You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘The Great Buster: A Celebration’

Peter Bogdanovich offers a by-the-book documentary about Buster Keaton that’s designed to introduce new audiences to the comic genius in time for new restorations.

Timed to coincide with Cohen Media’s restorations of Buster Keaton’s silent features, “The Great Buster: A Celebration” is a by-the-book documentary of the great comedian’s life and career clearly designed as an appetizer before the classic films are reissued. While Peter Bogdanovich’s enthusiasm for his subject is undeniable, in many cases his choice of talking heads remains questionable, unless being told that “Jackass 2” was influenced by the Great Stoneface really furthers an understanding of Keaton’s brilliance. Structured as a straightforward life story followed by an extended coda looking in detail at the features Cohen is restoring, “The Great Buster” can’t hold a candle to the 1987 three-part series “Buster Keaton: A Hard Act to Follow” but will make do as a decent DVD extra.

Long recognized, together with Charlie Chaplin and Harold Lloyd, as one of the true geniuses of comedy, Keaton’s life is a classic showbiz tale of hard work, great success, and then a painful professional and personal decline before recognition of his unique talents returned. Brought into his parents’ vaudeville act at a tender age, Buster was a pratfall pro long before he wore long pants, which made the transition to slapstick shorts an easy one. Teamed with the great Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle beginning in 1917, Keaton honed his straight-faced persona in a series of two-reelers that showed off his comic agility and expert timing. 1920 saw the release of his brilliant solo short “One Week,” which he co-directed, followed by a group of now classic comedies whose freshness has never faded (though the same can’t be said of some of the clips used here).

From 1923 he directed and starred in features like “Sherlock Jr.,” “The Navigator” and “The General,” masterpieces of inventiveness that will forever top lists of the world’s greatest comedies. However, a deeply unwise decision to sign over creative control to his brother-in-law Joseph Schenck and MGM led to a decline furthered by personal problems, not helped by MGM’s uncertain understanding of how to adapt Buster’s persona to sound. Heavy drinking together with a string of largely unmemorable films sent his career into a tailspin, and only the patience of his last wife Eleanor saw him through to a more fulfilling period and late-life recognition.

For biographical details, Bogdanovich uses scholar James Curtis, who intelligently discusses Keaton’s career, accompanied by a wealth of terrific photos from the comic’s earliest days. Dick Van Dyke is also a welcome presence, enthusiastically chatting about what made Buster unique, yet many of the other interviewees are of arguable usefulness, included for name recognition rather than an understanding of the comic and his films. Such is the case with Quentin Tarantino, who incorrectly says that all other male comedians of the era had the personae of weaklings, or Werner Herzog, intoning in Herzogian style that Keaton “was the essence of cinema.”

Clearly “The Great Buster” is hoping to attract younger audiences, for why else would Bogdanovich include Jon Watts talking about how “Spider-Man: Homecoming” was conceived with Keaton in mind? The parallels are stretched, to put it mildly. It would have been much better to have Bill Irwin, a physical comedian with clear performance links to Keaton, speak more about timing than Richard Lewis, especially when the latter ahistorically states that many of Buster’s gags had never been done before. Silent film comedy is such a rich and relatively unexplored subject, with even geniuses borrowing from each other all the time, that it’s impossible to lay claim to originality: What made Keaton different is that he made everything his own via a combination of hard work and sheer brilliance.

Clips used from the prints Cohen owns look fantastic, though too often sequences aren’t allowed to run through and we get too many choppy gags; for films that Cohen does not own the rights to, visual quality varies. Original music by the Mont Alto Motion Picture Orchestra is comfortably in keeping with traditional silent film accompaniment, but using snippets from the “William Tell Overture” or the “Ride of the Valkyries” is just plain wrong.

More Film

  • paranormal-activity-1

    Paramount, Blumhouse Announce Seventh 'Paranormal Activity' Movie

    Paramount Pictures and Jason Blum’s Blumhouse are teaming on a seventh “Paranormal Activity” movie. Paramount chief Jim Gianopulos announced the untitled project Wednesday during the studio’s CineEurope presentation in Barcelona. Plot details are also under wraps. The franchise was launched with 2007’s “Paranormal Activity,” a micro-budget film about a young couple who had who moved [...]

  • Steve Buscemi

    Steve Buscemi Joins Judd Apatow's Upcoming Pete Davidson Comedy (EXCLUSIVE)

    Steve Buscemi, Kevin Corrigan, Domenick Lombardozzi and Mike Vecchione have rounded out the cast of Universal’s untitled Judd Apatow comedy starring Pete Davidson. Marisa Tomei, Bill Burr, Bel Powley, Maude Apatow and Pamela Adlon had been previously announced. Apatow is directing from a script he co-wrote with Davidson and Dave Sirus. The film is a [...]

  • Viola Davis, Chadwick Boseman Starring in

    Viola Davis, Chadwick Boseman Starring in 'Ma Rainey's Black Bottom' for Netflix

    Viola Davis and Chadwick Boseman will star in the movie adaptation of the play “Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom” for Netflix. George C. Wolfe (“Lackawanna Blues”) will direct from a script by Ruben Santiago-Hudson, based on the award-winning play by August Wilson. Other cast include Glynn Turman, Colman Domingo (“If Beale Street Could Talk”) and Michael Potts. Denzel [...]

  • Crazy Bitches

    Why the CASE Act Will Empower Creatives to Fight the Horrors of Piracy

    Our horror film, “Crazy Bitches,” was released on Valentine’s Day 2015. We invested in an online marketing campaign that resulted in two times the industry clickthrough rate and 2.6M social media impressions in the week leading up to the release. So, we had reason to expect a successful return. What we didn’t count on was [...]

  • Alamo Drafthouse LA

    Alamo Drafthouse to Open in Downtown Los Angeles in July

    The Alamo Drafthouse Cinema chain is planning to open its first Los Angeles location with a “soft launch” in early July in the city’s downtown. The Texas-based chain, which has 38 locations, specializes food and drink service with unique programming. It announced Wednesday that the Los Angeles site, located at the Bloc, would offer an [...]

  • Max Landis Dropped by Manager Following

    Max Landis Dropped by Manager Following Sexual Assault Allegations

    Max Landis has been dropped as a client by his manager, a day after sexual assault allegations emerged against the  screenwriter. “I do not represent Max Landis,” Britton Rizzio at Writ Large Management told Variety in a statement. Landis is facing allegations of sexual abuse and psychological manipulation from eight women who told their stories [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content