×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Judge Blocks Redbox From Selling Disney Download Codes

A federal judge on Thursday issued an injunction to block Redbox from selling digital download codes of Disney films.

The ruling was a win for Disney, which has been trying to block the kiosk rental company from selling the codes since December. Redbox began selling the codes last fall at a considerable discount compared to prices on Amazon or iTunes. The company obtained the codes by buying DVD combo packs, which include DVD and Blu-ray discs as well as download codes, and then splitting them up and selling them separately.

Disney argued that Redbox was engaging in copyright infringement by encouraging its customers to make an unauthorized copy of its films. Redbox countered that Disney lost control of the digital copy of the film once it sold the combo pack, and Redbox was free to re-sell it, just as it does with the physical discs.

Disney’s first attempt to shut down the service failed in February. Judge Dean Pregerson ruled that the warning on the combo packs, indicating that “codes are not for sale or transfer,” was not explicit enough to prohibit Redbox from reselling the codes. Disney then rewrote the language for the release of “Black Panther.” The new language is much more detailed, and asserts that Disney owns the digital copy and licenses it only to the buyer of the combo pack. Disney then filed a second request for an injunction.

Pregerson ruled Thursday that the new language is sufficient, and granted the injunction.

“Because Redbox did not obtain an ownership right to any digital content when it purchased Combo Packs, Disney has adequately shown that it is likely to succeed on its claim that Redbox encouraged Redbox customers to infringe Disney’s copyrights by redeeming Codes in violation of the license terms set forth on the redemption sites,” Pregerson wrote.

The injunction applies to any combo packs that use the language on the “Black Panther” DVDs.

Redbox has argued that Disney’s lawsuit is an attempt to shut down a low-cost competitor, and has sued over Disney’s efforts to prevent Redbox from buying DVD packs. In April, Redbox alleged that one of its employees had been threatened with jail time for trying to buy “Coco” DVDs at a big-box retailer.

Update: In a statement following the ruling, Redbox emphasized that it applies only to the revised “Black Panther” license terms, and not to the terms found on earlier DVD packs such as “Coco.” Redbox has avoided selling “Black Panther” download codes.

“Redbox remains free to sell codes for those prior titles. This morning’s ruling is limited to digital codes for certain titles, like Black Panther, that contain new disclosures, but were distributed after the 19 titles listed in Disney’s complaint,” the company said. “Redbox has never attempted to sell, and had no plans to sell, digital codes for Black Panther. Disney, therefore, has not been damaged by Redbox’s business practices, and the ruling compels no change in Redbox’s business practices… The court’s decision once again maintains Redbox’s stance as an advocate for the consumer. We look forward to finalizing our victories in court.”

More Biz

  • Byron Allen

    Byron Allen's Discrimination Suit Against Comcast Should Be Allowed to Move Forward

    More than anything, the Supreme Court justices seemed bemused. Comcast executives and entrepreneur Byron Allen came to the nation’s high court on Nov. 13 to duke it out over the racial discrimination case that Allen’s Entertainment Studios has pursued since 2015.  But the question put before the court was a narrow issue of legal precedent [...]

  • Courtney Kemp Agboh'Power' TV show final

    Christine Baranski, Karey Burke and Courtney Kemp Set for Brandon Tartikoff Awards

    Christine Baranski, “Power” creator and showrunner Courtney Kemp and ABC Entertainment chief Karey Burke are among the five recipients set for the 2020 Brandon Tartikoff Awards, to be handed out in January as part of the annual NATPE conference in Miami. Jeff Zucker, chairman of news and sports for WarnerMedia and president of CNN Worldwide, [...]

  • BMI’s Charlie Feldman Retiring After 31

    BMI’s Charlie Feldman Retiring After 31 Years With Company

    Charlie Feldman, BMI’s Vice President of Creative in New York, announced today that he will retire from the company at the end of the year. A 31-year veteran of BMI, Feldman will continue to consult for the company in the new year, according to the announcement. Mike O’Neill, President and CEO of BMI, said, “I [...]

  • Chuck Lorre, Scott Stuber to Keynote

    Chuck Lorre, Scott Stuber to Keynote Variety Innovate Summit

    “The Big Bang Theory” co-creator and TV producer Chuck Lorre and the head of Netflix Films Scott Stuber will keynote Variety’s Innovate Summit presented by PwC on Dec. 5 in Los Angeles. Lorre will share the career experiences that lead to his co-creating and executive producing “The Big Bang Theory,” “Young Sheldon” and “Mom.” Lorre’s extensive [...]

  • Adele Haenel Adèle Haenel

    Accusations Against Roman Polanski, Other Filmmakers Propel #MeToo in France

    When the Harvey Weinstein scandal broke two years ago, the news was mostly met in France with a Gallic shrug. Screen icon Catherine Deneuve even denounced the #MeToo movement as creating a “totalitarian” environment. But bombshell accusations this month from actors Adèle Haenel and Valentine Monnier may finally have turned the tide in the local film [...]

  • Subhash Chandra Chairman of the Zee

    Another 16% Slice of India’s Zee to be Sold by Essel

    The Essel Group is to sell a further 16.5% stake in Zee Entertainment Enterprise Limited, India’s largest private sector broadcast group. The debt-reduction move comes just months after Essel auctioned off an 11% tranche of ZEEL. “The Group seeks to sell up to 16.5% stake in ZEEL to financial investors, in order to repay loan [...]

  • Frank Cicha

    Listen: Why Fox Television Stations Embraced Trial and Error in Daytime

    Frank Cicha, head of programming for Fox Television Stations, saw the future coming nearly a decade ago when Fox’s TV station group committed many millions to land syndication rights to “The Big Bang Theory” back in 2010. Even then, it was clear that big hits on the scale of “Big Bang” were going to be [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content