Manhattan D.A. Accuses Weinstein Lawyer of Seeking a ‘Public Circus’

The Manhattan District Attorney’s Office accused Harvey Weinstein’s attorney on Monday of seeking to create a “public circus,” as prosecutors push back on Weinstein’s effort to have his sexual assault case dismissed.

Weinstein’s attorney, Ben Brafman, has asked the court to hold an evidentiary hearing on alleged prosecutorial misconduct in the case. Brafman wants the opportunity to question New York City Police Department Det. Nicholas DiGaudio and prosecutor Joan Illuzzi-Orbon in order to bolster his argument for a dismissal. In a brief filed Monday, Assistant District Attorney Kevin Wilson accused Brafman of attempting to try the case through the media.

“The only reason the defendant wants a hearing is to provide a public circus that will further the public relations campaign the defendant has been waging from the outset of this case,” Wilson wrote.

Prosecutors agreed last month to dismiss one of six counts against Weinstein, after it emerged that DiGaudio had failed to inform the D.A.’s office of potentially exculpatory evidence on that count. The count involves Lucia Evans, who told the New Yorker last year that Weinstein forced her to perform oral sex on him at his office in 2004.

A friend of Evans’ later told police that Evans had given a contradictory account of the encounter, suggesting that it was in fact consensual. Prosecutors have said that DiGaudio discouraged the friend from coming forward in a way that would undermine the case, saying “less is more.”

Brafman has argued that the disclosure taints the grand jury process, and the entire case ought to be dismissed. Should the judge refuse to toss the case, Brafman wants to question DiGaudio on the stand as to whether he coached the two remaining accusers on their accounts. Brafman also wants to explore whether prosecutors in fact were informed by DiGaudio of the friend’s exculpatory account, which would indicate that they had improperly withheld evidence from the defense, and which would also jeopardize the case. Last month, the New York Post cited sources claiming that DiGaudio asserts that he did, in fact, inform prosecutors of the issue.

In the brief, Wilson argues that the issues regarding the sixth count do not affect the other five charges.

“The remaining charges were supported by competent and ample evidence: evidence that was completely independent of the proof presented in count six,” Wilson wrote.

Wilson also states that Brafman’s suggestion that DiGaudio may have coached the other witnesses relies on “pure speculation.”

“There are no facts that could be determined at a hearing that would be relevant to the evaluations of the sufficiency of the remaining counts in the indictment,” he wrote.

Brafman fired back in a statement: “Nothing in the DA’s response gives us any more confidence in the integrity of the Grand Jury’s proceedings, and we anticipate filing a formal reply after the Thanksgiving Holiday. As for the hearing that the People fear will become a ‘circus’ — it is a circus that they created with the DA and the NYPD calling each other liars.”

The next hearing in the case is set for Dec. 20.

More Biz

  • best airlines ranked inflight entertainment

    Holiday Travel Survey Reveals Airlines With Best In-Flight Entertainment

    There are many ways to pass the time if you’re in the air, but for most people, settling in with a glass of wine and a movie is the preferred way to fly. But not all airlines share the same script when it comes to entertainment offerings. A new survey from the website, CableTV.com, ranked [...]

  • Ventana Sur Rocks with Sales, Mass

    Ventana Sur Rocks with Sales, Mass Attendance, Structural Growth

    BUENOS AIRES — Celebrating its 10th anniversary with a huge hike in attendance to over 4,000 accredited delegates, the 2018 Ventana Sur will go down in history on multiple counts: Sales and pick-ups on movies which combined social comment and entertainment value, increasingly the new foreign-language movie standard; new sections, led by a Proyecta co-production [...]

  • Jennifer Lawrence Harvey Weinstein

    Harvey Weinstein Bragged of Sex With Jennifer Lawrence, Lawsuit Claims

    Harvey Weinstein was hit with a lawsuit Friday from an actress who claims he forcibly performed oral sex on her, repeatedly masturbated in front of her, and threatened to harm her career if she objected. According to the suit, Weinstein pushed her to the ground during a meeting in his office in 2013. He then [...]

  • Times Up Hollywood

    Time's Up Entertainment Announces New Industry Mentoring Initiative

    Time’s Up Entertainment, an affiliate of the Time’s Up coalition of women across industries working to improve workplace safety, has announced the “Who’s in the Room” industry mentoring initiative. The program’s goal is to increase the presence of people of color from diverse backgrounds in the entertainment industry’s executive ranks. Funded by a $500,000 grant from [...]

  • Tom Cruise as Ethan Hunt in

    Paramount Inks Deal for Theme Park in South Korea

    Paramount Pictures has announced a deal to install a studio-branded theme park in an entertainment resort being developed in South Korea. The agreement was struck between Paramount and Mohegan Gaming & Entertainment, which owns the Inspire Integrated Entertainment Resort in the South Korean city of Incheon. Mohegan has invested KRW 2.8 trillion ($2.4 billion) in [...]

  • Davan Maharaj Mel Gibson

    L.A. Times Publisher's Lawyer Was Accused of Extorting Mel Gibson

    The attorney who negotiated a $2.5 million exit package for L.A. Times publisher Davan Maharaj was previously accused of using secret recordings to extort actor Mel Gibson. Surreptitious recordings also figure in the Maharaj case. NPR reported on Wednesday that Maharaj taped Tronc chairman Michael Ferro. According to the report, Ferro was heard on the [...]

  • 'Blurred Lines' Suit Ends With $5

    'Blurred Lines' Suit Ends With $5 Million Judgement Against Robin Thicke, Pharrell Williams

    After five years, the legal battle over the copyright of the Robin Thicke’s 2013 hit “Blurred Lines” has ended, with Marvin Gaye’s family being awarded a final judgment of nearly $5 million against the song’s primary writers, Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams, according to CNN and other reports. The pair were accused of copyright infringement [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content