You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Poisonous Roses’

Audiences can practically smell the stench from Cairo’s old tanneries in this visually striking but narratively unconvincing brother-sister drama.

Ahmed Fawzi Saleh
Koky, Mahmoud Hemada, Ibrahim El-Nagary, Safaa El-Toukhy, Mohamed Brekaa. (Arabic dialogue)

1 hour 10 minutes

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt7866918/

The fetid effluence of sewage water is the major leitmotif of Ahmed Fawzi Saleh’s debut feature “Poisonous Roses,” an elliptical drama of two siblings, set within the hellish alleyways of Cairo’s unsavory tannery district. Best viewed as a fictional spinoff from the director’s superb 2010 documentary “Living Skin,” which depicted life in the same (or similar) workshops, the film is a mood piece that fitfully plumbs a sister’s obsessive love for her listless brother, who’s looking to escape Egypt. Atmospheric at the cost of narrative coherence, “Roses” is notable for the way it depicts a quasi-surrealistic netherworld via visually arresting shots of a queasy austerity. Festival programmers clued in to the small but distinctive Egyptian independent scene should come calling, while the French coin involved could translate into additional bookings.

The narrow semi-paved maze of streets in Cairo’s old tannery sector are difficult to square with the modern world: blackened waste pours out of pipes and into public spaces traversed by people and animal carts laden with hides. Each day Taheya (Koky) wends her way through the alleys to bring lunch to her deeply unappreciative brother, Saqr (Ibrahim El-Nagary), working in the district. Saqr’s lack of outward affection for his sister is in inverse proportion to her devotion, which borders on the incestuous. When he tells her he’s met a girl and he wants to go to Italy, Taheya appeals to the local magus (Mahmoud Hemada) for a spell that will keep her brother in Cairo.

On its own, it’s difficult to understand Taheya’s fixation with ensuring her brother remains at home. Sure, the family could use the money he brings in, since she can’t earn much by cleaning public toilets, but Taheya’s almost unnatural love for Saqr, despite his evident indifference, makes little sense as presented in the script. Only when compared with the film’s source material, Ahmed Zaghloul Al-sheety’s influential 1990 novel “Poisonous Roses for Saqr,” with its clear allusion to Taheya as a kind of modern-day Isis, does the quasi-incestuous, over-protective nature of the brother-sister relationship make sense.

Yet what’s the film trying to say with this? If it’s meant as a metaphor for today’s Egypt — and given the nature of the country’s dictatorship, metaphor is the only way any critique can be formulated — the message remains abstruse, though one could assign concrete values to these hypothetical allegories and thereby get entangled in any number of conjectured allusions. For example, what are we to make of the siblings’ mother (Safaa El-Toukhy), whose total lack of interest in Taheya could make the viewer presume she’s a step-mother rather than a biological relation, though that would render moot the whole Isis-Osiris parallel.

Far better to focus on the film’s genuine strengths, which lie in the visuals. Saleh and his cinematographer, Maged Nader, have an accomplished understanding of framing and pattern, making the medieval-seeming tanneries and the glue factory where Saqr later works at once repellent and captivating, without falling into the trap of exoticizing poverty. Taheya’s abaya-clad figure casually negotiating the squalid lanes that act as sluices for run-off chemicals forms a striking composition, her dark figure contrasted with the sand-colored buildings. Blue- and orange-dyed hides stretched and drying in the sun act as an open-air abstract tapestry. Accompanying these images is the inescapable sensation of the stench, and the thought that the actors, unaccustomed to the smell (unlike those who work there), must have exhibited heroic fortitude to endure these conditions.

Film Review: 'Poisonous Roses'

Reviewed at Rotterdam Film Festival (Bright Future), Jan. 28, 2018. 70 MIN. Original title: Ward masmoum.

Production: (Egypt-France) An Al Batrik, Red Star, Haut les Mains Prods. production. Producers: Eman Hemeida, Karim Aitouna, Thomas Micoulet. Co-producers: Baho Baksh, Mahmoud Hemada, Safi El Din Mahmoud. Executive producer: Ahmed Fawzi Saleh.

