×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Manto’

This biopic of celebrated — and castigated — Urdu short story writer Saadat Hasan Manto is stately, but too staid for his provocative writing.

Director:
Nandita Das
With:
Nawazuddin Siddiqui, Rasika Dugal

1 hour 53 minutes

“My stories are mirrors for society to see itself,” asserts author Saadat Hasan Manto (Nawazuddin Siddiqui), on trial for obscenity. Dramatizing Manto’s struggles as he excoriates humanity during the most tumultuous time on the Indian Subcontinent, actress-filmmaker Nandita Das’ “Manto” is elegant and old school, epic without losing sight of the personal. However, Das’ heavily expository style is almost too respectable to do justice to the scathing and sexually provocative nature of Manto’s short stories, considered some of the most powerful in the Urdu language. Siddiqui, the chameleon actor of “The Lunchbox” and “Gangs of Wasseypur” gives a tour-de-force portrayal of the writer’s intellect as well as his very human flaws.

“Manto” could garner support among the educated bourgeois crowd in India and Pakistan who likely know the protagonist’s life and oeuvre well; the film’s high-mindedness might not be as readily appreciated by general audiences abroad.

The action opens in Bombay (now Mumbai) in 1946, with India’s independence from British rule. Manto, a non-practicing Muslim of Kashmiri origin, is flushed with pride over his nation’s autonomy, as conveyed in his animated discourses with best friend Shyam Chadda (Tahir Bhasin), a Hindu actor, and his optimism for the bright future that awaits his baby daughters. The social gatherings Manto attends re-create the heady buzz of Bombay’s literati, with a wry glance at fledgling Bollywood, for which Manto wrote scripts.

Before long, however, the country becomes galvanized by violence, hatred and mass dispossession. A few taut episodes of escalating tension between Hindus, Muslims and Sikhs evoke Manto’s agony in witnessing the destruction of what he sees as his city’s soul. He’s forced to move to Lahore, in the newly created state of Pakistan, where the family of his wife, Safia (Rasika Dugal), lives.

Eschewing spectacle, Das nevertheless expresses the human cost of the greatest upheaval in the history of the Indian Subcontinent: She vividly depicts the dereliction of Lahore in 1948 in contrast to the swinging mood of 1946 Bombay, and delves into Manto’s darkening psyche. Recreations of his short stories also give a sense of the chaos and cruelty running rampant all around him, and the anger and pessimism he feels.

The film scores its highest points by so smoothly weaving extracts from Manto’s stories into the fabric of the narrative that it’s not easy to see the line between the author’s life and his fiction; placed at the center of a scene, he simultaneously observes and engages with the imaginary characters. Credit goes not only to the bold cutting of Sreekar Prasad, but also to Siddiqui for his ability to move between multiple worlds of reality and imagination with subtly differentiated expressions.

Siddiqui effectively reveals Manto’s alcoholism and emotional instability as a gradual deterioration, using quicksilver shifts of mood rather than flaming melodrama. However, his failing marriage is not developed enough to deliver a more tragic impact. Compared with earlier scenes of harmony, clearly built on a matching of equal minds among husband and wife, it’s a pity Safi’s reaction to Manto’s downward spiral is not detailed.

The film also betrays weakness in its account of Manto’s challenge against patriarchy and male violence (his stories abound with rape and other sexual abuse), or his compassion for the most reviled or stigmatized strata like prostitutes or sexually abused women. Although this is mentioned in the story re-creations, it doesn’t consolidate into an over-arching theme.

According to screen titles, the author has been tried in court as many as six times for obscenity. The film’s last act focuses on one such trial, in which he and his publishers are sued for the short story “Cold Meat.” His speech in his defense, in which he compares himself with Flaubert and Joyce (both taken to court for their masterpieces) detail his lifelong stance — and struggle — as the scourge of society. But here and elsewhere, there’s a fundamental problem with the dialogue; containing generous portions of Manto’s own words, the film gushes with eloquence but also sounds verbose and stuffy.

