You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Darkest Minds’

'Kung Fu Panda 2' director Jennifer Yuh Nelson adapts nicely to the world of live action, though she should have picked a less derivative project than this generic YA movie about kids with special powers.

Jennifer Yuh Nelson
Amandla Stenberg, Mandy Moore, Bradley Whitford
Release Date:
Aug 3, 2018

Rated PG-13  1 hour 44 minutes

Official Site: https://www.thedarkestminds.com/

A disease that wipes out 98% of the world’s children. Government roundups that send the survivors to concentration-camp-like rehabilitation facilities. Heavily armed “tracers” tasked with hunting down the few who manage to escape. Despite its PG-13 rating, “The Darkest Minds” would have been one of the darkest teen fantasy thrillers ever made — if not for all the other dark teen fantasy thrillers out there these days.

What once seemed daring (say, back when the original “Red Dawn” came out, pitting kids against threatening, heavily armed adults) has become the default template for young adult fiction and, by extension, for the woefully predictable film adaptations that hope to turn these supernatural-kids-misunderstood-by-the-world stories into the next hot franchise. Based on the first book in Alexandra Bracken’s young adult trilogy and directed by “Kung Fu Panda 2” helmer Jennifer Yuh Nelson, this relatively intense adolescent-focused action movie borrows nearly all its ingredients from other popular sci-fi franchises — from “X-Men” to “Stranger Things” — and doesn’t much seem to mind if kids recognize how derivative it is (at one point, the two romantic leads talk about how they feel like characters in a Harry Potter movie).

No doubt, the only thing more depressing than how many of these cookie-cutter novels find their way into print is the sheer number of rejected manuscripts for the same that have been piling up on editors’ desks in the years since J.K. Rowling coined the word “Muggles.” In this case, the movie’s not bad, but neither is it particularly original, casting an actress from another series — Amandla Stenberg of “The Hunger Games” — as Ruby Daly, a 16-year-old with abilities she doesn’t yet know how to control.

An exposition-heavy prologue establishes an outbreak of a highly contagious disease called IAAN, or Idiopathic Adolescent Acute Neurodegeneration, that targets only children. Ruby is eating lunch in the school cafeteria when a classmate starts shaking uncontrollably, then falls to the floor dead. According to news reports, the same thing swiftly happened to nearly all the minors on Earth — a super dark premise that would be truly nightmare-inducing if depicted — leaving only a small number of survivors, among them the president’s son, Clancy Gray (Patrick Gibson).

Are no more children born from this point forward? How do parents feel about losing their kids? Would they really permit authorities to separate and execute the survivors? (Bracken’s story clearly takes place in an alternate reality from the one in which citizens protest Trump’s immigrant child detention facilities.) And why do the survivors suddenly develop special abilities, ranging from telekinesis to mind control?

Only the last question seems to matter as the movie steamrolls forward, ignoring how such a cataclysm might affect the rest of the world’s population, and focusing instead on what happens to Ruby, who wakes up one morning to find that her parents no longer recognize her — another one of those ideas that, if played more menacingly, might scar young viewers. Taken captive by authorities and sent to a work camp, Ruby discovers that she can influence other people’s actions (à la Obi-Wan Kenobi’s “These aren’t the droids you’re looking for” trick). That makes her highly dangerous in the minds of the authorities, who have color-coded the surviving kids according to their abilities — she is Orange, superseded only by the lethal pyromaniacal Reds.

Lucky for Ruby, she has an ally in a seemingly concerned doctor named Cate (Mandy Moore), who breaks her out of jail and appears to have a mysterious agenda of her own. For understandable reasons, Ruby doesn’t trust Cate or any other adult, finding a way to sneak away with a trio of renegade teenagers, each of whom represents another color — and who collectively diversify the mix of races and genders featured: There’s Zu (Miya Cech), a young Asian-American Amber who can harness electricity, and who wears yellow kitchen gloves over her hands; smarty Chubs (Skylan Brooks) is a Green, an African-American super-brain who helps the crew make plans and solve puzzles; and the oldest is Liam (Harris Dickinson), a white Blue capable of moving objects with his mind — and of stirring Ruby’s affections with his dopey-cute attempts at courtship.

Nelson and screenwriter Chad Hodge want to orchestrate one of those semi-tragic teen love stories for the ages, investing a disproportionate amount of time in a romantic subplot that feels like excess baggage in what may as well be a war movie featuring kids. The confrontations are relatively small, although “The Darkest Minds” features a disturbing flashback in which armed guards gun down entire crowds of children and climaxes in a full-blown battle that somewhat startlingly claims the lives of dozens of kids and adults alike, while leaving the key characters alive to fight another day.

Keep in mind that the book on which “The Darkest Minds” was based kicks off a series, and Nelson’s film version has the feel of a promising TV pilot, setting up more than it resolves. The final image of the movie — a child’s hand held high in warring defiance of a villain we still don’t quite understand — isn’t so much a cliff-hanger as a “dot dot dot” for a sequel that will never get made, trailing off into the dustbin alongside such open-ended fantasy movies as “City of Ember,” “Ender’s Game,” and “The Golden Compass.”

