You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Silencio’

A magic space-rock holds the key to life and death in this turgid Mexico-U.S. fantasy thriller.

Lorena Villarreal
Melina Matthews, Rupert Graves, John Noble, Michel Chauvet, Nic Jackman, Hoze Melendez, Ian Garcia Monterrubio, Shayne Anneliese Coleman, Lucy Paez. (English, Spanish dialogue)
Release Date:
Oct 26, 2018

Rated R  1 hour 36 minutes

It’s become a reigning pulp cliché of our era that practically every dramatic protagonist must have a dead or endangered child motivating them. It’s the fallback device to provide “depth” to a troubled character, or to explain why they might bother saving the world or doing anything else for the greater good. Lorena Villarreal’s “Silencio” takes that lazy writer’s emotional choke-chain to ridiculous extremes, as eventually here it seems there’s almost no central figure who doesn’t have a child’s life to rescue or avenge. This turgid fantasy thriller, boasting scant thrills or imagination, douses a mystic time-travel concept with soap operatic hand-wringing to mawkishly unconvincing effect. The U.S.-Mexican co-production is getting released to some 300 Stateside screens, primarily targeting Hispanic markets.

A prologue depicts a NASA missile going off-course and crashing in the Zone of Silence, “the Bermuda Triangle of Mexico” which purportedly acts “like a magnetic vortex for meteors and other space debris.” (That Durango desert region actually does exist, and is an object of various modern urban myths.) Scientist Dr. James White (John Noble) and young assistant Peter (Nic Jackman) investigate the wreckage. Upon touching a particular rock found within, they’re suddenly transported to a time and place where they can partially avert a tragedy that recently stuck the doctor’s family.

Many years later, White is a sporadically senile grandfather living with surviving daughter Ana (Melina Matthews) and her only child Felix (Ian Garcia Monterrubio). During one of his more lucid moments, Gramps suddenly realizes he must “find the magic stone before my mind goes to sleep again,” though he can’t locate it where he once buried it.

Others are looking for the mystery rock as well: A thug (Hoze Melendez) is hired by someone to strong-arm it away from the Whites, prompting him to hold Felix hostage until they hand it over. A now middle-aged Peter (Rupert Graves) happens to be in town — he’s become a famous expert on the Zona’s mysteries — as all of this occurs. Another key figure is Daniel (Michel Chauvet), who has a “gift” for seeing dead people with urgent messages for the living.

Though professionally slick enough in its packaging surface, “Silencio” has little action and few engaging ideas. Instead, there’s a lot of poker-faced yakking about vague phenomena, and a weak attempt at twisty “Inception”-like revising of reality. Purportedly the stone can only save one life at a time, requiring an equal sacrifice in return — a dilemma that leads to multiple characters yelling at each other about just whose child must die to save another. We’re meant to find these tough choices primal and moving. But frankly, by that point, the story clearly lacks an emotionally genuine bone in its body — though Leoncio Lara’s earnest orchestral score struggles to suggest otherwise.

No one here seems terribly persuaded by Villarreal’s (“The Weeping Women”) contrived screenplay, and among the highly variable performances, veteran Australian actor Noble manages to be hammy in two separate time periods. Ironically, the character we feel most sympathy for is the poor, junkie-looking schmo of a kidnapper, who isn’t even granted a name — yet gets the brunt of some vigilante violence in return for crimes he’s hardly responsible for.

That scapegoat-battering aside, it’s not quite clear what secured “Silencio” its R rating, as the film seems aimed at a very middle-of-the-road audience, with “family values” ladled onto the popcorn-supernatural premise like trans-fatty “butter flavoring.” No parent should ever have to suffer losing a child — but using just such grief as a crude, over-milked plot device can turn a bland, forgettable escapist bore like this into a faintly insulting one. No offense is taken, however, at the seemingly inevitable, meaningless onscreen claim “Inspired by true events.”

