Film Review: ‘First Night Nerves’

Hong Kong director Stanley Kwan's overstuffed homage to drama-queen actresses plays like a cross between 'Crazy Rich Asians' and 'Feud.'

Stanley Kwan
Sammi Cheng, Gigi Leung, Bai Baihe

1 hour 40 minutes

Audiences looking for the next “Crazy Rich Asians” might take some delight in Stanley Kwan’s diva-licious “First Night Nerves,” a “Feud”-like behind-the-scenes rivalry which forces center stage all the drama between high-maintenance Hong Kong actresses Yuan Xiuling (Sammi Cheng) and He Yuwen (Gigi Leung). Set during the final week of rehearsals for a new play called “Two Sisters,” the film feels soapier than a broken dishwasher, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing for audiences who relish the chance to watch actresses display their full range of emotion in a movie that gives even the smallest female parts more dimension than most movies offer their ostensible leading ladies.

One of Hong Kong’s only openly gay directors, Kwan has crafted a movie that’s nearly Almodóvarian in the appreciation and respect it showers upon ladies of all classes — not just the city’s Ferrari-driving super-elite, but also the loyal assistants who cook and console our dueling stars. If only he also shared the Spanish helmer’s gift for storytelling and style (the script here is credited to Jimmy Ngai). “First Night Nerves” is a dense and sometimes dauntingly overloaded melodrama for which it might be helpful if someone could pause the narrative every few minutes to re-explain the intricacies of how everybody connects.

The film opens with a press conference at Hong Kong City Hall (a historic arts location, very nearly demolished and now under renovation), during which Kwan dumps nearly all the characters in our laps at once: The play is kind of a big deal because it marks the return to acting of Xiuling, who “retired” five years earlier and has now agreed to share the stage with the fellow actress who eclipsed her. With her short haircut and attention-grabbing fashion sense, Yuwen has a spunkier, more modern attitude, and though her reputation is for stealing the limelight, the truth is, she’s intimidated by her co-star. Add to that Cheng Cong (Angie Chiu), the chic Shanghai millionaire bankrolling the production; the show’s trans writer-director, Ouyang An (Kam Kwok Leung); busybody theater manager Mao (Kiki Sheung); and ultra-cool, independently wealthy lesbian bachelorette Fu Sha (Bai Baihe) who’s permitted to hang around in the actresses’ dressing rooms because she’s crazy-rich and kind of a blast to have around.

Popular on Variety

The standout of that ensemble is An, whom none of the characters quite know how to address, but whose responsibility it is to mediate between her two stars. On one hand, her period set “Two Sisters” play — a catty Anton Chekhov/Tennessee Williams hybrid which she continues to revise right up until opening night — offers sparring opportunities aplenty for both actresses, although Yuwen has only 207 lines, while Xiuling gets double as many (Yuwen counted).

Needy and narcissistic, these two may be drama queens, but “First Night Nerves” is nothing if not a love letter to such icons, conceiving their game of one-upswomanship in such a way that each new ploy to steal the spotlight serves to reinforce rather than undermine the actresses in our eyes. Consider Xiuling’s big crying scene. At the end of day two, the widowed actress reveals (to us, since the information was apparently reported widely by tabloids at the time) how she still mourns her late husband — this despite the fact the scoundrel (and Cong’s brother, through some unexplained coincidence) died in a fiery plane crash with his mistress, who bore him two children. Cut to the next day during rehearsals, when Xiuling’s character is expected to cry after seeing the ghost of her dead lover — except, as we can now appreciate, the tears are real.

Since Cheng gets a crying scene, so should Leung, and sure enough, later in the film, Kwan includes a scene wherein Yuwen grabs a taxi to work, only to discover that the driver is none other than the Hong Kong director who discovered her back in the day (a not-at-all flattering statement about how tough things have gotten for the helmers whose popularity has been eclipsed by the mainland Chinese film industry). The driver reminds her how she sobbed the day she won her “best newcomer” award, saying, “You’ll never have to cry again.” Cut to Yuwen sobbing in her dressing room as she’s reminded of how a high-profile affair with another director (Felix Chong) ended badly.

Such emotional displays are fun to watch, although they may feel a bit too much like daytime television for Western viewers. As if winking at the audience, Kwan indulges a running joke that draws our attention to the differences that distinguish stage and screen acting: His twin leads conspicuously alter their performance styles between the two environments, while DP Wang Boxue frames the rehearsals for maximum cinematic effect (tracking in during a juicy monologue, using mirrors to reflect the silent co-star, etc.). At one point, An orders Yuwen “not to emote while eating abalone,” adding, “This isn’t some tacky movie,” and yet, a staggering number of the star’s offstage scenes involve food — which can only be Kwan’s way of celebrating the joys of “tacky movie” acting.

