You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Berlin Film Review: ‘L’Animale’

This well-made but predictable LGBT coming-of-age tale is too familiar to wholly invest in.

Katharina Mueckstein
Sophie Stockinger, Kathrin Resetarits, Dominik Warta, Julia Franz Richter, Jack Hofer, Stefan Pohl, Dominic Marcus Singer, Simon Morzé, Eva Herzig, David Oberkogler, Martina Spitzer, Lisa C. Nemec, Johanna Orsini-Rosenberg, Gisela Salcher, Alexandra Schmidt.

1 hour 36 minutes

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt6169920/

With the buzzing of tires across the gravelly bottom of a small quarry bitten into a hillside, Austrian sophomore director Katharina Mueckstein (“Talea”) kickstarts her coming-of-age story in promisingly high gear. And when one of the helmeted motocross riders, clad in light, Imperial Stormtrooper-style body armor, is revealed, against expectations, to be a girl, there are shades of the opening of Celine Sciamma’s “Girlhood,” in which a team of young women pummel each other through the exaggeratedly masculine silhouettes of their football uniforms.

Sciamma’s previous film “Tomboy” also looms large in comparison, and later, in the most formally experimental moment of “L’Animale,” Mueckstein pays homage to Paul Thomas Anderson’s “Magnolia” when her characters suddenly break into song. Her references are impeccable, but they’re also the problem. Despite strong performances that go a long way to embedding the film in real, idiosyncratic life — and the warm-toned, polished photography of Michael Schindegger — too much of “L’Animale” feels too familiar. Even when they don’t nod directly to one of the category’s standouts, the scenes feel culled from the vast pool of the growing-pains/coming-out/lifestage drama, a genre that becomes more densely populated with every passing film festival.

The tomboy here is sulky teenaged Mati (an excellent Sophie Stockinger, reteaming with Mueckstein), though her blunt features appear not quite set yet, like those of a child. She’s staring down the barrel of her final high school exams and hangs out with an otherwise all-male motorbike gang, the members of which divide their time between racing each other around the quarry (Mati always wins), committing acts of minor vandalism, and drunkenly harassing the more gender-conforming girls they know at the local nightclub. The volatile Kogler (Dominic Marcus Singer) is the mean-boy ringleader, but Mati is closest to Sebi (Jack Hofer) the ambition-free son of a local farmer. Sebi would like them to be closer still. But Mati is attracted to Carla (Julia Franz Richter), the pretty young woman who one day brings her ailing cat into the clinic where Mati helps out her veterinarian mother, Gabi (Kathrin Resetarits).

Gabi is having her own problems with Mati’s father, Paul (Dominik Warta). He’s lethargic about finishing the partially built house in which they live; can it be he has a secret gnawing at him? Paul’s closeted homosexuality is subtly established merely by an overemphatic exclamation of his dislike of gay co-worker Felix (Stefan Pohl), followed by a gently lascivious shot of Felix’s mouth as he speaks. But Mueckstein’s overdetermined scripting always makes explicit the implicit. So there follows a contrived sequence involving the return of a forgotten wallet, in which we, and Gabi, must unequivocally glimpse her husband’s betrayal firsthand.

The metaphors are writ unmissably large. At one point Paul undergoes a long damp evening of the soul, when he’d been hoping for some “Stranger by the Lake” action, but instead shivers alone as night falls around him while across the water the gay party from which he’s literally and geographically separated kicks off under colored lights. And beware the coming-of-age indie that cross-cuts to a high-school literature class in which the work being discussed — here Goethe’s “Blissful Yearning” — neatly parallels the themes of the film. Even Stockinger’s sincere performance cannot rid the moment in which she suddenly responds to the newly relevant text of the air of cliché.

Both Goethe’s poem and Franco Battiato’s 1985 Italian pop song “L’Animale,” which supplants B. Fleischmann’s pleasant electro score in that showy, not wholly successful sing-along, make lyrical reference to the revivifying, transformational power of uncontrollable passion. Goethe wrote of a butterfly burned and reborn; Battiato sings of the fierce animal inside that enslaves him to his paramour. But Mueckstein’s film is the animal tamed. It occasionally captures the precariousness of youth, and the loneliness of running with a pack whose tribal loyalty you no longer share, but more often consigns those wilder, messier, more dangerous instincts to a well-made, gilded cage.

