New York Attorneys Doubt That Weinstein Case Will Be Dismissed

The case against Harvey Weinstein is headed for a moment of truth on Thursday, as the disgraced producer’s attorney is set to urge a Manhattan judge to dismiss five charges of rape and sexual assault.

Weinstein’s lead attorney, Ben Brafman, has been hammering away at the case in 234 pages of legal filings submitted over the last six weeks. Brafman has accused the alleged victims of lying and alleged that the D.A.’s office and the NYPD withheld evidence from the grand jury. The whole case, he argues, has been tainted by misconduct and should be thrown out.

Brafman has kicked up a lot of dust and made a lot of headlines, creating a sense that the prosecution is in serious jeopardy. But the Manhattan D.A.’s office seems confident that the five charges against Weinstein will proceed to trial, and some New York defense attorneys seem to agree.

“The indictment will not be dismissed,” predicted Steve Raiser, a criminal defense attorney in New York, who reviewed the pleadings. “While I disagree with the standard in New York, a prosecutor is generally not obligated to present evidence favorable to the defendant at the grand jury.”

Daniel Hochheiser, another criminal defense attorney, said that Brafman’s chance of success is “small.”

“The grand jury is traditionally a one-sided legal mechanism, in which the prosecutor is judge and jury,” Hochheiser said. “I don’t know that the defense is going to gain traction in terms of a dismissal.”

Judge James Burke is hearing the case and will rule on the motion. Burke was a prosecutor in the Manhattan D.A.’s office for 12 years before being appointed to the bench by Mayor Rudolph Giuliani in 2001. He has since been reappointed twice.

Defense attorneys who have appeared before him describe him as “tough,” and some say he tends to see issues from the D.A.’s point of view.

“His reputation is someone who is probably a little more prosecutorial leaning, because of his background,” said attorney Lori Cohen. “I’ve always found him to be someone who will consider the issues. He won’t discard them out of hand… He’s straight-up.”

Jeffrey Lichtman, who has represented a number of high-profile defendants in New York, said that Burke is “tough and fair,” and an “independent thinker.” He said that Burke may be taken aback by the alleged misconduct in the D.A.’s office.

“It’s going to take a strong judge to do what’s right and dismiss the case,” Lichtman said, adding that Weinstein “has been pretty badly abused here.”

Asked to make a prediction about the ruling, Lichtman said, “You have to assume the case will not be tossed. I think the case deserves to be tossed, but I wouldn’t hold your breath.”

Cohen said the failure to turn over exculpatory evidence — known as a Brady violation — is “more common than you would think,” and that courts rarely issue stiff penalties for it.

“These kinds of Brady violations happen over and over and over again to people who you guys never write about,” she said. “I love when some rich famous guy gets arrested, and there’s exculpatory material (that isn’t turned over). I’ve been dealing with that with poor people for years.”

Should Brafman beat the odds and prevail, the judge may allow prosecutors to present the case all over again to the grand jury. If he does not persuade Burke to dismiss the case, Brafman may still be able to plant the idea among future jurors that the case has been tainted.

In his pleadings, Brafman has given a preview of a trial argument that Weinstein and his accusers had consensual affairs. In a trial, Brafman would also be able to cross-examine Det. Nicholas DiGaudio, who prosecutors say dissuaded a witness from giving exculpatory testimony, and who has been removed from the case.

Attorneys say the judge will likely want to defer those issues to jurors rather than decide the case himself.

“It’s unlikely a judge is going to dismiss a high-profile rape case and effectively make himself the finder of fact,” Hochheiser said. “The judge may chastise the prosecution for it, or the police, but I don’t see him dismissing it.”

More Biz

  • Tokyo Film Festival and Market Choose

    Tokyo Film Festival and Market Set Separate Dates in 2019

    The Tokyo International Film Festival and its accompanying rights market, TIFFCOM, will be held on separate dates this year. Some film executives may have to choose to attend one or the other. The film festival Wednesday announced that it will be held from Monday, Oct 28 to Tues, Nov. 5. Previously, the TIFFCOM market said [...]

  • Jeremy Vuernick

    Capitol Music Group Promotes Jeremy Vuernick to Executive VP of A&R

    Jeremy Vuernick has been promoted to Executive Vice President of A&R for Capitol Music Group, it was announced today by CMG COO Michelle Jubelirer and president Ashley Newton. In his elevated position, Vuernick will draw upon his broad experience as an A&R executive to sign and develop artists for the company, as well as oversee recording projects for new and [...]

  • Darnell Strom

    Darnell Strom to Lead UTA's Newly Created Culture and Leadership Division

    Darnell Strom has joined UTA and is set to lead its newly created Culture and Leadership division. Strom will represent and work with existing and new UTA clients who want to expand their diverse businesses and cultural influence at the intersection of entertainment, media, entrepreneurship, politics, the arts, and thought leadership. Strom brings years of [...]


    British Lawmakers Reject Prime Minister's Brexit Plan, Heightening Uncertainty

    British lawmakers have resoundingly rejected Prime Minister Theresa May’s terms for the U.K.’s withdrawal from the European Union, heightening the country’s sense of uncertainty and paralysis less than two months before the exit is supposed to take effect. Parliament rejected May’s Brexit plan by a 432-202-vote Tuesday evening, one of the biggest parliamentary defeats in [...]

  • Dan Cohen nonesuch records

    Nonesuch Promotes Dan Cohen to Senior VP of Marketing

    Dan Cohen has been named Nonesuch Records’ senior vice president of marketing, the company announced today. In his new role, Cohen oversees marketing, sales, publicity, new media, and content creation for the long-running Warner Music Group label. Cohen reports to Nonesuch President David Bither and is based at the label’s headquarters in New York. Cohen [...]

  • hollywood debt

    Can Hollywood's Biggest Media Companies Avoid Getting Crushed by Debt?

    Randall Stephenson, AT&T’s chairman-CEO, summoned all of his folksy Oklahoma earnestness as he made an enthusiastic pitch to Wall Street analysts about the telephone company’s bold efforts to transform itself into a multimedia powerhouse. It was late November, less than six months after AT&T had wrapped up its $85 billion acquisition of Time Warner. But [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content