×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Radu Jude Discusses Historical Guilt, Images’ Ability to Hide

Jude’s ‘The Dead Nation’ screens in Locarno’s Signs of Life section

Radu Jude’s found-footage film “The Dead Nation,” which screens at Ji.hlava International Documentary Film Festival, attempts a fragmentary account of Romania in the 1930s and 1940s, using an extensive photo archive by Costică Acsinte together with a voice-over reading of contemporary diary notes by the Jewish doctor Emil Dorian. A rare exception among recent Romanian slice-of-life films that strive for maximum authenticity, “The Dead Nation” uses the images with a historiographer’s skepticism about the comprehensiveness of what they evoke. The diary accounts fill in the gaps regarding the murderous anti-Semitism of the era, a harsh reality that the portraits of Romanians of the same time leave unrepresented.

While shaping the film, were you looking to contrast the visual material with the voice-over account? Do you see a contrast between how Romanians wanted to be represented and what the social realities were around World War II?
The best way to answer that is to explain how I started working on the film. I had the idea of turning the photographs into a film, or a slideshow, and at the same time I was doing research for my new project, which has to do with problems of representation of the past and, generally, the problems of collective memory regarding the fascist period of the Romanian past. This idea came from a sort of dissatisfaction: when 8,600 photographs, a huge number, were found from a period of time when a lot of terrible things happened which left very vague traces in these photographs, this seemed very troubling to me. When I realized that photographs show something and hide other things – and I think it’s more complex than you put it, they don’t only reveal how Romanians wanted to represent themselves – I wanted to show the connection between these things.

There are pragmatic reasons – geographical etc. – for why these things are missing, but they are missing nevertheless. For instance, the mass killing of Jews in 1941 in Iași is very well documented – by the Germans, to be fair, who had photo cameras and made photographic records of it. The task was not so much to find sources that document these matters – that are hard to represent anyway – but rather to pose a theoretical problem, though one with obvious practical repercussions: What does it mean to represent history based on a collection of documents – visual documents, in this case – which you have at your disposal? Why are we so stuck in analyzing images, be they photographic or cinematic, only from the perspective of what they show, and not what they hide?

How did you choose among Acsinte’s photographs, as well as the elements of the soundtrack, from the numerous possibilities you’ve had?
I was interested in the photographs which were dated, to show synchronicity with Dorian’s diary notes. Apart from that, I was drawn to those that were expressive – from an anthropologic or painterly point of view – and especially those notable for mise-en-scène, because they aren’t documents. They are studio photographs and Acsinte acted like a film director. There were three or four painted backdrops, an inventory of gestures – women held their arms along their body in a certain way, soldiers posed with their weapon, others had significant objects – maybe a cow or a bicycle. I thought it matches the discourse of the film: How much is fiction, how much is unwrought reality?

For the soundtrack, we borrowed from propaganda films and radio broadcasts. Some work the same way: They seem to be documents but they are fiction, and even poor quality fiction, since many use some very low propaganda. We chose them to function along with the images. Some are very far away from what the photos have to say, and their effect is ironic.

How much more tolerant do you think Romanian society has become, in our days?
What happened recently with the homophobic Coalition for the Family shows that the Church isn’t separate from the state, as would be normal in a secular European state. With my recent project, I’ve discovered there is large nostalgia for the fascist period of Romanian history. When I talk to people about Marshal Antonescu and say that he was a war criminal, they reply: ‘So what?! He ruled with a firm grip on things.’

What has made you interested in found-footage films?
It is a little-known genre in Romania, even to cinephiles and critics, with a handful of exceptions. At first, I saw a couple of films – Andrei Ujică, Sergei Losznitsa, the ones I’d heard about – and thought I had exhausted them. Searching for them further – and for this, the Internet is a very useful tool – you can discover a whole continent of found-footage films which didn’t have the opportunity to be screened in big festivals and have the proper critical reception, so they were soon forgotten. There is no canon for these works.

More Film

  • BTS' ‘Burn the Stage’ Claims Biggest

    BTS' 'Burn the Stage' Movie Claims Biggest-Ever Event Cinema Box Office Haul

    BTS concert movie has now garnered the biggest-ever box office haul for an event cinema release. “Burn the Stage: The Movie” has raked in $18.5 million around the world, distributor Trafalgar Releasing told Variety. The film follows Korean boy-band sensations BTS on their Wings tour, which was seen by more than 500,000 fans. The movie [...]

  • Kevin Hart Oscars Gay Tweet Controversy

    10 Things Every Celebrity Should Do When Making a Public Apology (Guest Column)

    It’s true. PR people are often called “apologists.” I don’t bristle at that description, because apologizing and getting it right is a crucial skill set for today’s crisis manager. Apologies are hard to do — they are humbling, irritating and often required during periods of high emotional pressure and agitation. I promise, we live in [...]

  • Eurimages Winning Project ‘The Jungle’ At

    8horses Producer Tolga Dilsiz Talks Eurimages Award Winner ‘The Jungle’ at Ventana Sur

    Swiss director Matthias Huser, whose 2014 Kaurismaki-ish debut, “They Chased Me Through Arizona” drew fans at Locarno, is with his 8horses producer Tolga Dilsiz participating in Ventana Sur’s project section, where the two are looking to court potential co-producers on their upcoming feature, “The Jungle.” At September’s San Sebastian Festival, the project won the Co-production [...]

  • Veteran thesp adds voice to Federico

    Oscar-Nominated Argentine Actress Norma Aleandro Heads to ‘Paradise’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    Oscar-nominated Argentine actress Norma Aleandro will add her voice to “The Paradise” (El Paraiso), a noirish 2.5D animated feature directed by Federico Moreno Breser. Produced by Fernando Sirianni’s Nomad VFX, the project will take part in the Animation! Pitching Sessions in Ventana Sur this week. Set in 1920s Rosario – a city known as the [...]

  • Yellow Vests anti government protests with

    French Box Office Takes a Hit From 'Yellow Vests' Protests

    The violent “Yellow Vests” protests that have rocked France in recent weeks have also hit the movie business, dragging down local box-office performance in spite of several hit titles such as “Bohemian Rhapsody” and “Le Grand Bain.” In Paris, where demonstrators rioted on three consecutive Saturdays, theatrical admissions recorded on Dec. 8 were about 20% lower than [...]

  • Oscars: 10 Standouts for This Year’s

    Oscars: 10 Standouts for This Year’s Best Picture Race

    With all of this year’s Oscar narratives thoroughly dissected and each of the contenders mapped out, it’s time for the first real assessment of this season’s best picture race in this space. Below are the top 10 players as we see it, with nominations just over a month away. (Also check out In Contention’s full [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content