×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Redbox Claims Disney Suit Is a Bid to Block Digital Competition

Redbox has fired back against Disney’s efforts to block it from selling download codes, alleging that Disney’s copyright lawsuit is simply an effort to thwart a competitor.

Disney sued in December and sought an injunction to bar Redbox from distributing digital download codes for Disney films. Redbox does not have a distribution agreement with Disney. Instead, it buys up DVD and Blu-ray combo packs, which include codes to download the films, and then sells those codes separately through its network of kiosks.

Disney contends that Redbox is violating the terms of sale of the combo packs, which — at least in some instances — include specific language stating that “Codes are not for sale or transfer.” Redbox offers digital downloads at a significant discount from the download prices available on other services.

Redbox, however, argues that the codes should not be treated any differently than the physical discs, which Redbox is entitled to distribute just as if it were any other video rental business. In its argument opposing Disney’s request for an injunction, Redbox invokes the “first sale doctrine,” which holds that a copyright owner cannot prohibit a purchaser from reselling a copy of a work, such as a used book.

The key question is whether selling the download codes and allowing customers to download a copy of a movie, constitutes “reproduction” under federal copyright law. Disney contends that it does, and that Redbox is infringing on its exclusive right to distribute its works. Redbox argues that customers are not creating a new copy of the film — they are simply redeeming the copy that has already been sold to Redbox.

Redbox also argues that Disney is seeking to clear the field of rivals to its own forthcoming streaming service.

“Plaintiffs seek to stifle competition to more smoothly launch Disney’s own digital content streaming service, maximize the price other services like iTunes and Amazon (and their customers) pay for Disney movies, and secure a greater market share for Hulu — the viewing service Disney will control as part of its $52 billion acquisition of 21st Century Fox,” argued Michael A. Geibelson, Redbox’s attorney. “These anti-consumer and anti-competitive ends do not support a preliminary injunction, and neither do the plaintiffs’ evidence or applicable law.”

Redbox says it has invested $700,000 in launching its digital download service, which would be squandered should an injunction be issued. Disney’s motion for an injunction is set to be heard on Feb. 5 before Judge Dean Pregerson in Los Angeles federal court.

The suit comes as Disney and the other major studios, along with Netflix and Amazon, are also seeking to stamp out streaming devices that use Kodi software to enable streaming of copyrighted works.

Redbox Disney by gmaddaus on Scribd

More Biz

  • Santos Dumont

    Mipcom: International TV Output Picture Changing for U.S. Majors

    The global import-export strategies of the U.S. majors are in flux as the world’s major content companies gather this week in Cannes for the annual Mipcom market and conference. Disney, WarnerMedia and the other handful of media conglomerates that control the vast majority of the U.S. market are in the midst of a radical transition [...]

  • Jane Fonda Arrested

    Jane Fonda Arrested in D.C. During Climate Change Protest

    Jane Fonda was arrested on Friday in Washington, D.C. during a climate change protest, Variety has confirmed. “Today, the United States Capitol Police arrested 16 individuals for unlawfully demonstrating on the East Front of the U.S. Capitol,” Capitol Police communications director Eva Malecki said in a statement to Variety. She added that all were charged with crowding, [...]

  • Firefighters battle the Saddleridge fire in

    Saddleridge Fire Forces Evacuations, TV Production Shutdowns

    A wind-whipped wildfire has spread across parts of the San Fernando Valley north of Los Angeles and forced evacuations, threatened thousands of homes and closed parts of five major freeways. The Saddleridge fire has prompted mandatory evacuations affecting about 100,000 people between Porter Ranch, Granada Hills and Sylmar. Mandatory evacuations have been called for about [...]

  • amazon-studios

    Amazon Studios Pacts With Howard University for Entertainment Education Program

    Howard University and Amazon Studios have teamed to launch Howard Entertainment, a two-semester program based in Los Angeles that offers Howard students the ability to take courses, network with Amazon industry partners and gain work experience in the entertainment industry. The inaugural program will begin January. The curriculum and immersive experiences will start with academic [...]

  • Remembering Prince

    Prince Estate Slams Trump Campaign for Playing ‘Purple Rain’ at Minneapolis Rally

    The Prince Estate strongly criticized the Trump campaign for playing “Purple Rain” at a Minneapolis rally in which the president made multiple aggressive and juvenile comments about Democratic leaders, Bruce Springsteen, Beyonce and Jay-Z. In a statement posted on social media, the Estate wrote, “President Trump played Prince’s ‘Purple Rain’ tonight at a campaign event [...]

  • Charlie Rose Sexual Harassment

    Charlie Rose Wins Dismissal of Retaliation Claim in Harassment Suit

    A New York judge on Thursday dismissed a claim that Charlie Rose retaliated against three female employees who complained of sexual harassment. Judge Doris Ling-Cohan found that while Rose had allegedly disparaged the women — calling one a “f—ing idiot” and another a “f—ing kindergartner” — his comments did not amount to retaliation under the [...]

  • James Murdoch

    James Murdoch's Lupa Systems Takes Minority Stake in Vice (Report)

    James Murdoch has purchased a minority stake in Vice Media, the once-upstart brand that is trying to reconfigure itself as many prominent digital-media brand grapple with a wave of consolidation, according to a new report. The Financial Times reported that Murdoch’s investment vehicle, Lupa Systems, has secured a small ownership stake in Vice. A spokeswoman [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content