×

Toronto Film Review: ‘The Elephant Queen’

This soft-hearted nature doc often doesn't jive with life-threatening issues as it tracks an elephant herd across the African savannah.

Director:
Victoria Stone, Mark Deeble
With:
Narrator: Chiwetel Ejiofor.

1 hour 36 minutes

In the grand, hoary tradition of Disney nature documentaries, “The Elephant Queen” presents the plight of African pachyderms as a story with heartrending characters and traditional narrative arcs — the circle of life examined over a year on the savannah. “Oh wise and gentle soul,” begins Chiwetel Ejiofor’s voiceover, like the hushed dialectic of a Terrence Malick film, referring to the giant-tusked, 50-year-old matriarch who leads her family through perils both ancient and climate-influenced. There’s no denying the emotional pull of Victoria Stone and Mark Deeble’s storytelling or the vivid rapture of the images, but “The Elephant Queen” adheres too closely to the parameters of family-friendly nature docs, and the formula doesn’t always serve it well.

The wise and gentle soul in question is named Athena, who learned how to survive from her elders but faces additional challenges due to the scarcities of a changing landscape. “Do you remember when we had it all?” asks Ejiofor, as if channeling a message from her ancestors, who perhaps didn’t have to manage the twin threats of poachers and extended droughts. When “The Elephant Queen” opens, however, Athena and her herd do seem to have it all, splashing around the watering holes they’ve dug out in anticipation of a nourishing rainstorm. In these happy times, the film takes the opportunity to introduce the playful youngsters in Athena’s herd, like the “naughty” Wei-Wei and Mimi, a newborn that struggles to keep up with the rest.

There are side characters in the elephant’s world, too, who rely on the same ecological phenomena to continue their species. Foam frogs create tadpoles out of cotton-candy nests that, in turn, feed the tiny fish that populate the waterholes while they last. Egyptian geese nurture their chicks for two months before they leave the perch, though one, a cute little straggler named Steven, needs some luck to stay close to his parents. There are tortoises, too, and dung beetles that scrap over a bounty of elephant droppings before the winner arduously tucks a sample into the soft earth for later use. In this early section of the film, Stone and Deeble delight in animals at play in an environment of sun-kissed fertility and balance. 

Popular on Variety

Then comes the dry season. It’s entirely expected that Athena and her herd have a journey ahead of them after the water dries up; in fact, there are paths that have been laid out by generations of giant-huskers between their home territory and the refuge they seek. But when the dry season becomes an out-and-out drought, Athena has to make difficult choices that risk starvation on one hand and dehydration on the other. Either way, the calves might run out of mother’s milk and not survive. “The Elephant Queen” respects the burden of these decisions and their consequences even while it’s guilty of anthropomorphizing the melancholy and grief of these animals as hardships pile up, thus projecting emotions onto its “characters” that are better left for the audience to feel.

At least Stone and Deeble have the footage to support their narrative. Deeble, the credited cinematographer, gets spectacularly intimate and beautiful shots of the elephants and their animal friends. The film is at its best when it lays out the entire ecosystem species by species, each relying on the other in a delicate chain of life, death, verdancy and sustenance. Without saying as much, Stone and Debble suggest the essentials of survival and how the threat to elephants like Athena can devastate other animals down the chain. A dung beetle needs dung, after all. 

Yet “The Elephant Queen” curiously underplays the mortal threat facing Athena and her ilk. For all the mellifluousness of Ejiofor’s narration, the words “climate change” never come up, much less a more substantive overview of the challenges facing giant-tusked elephants now and in the future. Stone and Deeble cover some heartbreaking moments, but they’re made to seem like anomalous events rather than a more permanent obstacle. These omissions become especially untenable in the closing credits, which deliver some disquieting news that the film itself seems too soft-hearted to reveal. There’s a gap between the story Stone and Deeble want to tell about love and family, and the much grimmer story nature itself is telling, in unsentimental terms. In the end, it’s hard to reconcile the two. 

Toronto Film Review: 'The Elephant Queen'

Reviewed at Toronto Film Festival (TIFF Docs), Sept. 11, 2018. Running time: 96 MIN.

Production: (Documentary — U.K.-Kenya) An Apple release of a Mister Smith Entertainment, Deeble & Stone production. Producers: Lucinda Englehart, Victoria Stone. Executive producers: Alan Root Obe, Sara Williams, Nick Williams.

Crew: Directors: Victoria Stone, Mark Deeble. Screenplay: Deeble. Camera (color, widescreen): Deeble. Editor: David Dickie. Music: Alex Heffes.

With: Narrator: Chiwetel Ejiofor.

More Film

  • 'Charlatan' Review: Agnieszka Holland Shows Faith

    'Charlatan': Film Review

    At several points in “Charlatan,” the camera looks glossily on as our protagonist holds small bottles of amber liquid to the light, academically scrutinizing their contents as they beam a light golden glow onto his features: an effect both ennobling and almost romantic. The man is Jan Mikolášek, a famous Czech herbalist and healer with [...]

  • Toho Cinemas at Tokyo Midtown Hibiya

    Japanese Cinemas To Refund Tickets in Virus Response

    In response to the coronavirus crisis, the Japanese film industry has begun to delay releases, close theaters and refund ticket purchases. The releases of the new “Doraemon” and “Jimaro” feature animations targeted at kids out of school for the spring break, have been delayed. The former was scheduled to open March 6, the latter on [...]

  • Blood on Her Name

    Film Review: ‘Blood on Her Name’

    In the opening moments of “Blood on Her Name,” an arrestingly twisty and suspenseful Southern noir thriller in the tradition of “One False Move,” we’re introduced to Leigh, the working-class protagonist played by Bethany Anne Lind, with a jarring close-up that is at once explicit and ambiguous. Her face is battered, her breathing is labored, [...]

  • Liev Schreiber Broadway

    Film News Roundup: Liev Schreiber Joins Will Smith's Tennis Drama 'King Richard'

    In today’s film news roundup, Liev Schreiber and retired pro footballer Vernon Davis score roles, Jason Blum will speak at his alma mater, Irish drama “Rialto” finds a U.S. distributor and “1917” hits a box office milestone. CASTINGS Liev Schreiber will portray tennis coach Paul Cohen in Warner Bros.’ “King Richard” opposite Will Smith. Popular [...]

  • AMC theater

    AMC Entertainment Reports Mixed Fourth-Quarter Results

    AMC Entertainment has reported mixed fourth-quarter results, which saw revenues rise 2.4% to $1.45 billion, despite a 4.4% drop in U.S. attendance to 62.3 million. The exhibitor, owned by Dalian Wanda Group, announced a fourth-quarter loss of $13.5 million, compared to a year-earlier profit of $170.6 million, due to $84.3 million of expense related to [...]

  • 'Straight Up' Review: James Sweeney's Gay

    'Straight Up': Film Review

    There’s a tradition in movies, as vital as a hypnotic action scene or a swooning love scene, of dialogue so witty and nimble and rapid-fire that it comes at you like something out of a stylized dream. I first encountered that brand of high-velocity verbal jousting in “A Hard Day’s Night,” and later on in [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content