Film Review: 'First Night Nerves'

Reviewed at Busan Film Festival (Gala Presentations), Oct. 5, 2018. Running time: 100 MIN.

Production: (Hong Kong-China) A Seven Stars Film (Beijing), Qin Han Wild Horse Entertainment Investment Fund, Dadi Century (Beijing) Co., Huarui Pictures (Tianjin) Co., Beijing High See Film Corp. presentation, in co-presentation with Golden Scene Co., Arena Prods., Beijing Orient Dadi Cultural Industries Development Centre, Red Coral Pictures (Xi’an) Co., Star Essence Culture (Beijing) Co., Zhejiang Sunshine Film Co., Beijing Studio TOP Co., Red Coral Pictures. (Int’l sales: Golden Scene Co., Hong Kong.) Producers: Katie Kwan, Zhang Qun, Wu Xinxin. Executive producers: Zhao Ye, Xu Zhen, Liu Rong, Chen Liwei, Wang Ying. Co-executive producers: Winnie Tsang, Katie Kwan, Zhang Chunping, Zhang Qi, Xiong Ying, Li Hui, Jia Li, Wang Mei.

Crew: Director: Stanley Kwan. Screenplay: Jimmy Ngai. Camera (color, widescreen): Wang Boxue. Editors: William Chang, Shirley Yip. Music: Yu Yat Yiu, Edgar Hung.

With: Sammi Cheng, Gigi Leung, Bai Baihe, Qi Xi, Catherine Chau, Kiki Sheung, Angie Chiu, Bowie Lam, Kam Kwok Leung. (Cantonese dialogue)

More Film

  • Hillary Clinton - Sundance

    Hillary Clinton Gets Candid About Feminism, Beyonce and 'Little Women' (EXCLUSIVE)

    One of the breakout projects at this year’s Sundance Film Festival is “Hillary,” a four-hour docu-series about Hillary Clinton. The former first lady, Secretary of State and first woman presidential nominee from a major political party sat down for 35 hours of interviews with director Nanette Burstein, who also poured through exclusive footage from the [...]

  • Steven Garza appears in Boys State

    Apple and A24 Partner to Buy Documentary 'Boys State' Out of Sundance

    Apple and A24 have partnered to buy the Sundance documentary “Boys State,” Variety has confirmed. The sale, for $10 million, represents one of the biggest pacts ever for a non-fiction film. “Boys State,” a political coming-of-age story, follows annual rite of passage in which a thousand teenage boys from across Texas come together to build [...]

  • Sandy Powell Costume Design The Irishman

    Mayes C. Rubeo, Sandy Powell Lead Below-the-Line Surge in Women Oscar Noms

    The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences was quick to point out on Jan. 13 as the Oscar nominations were announced, that “A record 62 women were nominated, almost one-third of this year’s nominees.” Twenty of those below-the-line nominations were for women and minorities, including Sandy Powell, who secured her 15th nomination for “The [...]

  • Saoirse Ronan Awards Season Fashion

    Saoirse Ronan's Stylist Elizabeth Saltzman Creates 'Strong, Feminine Woman'

    Elizabeth Saltzman wanted Saoirse Ronan’s “Little Women” press tour looks to reflect her character: “A strong, feminine woman with a little masculinity mixed in.” In designing a Golden Globes dress, Saltzman spoke about Ronan with the Celine team. “We talked about Saoirse being effortless, sensual and cool — and not trying too hard,” she says. [...]

  • 1917 Movie

    George MacKay Talks '1917' and Filming in the Trenches

    George MacKay delivers a star-making performance in “1917.” After making his film debut at age 10 in the 2003 live-action “Peter Pan,” he played occasional film and TV roles and realized at age 19 “acting is what I wanted to do.” Since then, he’s appeared in an earlier WWI saga, “Private Peaceful,” and played Viggo [...]

  • Palm Springs Sundance

    Neon, Hulu Chasing Worldwide Rights Deal on Andy Samberg's 'Palm Springs'

    Tom Quinn’s Neon and streamer Hulu are looking to partner on a multi-million dollar, worldwide rights deal for Andy Samberg’s Sundance comedy “Palm Springs,” sources told Variety. Neon would take the film out theatrically while Hulu would retain rights for streaming customers around the world, said the insiders familiar with talks. One report valued the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content