×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

How YouTube’s Far Right Is Using Classic Influencer Tactics to Promote Its Views

Hardly a week goes by without conspiracy theories finding their way into YouTube’s top search results. The Google-owned video service has been trying to fight back by banning accounts like those of Infowars.com and promoting authoritative sources, but a new study suggests that many far-right YouTubers are largely unaffected by those measures. That’s in part because these video producers are using classic influencer tactics to promote their views across a tight-knit network.

To figure out how far-right YouTubers reach audiences on the platform, Rebecca Lewis from the New York-based nonprofit Data & Society recently analyzed a network of 61 influencers across 81 channels. Some of the YouTubers included in Lewis’ analysis are widely known as fringe right-wing activists, including Milo Yiannopolous, Richard Spencer, Mike Cernovich and Gavin McInnes.

CREDIT: Courtesy of Data & Society

A subset of the YouTube personalities analyzed for Data & Society’s new report.

However, Lewis quickly noticed that these right-wing YouTubers frequently appeared on other shows, including some hosted by more mainstream conservative and libertarian YouTubers. That’s why she also included YouTubers like conservative commentator Candace Owens, comedian Joe Rogan and libertarian talk show host Dave Rubin in her analysis.

Plotting out the guest appearances of far-right YouTubers, she discovered a tight-knit “alternative influence network.” “Many of these YouTubers are less defined by any single ideology than they are by a ‘reactionary’ position: a general opposition to feminism, social justice, or left-wing politics,” she wrote in her report.

In that network, self-proclaimed libertarian and conservative YouTubers play a key role in promoting racist and white nationalist views. That’s because in many instances, they host members of the far right on their shows without effectively challenging their points of view. “There is a really slippery nature to this,” Lewis said during a media call Tuesday.

Across the network of YouTube channels analyzed by Lewis, she found a few recurring motives: Far-right YouTubers regularly cast themselves as an alternative to mainstream media, and they paint a picture of political persecution against conservative and far-right points of view.

But while that may not sound new to anyone who has ever watched conservative talking heads on network TV, there is something novel in the way far-right YouTubers propagate these views on the service: They’re relying on the very tactics used by beauty bloggers and other influencers on YouTube. From the report:

“One of the most effective ways to network on YouTube is by referencing and including other people in video content. In fact, how-to manuals for building influence on YouTube often list collaborations as one of the most effective strategies.”

The challenge for YouTube is that it is much harder to police thee types of influencer techniques. Far-right YouTubers know to avoid words that would get them banned, and their guest appearances on popular shows help to bring their ideas to millions of viewers. “YouTube has a much more complex problem to solve around trust and content,” said Data & Society’s media manipulation research lead Joan Donovan.

However, the report also suggest that there are concrete steps that YouTube could do. Instead of just punishing white supremacists when they cross the line, the service should also take steps against the shows giving these fringe voices a podium.

“The platform should not only assess what channels say in their content, but also who they host and what their guests say,” Lewis wrote in her report. “In a media environment consisting of networked influencers, YouTube must respond with policies that account for influence and amplification, as well as social networks.”

YouTube responded Tuesday by pointing out that it has implemented stricter rules on monetization since the conclusion of the report:

“YouTube is an open platform where anyone can choose to post videos to a global audience, subject to our Community Guidelines, which we enforce rigorously. Additionally, we’ve made updates over the past year to tighten our monetization policies and improve our enforcement against hate speech. Since this research concluded in April 2018, we’ve made more updates to which channels have access to monetization features and deployed advanced machine learning technology to tackle more hate speech in comment features. We continue to expand this work and appreciate input from all researchers.”

Update: This post was updated with a response from YouTube.

More Digital

  • Twitter Jack Dorsey

    Trump Meets With Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey After Complaining of Bias

    WASHINGTON — Less than 12 hours after complaining that Twitter doesn’t “treat me well as a Republican,” President Trump met with the company’s CEO, Jack Dorsey, and indicated that they would be “keeping an open dialogue.” “Great meeting this afternoon at the @WhiteHouse with @Jack from @Twitter. Lots of subjects discussed regarding their platform, and [...]

  • Wanda Sykes Silicon Valleywood

    Wanda Sykes on Doing Business With Netflix: 'They Moved That Comma'

    MENLO PARK, Calif. — Wanda Sykes wears a lot of hats as a comedian, writer, producer and entrepreneur, and that gives her a keen sense of the ever-growing content marketplace. She also has a very clear understanding of what she’s worth in dollars and cents, as she shared Tuesday in her Q&A at Variety’s Silicon [...]

  • Snap CEO Evan Spiegel

    Snapchat Gains 4 Million Users in Q1 as Snap Beats Earnings Estimates

    Snap topped Wall Street estimates on the top and bottom lines in the first quarter of 2019 — and the still-unprofitable company managed to show an uptick in Snapchat users for the first time in a year. Revenue for the quarter was $320 million, up 39% year over year, while it narrowed its net loss [...]

  • Jim Lanzone

    CBS Interactive Chief Jim Lanzone: 'We Have a Tiger by the Tail' With Streaming Growth

    MENLO PARK, Calif. — CBS All Access can’t serve up addressable advertising inventory fast enough for marketers hungry to reach consumers watching premium video online. That was the upbeat outlook shared by CBS Interactive CEO Jim Lanzone during his keynote address on Tuesday at Variety’s Silicon Valleywood presented by PwC. “There’s not a form of advertising [...]

  • Fidji SimoFacebook Watch Executive panel, TCA

    Facebook Exec Fidji Simo: Restricting Facebook Live Could Hurt Minorities

    Facebook vice president Fidji Simo told the audience of Variety’s Silicon Valleywood presented by PwC on Tuesday that the company was carefully evaluating how to increase the safety of its live streaming feature in the wake of the New Zealand massacre. “We know that we need to do more to protect people on live,” she said, [...]

  • Reddit

    Reddit Rolls Out Collections and Events Posts to All Communities (EXCLUSIVE)

    After testing them with “Game of Thrones” fans and a few dozen other Subreddits for the past couple of months, Reddit is now launching two new post types to its entire user base: Events will help communities with discussions about TV show episodes, awards shows, breaking news and more; Collections will help to curate posts, [...]

  • silicon valleywood Wanda Sykes

    Silicon Valleywood Confab Will Mine Maximum Data Strategies

    As Apple’s recent star-studded event for its new TV streaming service demonstrated, the worlds of entertainment and technology are becoming increasingly intertwined — a convergence Variety will explore during its inaugural Silicon Valleywood Summit on April 23 in Menlo Park. Entertainment leaders will join tech giants on the latter industry’s home turf to discuss how [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content