Berlin Film Review: 'L'Animale'

Reviewed at Berlin Film Festival — Panorama, Feb. 24, 2018. Running Time: 96 MIN.

Production: (Austria) An NGF Nikolaus Geyrhalter Filmproduktion and La Banda Film production, supported by Österreichisches Filminstitut, Filmfonds Wien, ORF Film/Fernsehabkommen, FISA and Land Niederösterreich Kultur. (International sales: Films Boutique, Berlin.) Producers: Michael Kitzberger, Wolfgang Widerhofer, Flavio Marchetti, Nikolaus Geyrhalter, Markus Glaser, Michael Schindegger, Natalie Schwager, Katharina Mueckstein.

Crew: Director, writer: Katharina Mueckstein. Camera (color): Michael Schindegger. Editor: Natalie Schwager. Music: B. Fleischmann.

With: Sophie Stockinger, Kathrin Resetarits, Dominik Warta, Julia Franz Richter, Jack Hofer, Stefan Pohl, Dominic Marcus Singer, Simon Morzé, Eva Herzig, David Oberkogler, Martina Spitzer, Lisa C. Nemec, Johanna Orsini-Rosenberg, Gisela Salcher, Alexandra Schmidt.

More Film

  • Matt Smith

    Matt Smith, 'Leave No Trace' Star Thomasin Harcourt McKenzie Circle Edgar Wright Movie

    Matt Smith and “Leave No Trace” star Thomasin Harcourt McKenzie are in negotiations to join Edgar Wright’s next film, “Last Night in Soho,” sources tell Variety. Details are vague about the psychological horror movie, other than it being set in London’s Soho district. Anya Taylor Joy is also in the cast. Production is expected to [...]

  • Vice Media

    Vice Media Taps Joe Simon as Chief Technology Officer (EXCLUSIVE)

    Joe Simon has been tapped as chief technology officer at Vice Media. The newly created role will include oversight of data analytics, engineering, information technology, media operations, media technology, post production, and systems management. Prior to Vice, Simon spent three years as Encompass Digital Media’s chief operating officer. Previously he held the chief technology officer [...]

  • Michael B Jordan denzel washington

    Michael B. Jordan to Star in Denzel Washington's 'Journal for Jordan'

    Michael B. Jordan is in talks to star in Sony’s “Journal for Jordan,” a drama that will be directed by Denzel Washington. The movie, penned by Oscar-nominated screenwriter Virgil Williams, is based on the true story of Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Dana Canedy’s love affair with First Sergeant Charles Monroe King. King kept a journal [...]

  • Sylvester Stallone

    Sylvester Stallone's Superhero Drama 'Samaritan' Lands at MGM

    MGM is developing the superhero drama “Samaritan” with Sylvester Stallone attached to star and produce through his Balboa Productions. The studio has acquired Bragi F. Schut’s script, which centers on a boy learning that a missing superhero, who vanished 20 years earlier after a battle, may still be alive. MGM will develop “Samaritan” with Stallone [...]

  • Kendrick Lamar

    Oscars: Kendrick Lamar and SZA Will Not Perform 'Black Panther' Song (EXCLUSIVE)

    Despite the Academy’s efforts to secure Kendrick Lamar and SZA for a performance of the Oscar-nominated song “All the Stars” from “Black Panther” on the upcoming Oscars telecast, the duo will not be a part of the show, Variety has learned. The reason, according to a source close to the situation, is logistics and timing. [...]

  • Oscars Spa Treatments

    Area Spas Offer Red Carpet Treatments in Time for Oscars

    From a shopping session with a celebrity stylist to a covert airport pickup, these hotels and spas are offering even more curated packages for the ultimate VIP Oscar experience. For the Jetsetter Four Seasons Hotel Los Angeles at Beverly Hills’ Doheny Suite Experience package allows travelers to evade the paparazzi with an underground or curbside [...]

  • Rocketman

    See Taron Egerton Transform Into Elton John in New ‘Rocketman’ Trailer

    A new trailer for “Rocketman,” the Elton John “fantasy musical” in theaters May 31, was released today. As the singer, actor Taron Egerton (“Eddie the Eagle”) performs “Tiny Dancer” and is seen honing his talent at home, rising to fame and grappling with the pitfalls that superstardom can bring. The film also stars Jamie Bell (as John’s [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content