×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Judge Denies AT&T Effort to Obtain Info on Potential Trump Influence in Antitrust Case

A federal judge has denied an effort by AT&T’s legal team to compel the Justice Department to produce information that could shed light on whether the White House influenced the Antitrust Division’s decision to sue to block the merger with Time Warner.

The decision was a setback for AT&T and Time Warner in its pursuit of a defense that they have been unfairly singled out by the Justice Department because of President Donald Trump’s hatred of CNN, one of the Time Warner divisions.

U.S. District Judge Richard Leon, in his ruling on Tuesday, wrote that AT&T-Time Warner had not met the legal threshold to show that they have “been ‘especially singled out'” by the Justice Department, and therefore could obtain records of correspondence that would shed light on how the decision to was made to try to block the merger.

Leon wrote that AT&T had not shown evidence of so-called “selective enforcement” to warrant obtaining the information and had fallen “far short” of showing that they were singled out.

On Friday, Dan Petrocelli, the lead counsel for AT&T and Time Warner, argued that what they were trying to obtain was a “privilege log” of communications involving the Justice Department’s Antitrust Division, Attorney General Jeff Sessions, and the White House.

But Leon denied the request to obtain additional written correspondence about the merger between the White House and Sessions’ office; documents between the attorney general and the Antitrust Division on the Trump administration view of the merger, and records of all oral communications between the White House and the Antitrust Division related to the merger.

“We respect the judge’s decision and look forward to the upcoming trial,” Petrocelli said in a statement after Leon’s ruling.

The trial is scheduled to begin on March 19.

Jeff Bewkes, the CEO of Time Warner, gave an extensive deposition last week in which he laid out his views on whether the decision to sue was motivated by Trump’s animus toward CNN, a unit of Time Warner. Bewkes’ deposition has not been made public, but Petrocelli noted that Bewkes’ comments on the issue ran 40 pages.

The Justice Department denies that there was anything “untoward” about the decision to sue. Its lead attorney, Craig Conrath, said AT&T-Time Warner was engaging in a “fishing expedition” to mount a defense that the decision was politically motivated, and he warned that the discovery dispute could delay the trial. He also said AT&T-Time Warner had yet to meet the legal threshold to mount such a “selective enforcement” defense.

Petrocelli argued that the AT&T-Time Warner merger was just the type of “vertical” transaction that has secured the DOJ’s green light in recent decades, in contrast to more problematic “horizontal” mergers that overtly remove competition from the marketplace. He also pointed to another merger — Comcast’s acquisition of NBC Universal in 2011 — as the type of vertical transaction that did get approved even though it presented more potential problems.

But Leon wrote that the Antitrust Division did file an enforcement action to try to block the Comcast-NBC U deal, but it was resolved through a settlement. Moreover, in that case, the FCC had oversight as well, he wrote. The settlement included a set of behavioral conditions, or requirements Comcast had to follow in its business practices. Current antitrust chief Makan Delrahim has expressed his general dislike of settlements that include behavioral conditions, and instead favors the sale of assets as a way to make a merger palatable.

Leon also challenged the notion that this was the “first and only time” that the Antitrust Division has found an antitrust problem with a vertical merger “or insisted on a structural remedy as a condition to settlement.”

“So while it may be, indeed, be a rare breed of horse, it is not exactly a unicorn!” Leon wrote.

The division told AT&T and Time Warner executives that the merger would get their approval if they sold off the Turner networks division, which includes CNN, or DirecTV. The companies declined to do so.

Kerri Kupec, spokeswoman for the Antitrust Division, said in a statement, “We are pleased with and respect today’s decision, which will permit the parties and court to focus on the case at hand. This case has always been about protecting consumers from competitive harms, and we look forward to presenting our case at trial on March 19.”

 

 

More Politics

  • Cenk Uygur

    Bernie Sanders Retracts Endorsement of Young Turks Founder Cenk Uygur After Backlash

    Bernie Sanders pulled his support for Cenk Uygur’s congressional bid, with the Vermont independent in part acknowledging that Sanders’ supporters were “frustrated” about the endorsement. Sanders, who’s running for the 2020 Democratic presidential nomination, cited Uygur’s announcement Friday that he would not be accepting any endorsements. In a statement, Sanders alluded to sexist and other [...]

  • Pete Buttigieg

    Here's Who's Raising Money in Hollywood for Pete Buttigieg

    The Pete Buttigieg campaign released its top bundlers on Friday evening, as it continues to open up its fundraising process to media scrutiny. Buttigieg released the names of 157 members of his “investors circle,” each of whom has raised at least $25,000 for his campaign. Buttigieg is now the most prolific fundraiser in Hollywood, with [...]

  • Ivanka Trump

    Ivanka Trump Reportedly Set to Speak at CES 2020

    Ivanka Trump, President Donald Trump’s daughter and an adviser to the president, is scheduled to appear on a panel at CES 2020 in January, according to a published report. Ivanka Trump will appear on a panel set for Jan. 8 at 3 p.m. at the Las Vegas confab with Gary Shapiro, president and CEO of [...]

  • Donald Trump Hollywood Racism

    House Judiciary Committee Votes to Impeach President Trump

    The House Judiciary Committee voted to adopt two articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump on Friday morning, sending the matter to the full House for a vote next week. The articles accuse Trump of abusing his power by pressuring Ukraine to interfere in the 2020 election and of obstructing the impeachment inquiry. Both articles [...]

  • Boris JohnsonConservative Party rally on eve

    Boris Johnson Returns as Prime Minister After Election, Pledges to Deliver Brexit

    UPDATED: The third general election in Britain in four years has returned former London mayor Boris Johnson as prime minister and given his Conservative Party a commanding majority in Parliament. Johnson campaigned on a promise to finally pull the U.K. out of the European Union after three-and-a-half years of political infighting since Britons voted to [...]

  • Boris Epshteyn

    Sinclair Drops Political Commentary Segments From Boris Epshteyn, Ameshia Cross

    Sinclair Broadcast Group has decided to scrap the political commentary segments that have aired across its vast station group since 2017. Boris Epshteyn, former Trump campaign official turned chief political analyst for Sinclair, has been delivering commentary segments that were mandated to run adjacent to local newscasts on all Sinclair stations since the spring of [...]

  • From left House Speaker Nancy Pelosi,

    House Leadership Unveils Impeachment Articles Against President Trump

    House Democrats unveiled two articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump on Tuesday morning, accusing him of abusing his power and obstructing Congress in its impeachment inquiry. Two committee chairmen — Jerrold Nadler and Adam Schiff — laid out a case that Trump interfered in the 2020 election by pressuring Ukraine to announce an investigation [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content