Although “Divergent” and “The Maze Runner” are the more obvious points of comparison, this mixed-race, believe-in-yourself parable bears no small resemblance to Disney’s far bigger-budgeted “A Wrinkle in Time” from a few months back — and believe it or not, this is the better movie. Unlike so many somber-toned YA franchises, which go dark in hopes of snaring a wider audience, “The Darkest Minds” seems to be aimed squarely at teens. Without watering down the action, Nelson soft-pedals the most disturbing ideas in such a way that young audiences won’t be overwhelmed with gloom, instead inviting them to identify with the film’s empowered female heroine as she struggles to overcome her crippling lack of self-confidence and embrace what makes her special.

Film Review: 'The Darkest Minds'

Reviewed at Fox studios, Los Angeles, July 30, 2018. MPAA Rating: PG-13. Running time: 104 MIN.

Production: A 20th Century Fox release and presentation of a 21 Laps production. Producers: Shawn Levy, Dan Levine. Executive producers: Dan Cohen, John H. Starke.

Crew: Director: Jennifer Yuh Nelson. Screenplay: Chad Hodge, based on the novel by Alexandra Bracken. Camera (color, widescreen): Kramer Morgenthau. Editors: Maryann Brandon, Dean Zimmerman. Music: Benjamin Wallfisch.

With: Amandla Stenberg, Mandy Moore, Bradley Whitford, Harris Dickinson, Patrick Gibson, Skylan Brooks, Miya Cech, Lidya Jewett, Gwendoline Christie.

More Film

  • Oscar Nomination for Short Film 'Detainment'

    Oscar Nomination for Short Film 'Detainment' Sparks Backlash in Britain

    Oscar-nominated short film “Detainment,” about a notorious real-life child abduction and murder, has sparked outrage in Britain from the victim’s mother and from thousands of petitioners demanding that the Academy Award nod be rescinded. The 30-minute film centers on the 1993 killing of 2-year-old James Bulger, one of the most shocking criminal cases in modern British [...]

  • Alfonso Cuaron's 'Roma' Companion Album to

    Alfonso Cuarón's New 'Roma' Album to Feature Beck, Patti Smith, El-P, T Bone Burnett

    Not to be outdone by Ariana Grande’s impending record news, filmmaker Alfonso Cuarón has announced the track list and release date for his new album, which, coincidentally, is also due Feb. 8. He’s the curator of “Music Inspired by the Film Roma,” which was already teased by a Billie Eilish track, and is now revealed [...]

  • The Beach Bum Trailer

    Watch: Matthew McConaughey Stars in Groovy New 'The Beach Bum' Trailer

    Matthew McConaughey takes on new levels of drug use in the latest trailer for “The Beach Bum.” True to the film’s title, the trailer opens on a trashy beach town stage where McConaughey’s character Moondog is waiting to accept some sort of musical award. More Reviews Concert Review: Lady Gaga Outdoes Her Other Vegas Show [...]

  • SAG Awards Placeholder

    SAG Awards Unveils Presenters After Accusing Academy of 'Intimidation'

    The SAG Awards has unveiled its first round of presenters, including Lady Gaga, Bradley Cooper, Rami Malek, Chadwick Boseman, Adam Driver, Sam Elliott, and Constance Wu. Wednesday’s announcement comes two weeks after SAG-AFTRA accused the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences of intimidation in trying to limit actors from presenting on awards shows other [...]

  • Kevin Hart Fatherhood

    Kevin Hart Partnering With STX on Two Comedies (EXCLUSIVE)

    Kevin Hart is partnering with STXfilms to produce on a pair of comedy movies through his HartBeat Productions with an eye to star in both projects, Variety has learned exclusively. The announcement comes on the heels of Hart’s solid box office performance in “The Upside,” in which he co-stars with Bryan Cranston. STX’s comedic drama, co-produced [...]

  • Yalitza Aparicio as Cleo, Marco Graf

    Disruptor Netflix Joins Big Studios at the Table With MPAA Membership, Analysts Say

    Netflix is starting to look a lot like the media institutions it has been disrupting for years. In one fell swoop on Tuesday, the streaming giant racked up an impressive 15 Academy Award nominations, including a best picture nod for Alfonso Cuaron’s black-and-white, Spanish-language drama “Roma.” Hours later came official word that the company had [...]

  • Italy's Notorious Pictures Expands Into Exhibition,

    Italy's Notorious Pictures Expands Into Exhibition, Plans 200 Screens by 2023

    Italian distribution and production company Notorious Pictures is branching out into exhibition, aiming to have 20 multiplexes up and running within the next five years. The company has appointed former UCI Italy chief Andrea Stratta to head up a new Notorious Cinemas unit. The company said it was already in the process of taking out a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content