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'Silencio'

Reviewed online, San Francisco, Oct. 22, 2018. MPAA Rating: R. Running time: 96 MIN.

Production: (Mexico-U.S.) A Tulip Pictures release of a Tulip Pictures presentation of a Barraca Prods. production. Producers: Lorena Villarreal, Denisse Chapa. Co-producers: Darian De La Fuente, Kim Williams.

Crew: Director, writer: Lorena Villarreal. Camera (color, widescreen, HD): Mateo Londono. Editors: Glenn Garland, Patrick McMachon. Music: Leoncio Lara “Bon.”

With: Melina Matthews, Rupert Graves, John Noble, Michel Chauvet, Nic Jackman, Hoze Melendez, Ian Garcia Monterrubio, Shayne Anneliese Coleman, Lucy Paez. (English, Spanish dialogue)

More Film

  • Rugrats. Nickeoldeon Animation Studios

    Film News Roundup: 'Rugrats' Writer David N. Weiss Honored by Animation Writers

    In today’s film news roundup, David N. Weiss is honored, Rin Tin Tin is getting a modern movie and “The Shasta Triangle” finds a home. WEISS HONORED David N. Weiss will receive the animation writing award from the Animation Writers Caucus of the Writers Guild of America West. The award will be presented by Weiss’ [...]

  • Marrakech Chief on Selecting Arthouse Films

    Marrakech Chief on Selecting Arthouse Films With a Big Stress on the Word 'Art'

    The 18th edition of the Marrakech Film Festival (Nov. 29-Dec. 7) – one of the leading cultural events in the Africa and Middle East region – will screen 98 films from 34 countries. The fest is also reinforcing its industry presence this year through the second edition of the Atlas Workshops, sponsored by Netflix, which [...]

  • Emma Stone Brad Pitt Damien Chazelle

    Paramount Lands Damien Chazelle's 'Babylon,' Dates It for Christmas 2021

    Paramount Pictures has landed the worldwide rights to Damien Chazelle’s next feature film “Babylon,” sources tell Variety. Insiders add the studio has dated the film for a Dec. 25, 2021 limited release, with plans to go wide on Jan. 7. The release date puts in prime position for another awards season run for Chazelle, who [...]

  • Chris Pratt

    Chris Pratt's Sci-Fi Film 'The Tomorrow War' Gets Release Date

    Chris Pratt’s upcoming sci-fi actioner, which was recently retitled “The Tomorrow War,” has set a Christmas Day 2020 release date. The Paramount film was formerly titled “Ghost Draft.” It follows a man (played by Pratt) who is drafted to fight a future war in which the fate of humanity may rely on his ability to [...]

  • Kim Dong-Ho of GIFF Chairman of

    Inaugural Gangneung Film Festival Pays Tribute to Pierre Rissient

    The opening ceremony of the first edition of the Gangneung International Film Festival was dominated by a tribute to the French film scout and festival selector Pierre Rissient, who died in May 2018. The new festival, 240 km from Seoul, counts former Busan festival co-founder Kim Dong-ho as its chairman and former Bucheon festival head [...]

  • 'Waves': Sterling K. Brown and Trey

    'Waves' Cast Reflects on the Making of the Tragic Family Drama

    “Waves,” a partially autobiographical film written and directed by Trey Edward Shults, is a visually arresting look at the fraying of an upper-middle class black family in South Florida in the aftermath of a violent tragedy. It examines themes of grief, domestic violence, substance abuse and modern-day pressures on kids to succeed. “Propelled by color, [...]

  • Gaston Pavlovich

    Gaston Pavlovich Talks About Producing 'The Irishman'

    Through his production company Fabrica De Cine, Gastón Pavlovich is one of the producers on Martin Scorsese’s two most recent movies: 2016’s “Silence” and 2019’s “The Irishman.” The 51-year-old native of Mexico first gained notice as an executive producer on the Tom Hanks comedy-drama “A Hologram for the King.” Pavlovich also began working with Scorsese [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content