so aggravating. Happily, Faqih’s personality shines through: wise and warm-hearted, firm when necessary, generous of spirit, a loving wife and mother of four who somehow manages to balance it all. Her insistence on the necessity of educating Palestinian women about their rights deserves every accolade and award, and the film is at its best when showing her at work, counselling and occasionally cajoling the plaintiffs before the bench. Refreshingly, Cohn shows off the beauty of Palestine’s landscape, though given what a good job she does in presenting an enlightened Islam, it’s a shame that troubling music is paired with a scene of Al-Tamimi at prayer.

Film Review: 'The Judge'

Reviewed online, Rome, April 5, 2018 (In Toronto Film Festival; IDFA.) 82 MIN.

Production: (Documentary) An Idle Wild Films production, in association with ITVS. (International sales: Ro*co Films Intl., Sausalito.) Producer: Erika Cohn. Executive producers: Geralyn Dreyfous, Diana Lady Dougan, Barbara Dobkin, Patty Quillin, Sally Jo Fifer, Lois Vossen. Co-producers: Jennifer Jordan, Sara Maamouri, Amber Fares, Mark Lipson.

Crew: Director, writer: Erika Cohn. Camera (color): Amber Fares. Editors: Sara Maamouri, Ken Schneider. Music: Omar Fadel.

With: Kholoud Al-Faqih, Sheikh Tayseer Al-Tamimi, Husam Al-Deen Afanah, Yaqoub Shawwa, Imad Ahmad, Reema Shamasneh, Hanan Ashrawi, Tahreer Hammad, Dareen Salhiyeh, Sumayya Irhaimeh, Mustafa Shrateh, Bilal Barghouthi. (Arabic, English dialogue)

More Film

  • Nona

    Film Review: 'Nona'

    Twenty years and 12 features down the line, it’s still hard to peg the directorial sensibility of Michael Polish, with or without the presence of brother Mark as frequent co-writer and actor. His output has been all over the place, from early Lynchian quirkfests to the very middle-of-the-road inspirational dramedy “The Astronaut Farmer,” not to [...]

  • Pawel Pawlikowski "Cold War"

    Pawel Pawlikowski's 'Cold War' Wins for Best Film, Director at European Film Awards

    “Cold War,” Pawel Pawlikowski’s black-and-white romance set in the 1950s, scooped the prizes for best film, director and screenplay at the 31st edition of the European Film Awards on Saturday. “Cold War” star Joanna Kulig also won the award for best actress. Marcello Fonte, the star of Matteo Garrone’s “Dogman,” won for best actor. More Reviews [...]

  • The Favourite Bohemian Rapsody Star is

    The Best Movie Scenes of 2018

    When we think back on a movie that transported us, we often focus on a great scene — or maybe the greatest scene — in it. It’s natural. Those scenes are more than just defining. They can be the moment that lifts a movie into the stratosphere, that takes it to the higher reaches of [...]

  • Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

    Box Office: 'Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse' Soars Toward $35-40 Million Debut

    “Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse” is swinging into theaters on a high note. Sony-Marvel’s latest output is launching to $42 million from 3,813 North American locations in its debut, though other more conservative estimates place that number at $35.5 million. The animated superhero story picked up $12.6 million on Friday, easily leading the pack for the weekend. [...]

  • Ventana Sur : Cinema226 Closes Four

    Cinema226 Announces Four Intl. Co-Productions, Hints at More (EXCLUSIVE)

    Mexico’s Cinema226, run by Marco Antonio Salgado and Sam Guillén, is driving into a raft of Mexico, Argentina and Spain co-productions, playing off the current vibrancy of Mexican film production funding and distribution outlets. Among the projects are titles which have been standouts at Ventana Sur’s Blood Window, the next film by Mexico-based Argentine filmmaker [...]

  • Ventana Sur Debates Gender Parity in

    Ventana Sur Debates Gender’s 50/50 in 2020 for Argentina Film Industry

    BUENOS AIRES — Despite recent gains, namely the equality pledge towards 50/50-2020 signed at the Mar del Plata Film Festival on Nov. 12, producer Magalí Nieva, pointed out that no representative from INCAA was present following the apparent resignation of its vice-president Fernando Juan Lima. “We are left without an interlocutor to discuss gender policies [...]

  • Ventana Sur Rocks with Sales, Mass

    Ventana Sur Rocks with Sales, Mass Attendance, Structural Growth

    BUENOS AIRES — Celebrating its 10th anniversary with a huge hike in attendance to over 4,000 accredited delegates, the 2018 Ventana Sur will go down in history on multiple counts: Sales and pick-ups on movies which combined social comment and entertainment value, increasingly the new foreign-language movie standard; new sections, led by a Proyecta co-production [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content