Film Review: ‘Lu Over the Wall’

An ultra-weird grown-up version of the beloved anime 'Ponyo,' Masaaki Yuasa's trippy toon recounts the odd friendship between a boy and a mermaid.

Masaaki Yuasa
Kanon Tani, Shōta Shimoda, Shin'ichi Shinohara, Akira Emoto, Sōma Saitō, Minako Kotobuki.
Release Date:
May 11, 2018

Rated PG  1 hour 53 minutes

For those whose appetites for Japanese anime don’t stop at Studio Ghibli, Masaaki Yuasa’s “Lu Over the Wall” goes not just over the wall, but pinwheeling through the neighbor’s garden and practically into another dimension — but then, what else would you expect from the director of 2004’s deranged “Mind Game”? If anything, “Lu” feels tame by comparison, although by traditional cartoon standards, this far-fetched, wildly imaginative (and 100% unofficial) riff on Hayao Miyazaki’s “Ponyo” — which was itself a loose reimagining of Hans Christian Andersen’s “The Little Mermaid” — puts a zany spin on the old boy-meets-mergirl formula, where a magical sea creature is beckoned ashore by the sound of a mopey rocker’s emo music.

Whereas Miyazaki’s universally accessible “Ponyo” felt like it was targeted at toddlers, “Lu” skews older, appealing more directly to adolescent and adult viewers willing to have their minds blown by the title creature’s supernatural shenanigans. In terms of craftsmanship, the film has a scrappy, sometimes cheap look to it (characters look flat, like thin-lined Etch-a-Sketch drawings, superimposed over more colorful hand-painted backgrounds), for which it more than compensates via other strengths — namely, a trio of relatable, well-written human protagonists and Lu, who can change form and bend water at will. These qualities, and an endearing overall sense of weirdness, earned the film top prize at the 2017 Annecy animation festival.

The story takes place in Hinashi Town, a seaside village where superstitious fisherman live in fear of the malevolent merfolk said to inhabit the local waters, which are chock-a-block with sunken ships. Years earlier, as a protective measure, they blasted a massive boulder, effectively imprisoning the pesky creatures — until teenage Kai (voiced by Shôta Shimoda) and his two bandmates venture to Merfolk Island, where their rehearsal lures Lu “over the wall.”

Nearly an hour has passed by the time the movie gets around to explaining Lu’s species (technically, ningyo), though it hardly matters, since everything the humans think they know about merfolk is wrong, and her abilities go far beyond what anyone can imagine: She can manipulate water, making it glow radioactive, or mold itself into rectangular shapes (a trick she uses to punish a pair of poachers, forcing them high into the air on a pedestal of water). Most of the time, the loosely rendered Lu is an emoji-faced girl, googly-eyed and saw-toothed, with jellyfish-blue hair, a seaweed skirt, and salmon-pink tail. When music plays, however, she can’t help dancing, adapting a pair of batonette legs and rocketing about like a firework set off inside a circus tent.

At first, Lu remains a well-kept secret, but her powers are such that it’s tough for Kai to keep the townsfolk from finding out about his newfound friend — and once they do, they’re quick to exploit the situation, making Lu the centerpiece of his musical act. From there, things get surreal fast, as a giant shark-monster gets involved, stomping out of the sea to wreak havoc on the fast-evolving human-fish relations. Not much of what follows makes sense (despite a few expository interludes rendered in a more primitive style reminiscent of “Mind Game”), but it’s darn crazy to observe, and the fact that Kai and his friends are musicians ensures that there will be fun music to propel things toward their gonzo finale.

Popular on Variety

Film Review: 'Lu Over the Wall'

Reviewed at Animation Is Film Festival, Los Angeles, Oct. 22, 2017. MPAA Rating: PG. Running time: 113 MIN. (Original title: “Yoake Tsugeru Rū no Uta”)

Production: (Japan — Animated) A GKIDS release of a Fuji Television Network, Toho Co., Science Saru, BS Fuji Inc. production. Producers: Yuka Okayasu, Junnosuke Ito. Executive producers: Kenji Shimizu, Keiji Ota, Masaaki Yuasa, Akihiro Arai.

Crew: Director: Masaaki Yuasa. Screenplay: Reiko Yoshida, Yuasa. Camera (color): Baptiste Perron. Editor: Ayako Tan. Music: Takatsugu Muramatsu.

With: Kanon Tani, Shōta Shimoda, Shin'ichi Shinohara, Akira Emoto, Sōma Saitō, Minako Kotobuki.

More Film

  • Peter Fonda Obit Remembered

    Remembering Peter Fonda, Indie Revolutionary and Counterculture Icon (Column)

    Captain America has died. Not the spandex-clad Marvel superhero, but counterculture poster boy Peter Fonda, who shook up Hollywood and revolutionized the country’s sense of itself by co-writing, producing and starring in “Easy Rider” 50 years ago this summer — the same summer depicted in Quentin Tarantino’s “Once Upon a Time … in Hollywood.” Culture [...]

  • Knives Out

    Rian Johnson's 'Knives Out' Sells to KKR's New Distribution Company in Germany

    Rian Johnson’s “Knives Out” has been picked up for Germany by the newly established distribution company owned by New York-based private equity group KKR. Fred Kogel’s rapidly growing, but still unnamed, German independent production and distribution operation has taken all rights for Germany and Austria on the all-star whodunnit, which stars Daniel Craig, Jamie Lee Curtis, [...]

  • Director Mati Diop poses for photographers

    Toronto Film Festival: Director Mati Diop to Receive Inaugural Mary Pickford Award

    French actress and director Mati Diop will be honored with the inaugural Mary Pickford Award for outstanding female talent at the Toronto International Film Festival’s upcoming Tribute Gala. TIFF announced the news along with their schedule of events including live performances and interviews featuring directors and actors such as Oscar winner Javier Bardem. “Mati Diop’s [...]

  • Hollywood Recession Business Placeholder

    How an Economic Downturn Could Ravage Hollywood

    Trade-war fears, stock market volatility and, most recently, bond market signals that point to a pending recession are rattling investors, igniting concerns that another devastating downturn may be just around the corner. As those worries reverberate all the way from Wall Street to Hollywood, the entertainment industry is in for an unsettling reminder of the [...]

  • 'La Muralla'

    HBO Latino Snaps up Bolivia’s ‘Muralla’ by Gory Patiño (EXCLUSIVE)

    In its continued bid to provide a diverse range of films from Latin America, HBO Latino has acquired U.S. pay TV rights to Bolivian Gory Patiño’s thriller “Muralla” from Alfredo Calviño of Habanero Film Sales. “Muralla” was Bolivia’s official entry to the 2019 Oscars and Golden Globes. Back home, where it had a 10-week theatrical [...]

  • Wagner Moura

    Wagner Moura’s ‘Marighella’ Slated for Nov. 20 Release Amid Calls for Boycott

    SANTIAGO, Chile – “Marighella,” Wagner Moura’s contentious directorial debut, is slated to bow in Brazil on Nov. 20 but Moura fears that its domestic release could be hampered by ongoing calls to boycott it by conservatives and the government of President Jair Bolsonaro who claims, among other things, that Brazil’s 21 years under military rule [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content