Crew: Director, writer: Ahmed Fawzi Saleh, adapted from the novel "Poisonous Roses for Saqr" by Ahmed Zaghloul Al-sheety. Camera (color): Maged Nader. Editors: Qutaiba Barhamji, Mennatallah El Shishini, Nadia Ben Rachid.

With: Koky, Mahmoud Hemada, Ibrahim El-Nagary, Safaa El-Toukhy, Mohamed Brekaa. (Arabic dialogue)

More Film

  • (L to R) VIGGO MORTENSEN and

    Green Book' Lands Post-Oscars Theatrical Release in China

    Fresh off Monday’s news that it had picked up five Academy Award nominations, best picture favorite “Green Book” is set for more good luck. The film will hit Middle Kingdom theaters on March 1, the first weekend after the Oscars, which fall on Feb 24, Alibaba Pictures said on its official social media account, on [...]

  • Fan Bingbing

    Chinese Celebrities Pay $1.7 Billion in Back Taxes Following Fan Bingbing Scandal

    Chinese film and TV stars have paid some $1.7 billion (RMB11.7 billion) of additional taxes, following the mid-2018 scandal surrounding actress Fan Bingbing. The figure was announced Tuesday by China’s State Tax Administration. Chinese authorities launched a probe into the taxation affairs of the entertainment sector in October. Companies and individuals were asked to examine [...]

  • Yalitza Aparicio as Cleo, Marco Graf

    Film News Roundup: AMC, Regal to Leave 'Roma' Out of Best Picture Showcases

    In today’s film news roundup, “Roma” will not be in the best picture showcases at AMC and Regal, “Jimi Hendrix: Electric Church” gets a release and SAG-AFTRA’s David White has a new appointment. ‘ROMA’ SPURNED More Reviews Concert Review: Lady Gaga Outdoes Her Other Vegas Show With Masterful 'Jazz & Piano' TV Review: 'Russian Doll' [...]

  • First Look at SAG Awards' Cuban

    First Look at SAG Awards' Cuban-Inspired After-Party (EXCLUSIVE)

    Celebrities at this year’s SAG Awards won’t have to go far for some tropical fun. Sunday’s annual post-show gala, hosted by People magazine for the 23rd year, is set to feature a Cuban-themed party space adjacent to the Shrine Auditorium. More Reviews Concert Review: Lady Gaga Outdoes Her Other Vegas Show With Masterful 'Jazz & [...]

  • Paul DavidsonVariety Big Data Summit Presented

    Listen: The Orchard's Paul Davidson on Surviving Sundance Bidding Wars

    Hollywood heads to Park City, Utah this week in the hopes of finding the next big Sundance Film Festival breakout. Paul Davidson, executive vice president of film and television at The Orchard, plans to be in the thick of it. In today’s edition of Variety‘s “Strictly Business” podcast, Davidson opens up about The Orchard’s strategy [...]

  • Young Tony Soprano in 'Sopranos' Movie:

    James Gandolfini's Son Michael Gandolfini Cast as Tony Soprano in 'Sopranos' Movie

    Michael Gandolfini, son of the late James Gandolfini, will play the young Tony Soprano in “The Many Saints of Newark,” the  prequel movie to the television series “The Sopranos.” “It’s a profound honor to continue my dad’s legacy while stepping into the shoes of a young Tony Soprano,” Gandolfini said. “I’m thrilled that I am [...]

  • Bradley Cooper A Star Is Born

    The Message of the Oscar Nominations: You'd Better Have a Social Message

    Each year at the Left Coast crack of dawn, when the Oscar nominations are announced, there’s generally at least one major nomination many pundits were predicting that fails to materialize. When that happens, entertainment media tends to rise up as one and say the s-word: snub. In truth, it’s not usually a snub; it’s just [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content