Tech credits are well-appointed, particularly the full-bodied, mournful score by master composer Zakir Hussain. Sneha Khanwalkar’s closing song boasts lyrics that express the essence of Manto’s beliefs.

Film Review: ‘Manto’

Reviewed at Cannes Film Festival (Un Certain Regard), May 14, 2018. Running time: 113 MIN.

Production: (India-France) A Dandita Das Initiatives, Filmstoc, HP Studios, Viacom 18 Motion Pictures production. (International sales: Radiant Films Intl., Los Angeles.) Producers: Nirang Desai, Sameer Dixit, Jatish Varma. Executive producer: Sanjeev Kumar Nair.

Crew: Director, writer: Nandita Das. Camera (color) Kartik Vijay. Editor: Sreekar Prasad. Music: Zakir Hussain, Sneha Khanwalkar.

With: Nawazuddin Siddiqui, Rasika DugalTahir Raj Bhasin, Rishi Kapoor (Urdu, English, Hindi, Punjabi dialogue)

More Film

  • 'All These Small Moments' Review

    Film Review: 'All These Small Moments'

    The magic of writer-director Melissa B. Miller Costanzo’s “All These Small Moments” can be found within the intimacy of the scenarios, the authenticity of her earnest characterizations, and the accessibility of the actors’ honest performances. In her deftly polished directorial debut, Costanzo dovetails the primary story about a teen’s coming of age with a secondary [...]

  • Bruce Tufeld Dead: Hollywood Agent and

    Hollywood Agent and Manager Bruce Tufeld Dies at 66

    Bruce Tufeld, a Hollywood agent and manager who once repped stars like Rob Lowe, Laura Dern, and Kelsey Grammer, died Tuesday in Los Angeles as a result of complications from liver cancer. He was 66. The son of respected television announcer Richard “Dick” Tufeld and Adrienne Tufeld, Bruce began his career as an assistant at ICM [...]

  • Bruce Dern

    Film News Roundup: Bruce Dern's 'The Lears' Bought by Vertical for February Release

    In today’s film news roundup, Bruce Dern’s “The Lears” and “Angels Are Made of Light” are acquired, Cold War drama “Stanley Cage” is launched and a documentary about Madonna’s early music career gets a release. ACQUISITIONS Vertical Entertainment has acquired North American rights from NeoClassics Films to “The Lears,” starring Bruce Dern in a modern-day [...]

  • Octavia Spencer Bryce Dallas Howard

    Octavia Spencer, Bryce Dallas Howard to Reunite for Comedy 'Fairy Tale Ending'

    Octavia Spencer and Bryce Dallas Howard will reunite for the ensemble comedy “Fairy Tale Ending.” Jim Hecht (“Ice Age: The Meltdown) and Tracy McMillan (“Marvel’s Runaways”) are writing the screenplay. Howard will also produce the Universal movie through her Nine Muses Entertainment alongside Eric Carlson and Susan Carlson. Seth MacFarlane and Erica Huggins will produce [...]

  • Robert Smith, Longtime Executive at DuArt

    Robert Smith, Longtime Executive at New York's DuArt Film Labs, Dies at 88

    Robert Smith, a longtime executive with New York’s DuArt Film Labs, died Jan. 11 in Montvale, N.J. He was 88. Smith spent some 62 years with DuArt, the film processing and post-production facility founded in 1922 in the penthouse of an automobile garage in Midtown. Smith rose to president of DuArt before retiring in 2015. [...]

  • Bird Box

    Los Angeles On-Location Feature Filming Surges 12.2% in 2018

    On-location feature filming in Greater Los Angeles expanded impressively in 2018, gaining 12.2% to 4,377 shooting days, according to FilmL.A. Production activity for feature films rose 15.5% to 1,078 shooting days during the fourth quarter, with 146 days coming from projects receiving California tax credits — including Netflix’s “Bird Box,” Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content