×

Homepod Reviews: What the Critics Are Saying

Apple is beginning to sell its Homepod this week, a device that is directly competing with smart speakers like the Amazon Echo and the Google Home.

How does the Homepod compare to these competitors? A first wave of hands-on reviews offers some clues, with many reviewers giving the device high notes for its audio quality. However, many also had some serious concerns about the Homepod’s smarts, and its exclusive tie-in with Apple’s services.

The Verge’s Nilay Patel really liked the Homepod’s smart sound features, which tune bass response and directional audio based on both the music it is playing as well as its room placement. But he lamented that Homepod users can’t ask the device to play music from Spotify or Sirius XM, and seemed baffled that Siri on the Homepod wasn’t even able to set two timers at once. Patel’s verdict:

“The Homepod sounds incredible, but not so world-bendingly amazing that you should switch away from Spotify, or accept Siri’s frustrating limitations as compared to Alexa. Apple’s ecosystem lock-in is actively working against a remarkable product with the Homepod.”

Techcrunch’s Matthew Panzarino praised the speaker’s sound, but remarked that it didn’t get as loud as some competing products. He liked quizzing Siri about musical information, and noted that the speaker’s microphones were “exceptionally well” at catching voice commands. His final verdict on the Homepod was more or less coming down to whether consumers use Apple Music or not:

“If you don’t like Apple Music, don’t buy a Homepod. The Homepod sounds great but on the surface, it’s debatable whether it’s great enough to justify the limitations. (…) However, if you’re an Apple Music subscriber, the equation instantly plops in the other direction: it’s near useless to buy any other speaker and this one sounds great, so why not.”

BuzzFeed’s Nicole Nguyen liked the tight integration with the iPhone, Siri’s voice recognition, and the ability to send texts and Whatsapp messages with her voice. She also enjoyed the sound, but noted that it wasn’t necessarily the breakthrough speaker it’s set out to be, at least not for every musical taste and environment. And she took some issue with the $349 price tag:

“The Homepod is a hard sell when you consider the price and flexibility of its competitors. The Homepod is designed for someone with 100% Apple product buy-in, who lives in the iOS/Mac ecosystem, who subscribes to Apple Music, and who just wants basic smart speaker features.”

USA Today’s Ed Baig found that the Homepod sounded very similar to Google’s Home Max speaker, while lacking in the smarts department. But as an iPhone user, he liked the speaker nonetheless:

“Homepod may be a latecomer on the smart loudspeaker scene, but Apple’s entry onto the dance floor is about to liven up the party. At least for well-heeled Apple die-hards who share my passion for all kinds of music.”

The New York Times’ Brian X. Chen on the other hand was pretty underwhelmed by the Homepod, noting that the device didn’t know how to help him with basic kitchen tasks, couldn’t order an Uber and kept serving up music he didn’t like. “Don’t rush to buy it,” he advised:

“Siri on Homepod is embarrassingly inadequate, even though that is the primary way you interact with it. Siri is sorely lacking in capabilities compared with Amazon’s Alexa and Google’s Assistant.”

More Digital

  • YouTube Originals A Heist With Markiplier

    YouTube's First Interactive Special Stars Markiplier and Has 31 Possible Endings

    YouTube is diving into interactive entertainment with a new special featuring popular gaming creator Markiplier as a black-clad super-criminal who tries to steal a priceless artifact from the world’s most secure museum. Along the lines of Netflix’s “Black Mirror: Bandersnatch,” viewers will control the outcome of the interactive movie, “A Heist With Markiplier.” The first-person [...]

  • Euphoria HBO

    'It's an Explosion': Inside the Rising Costs of Making a Scripted TV Series

    When Apple TV plus launches on Nov. 1, it will do so with what’s arguably the most expensive new-series lineup in TV history. Among the streamer’s initial offerings are the drama “The Morning Show,” bearing a price tag believed to be more than $15 million an episode, and the dystopian sci-fi series “See,” which is [...]

  • Erika Nardini - Barstool Sports

    Listen: Barstool Sports CEO Learns From Digital Media's Past Mistakes

    Long before she became CEO of Barstool Sports, Erika Nardini had a front-row seat to the early days of the internet advertising world and she has no intention of repeating its errors. Over a career that saw stops at AOL, Microsoft, Yahoo and Demand Media, she watched as the digital powerhouses of yesteryear cluttered the [...]

  • Dany Garcia

    Dany Garcia Invests in Privacy-Focused Social Media Service MeWe

    Dany Garcia, CEO of Seven Bucks Productions and founder, CEO and chairwoman of the Garcia Companies and TGC Management, has taken a minority investment in MeWe, a startup that positions itself as a social network rival to Facebook — but one that gives users full control over their own data and privacy. Garcia co-founded Seven [...]

  • Meg Whitman and Jeffrey Katzenberg Quibi

    Quibi Says It Has Sold Out $150 Million First-Year Ad Inventory

    Nearly six months before Quibi is slated to hit the market, a cluster of large advertisers has committed millions in ad spending to the ambitious — and untested — premium mobile-video brainchild of Jeffrey Katzenberg. Quibi announced that it has sold out its $150 million advertising inventory for the first year. The startup’s category-exclusive ad partners [...]

  • Mackenzie Davis Terminator Dark Fate

    ‘Terminator: Dark Fate’ Tops Studios’ TV Ad Spending

    In this week’s edition of the Variety Movie Commercial Tracker, powered by the always-on TV ad measurement and attribution company iSpot.tv, Paramount Pictures claims the top spot in spending with “Terminator: Dark Fate.” Ads placed for the sci-fi action film had an estimated media value of $6.81 million through Sunday for 796 national ad airings [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content