You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Fyre Fallout: How Much Prison Time — and Debt — Is Festival Founder Billy McFarland Really Looking At?

Billy McFarland, the promoter behind last year’s disastrous Fyre Festival, accepted a $26 million forfeiture as part of his plea deal for defrauding investors, and he faces as much as 40 years in prison. But in reality, those numbers are almost as inflated as his promises about the festival.

There’s little likelihood that the injured parties from the Fyre debacle will see much, if any, of that money. And McFarland’s lawyers bartered for a recommended 8-10 year sentence as part of his guilty plea to two counts of wire fraud in federal court on March 6 — although ultimately the term is up to U.S. judge for the Southern District of New York Naomi Reice Buchwald, who sources tell Variety may decide to go light in an effort to get him back in a position to be earning money.

But what chance does the disgraced 26-year-old would-be entrepreneur have for financial rehabilitation? The Fyre Festival has become a metaphor for almost comically inept planning. The heavily hyped event was to be a “luxury concert” — taking place on a small island in the Bahamas and featuring Blink-182, Migos and Disclosure — that collapsed on in a mess of disorganization on April 29 before it had even started. Far from the luxury accommodations and celebrity-chef-prepared meals promised by its producers — McFarland and rapper Ja Rule — concertgoers were met with flimsy tents, boxed lunches, near-total disorganization and long waits for flights to return to the mainland after airlines began refusing to fly would-be concertgoers to the overcrowded island of Exumas. One production professional briefly associated with the festival told Variety the event was marked by “incompetence on an almost inconceivable scale.”

While it’s possible some money could be raised by a documentary film (“Bonfyre of the Vanities”?) or a “my story” memoir McFarland could write while behind bars, there’s little chance they would raise even a fraction of the forfeiture obligation.

On top of that, any money recovered goes first to Uncle Sam. “Under federal law, forfeiture funds go to the government — it isn’t restitution,” white-collar criminal defense attorney Alan Ellis tells Variety. And although the Department of Justice’s “Guidelines on Seized and Forefeited Property” includes secured creditors as priority third-party beneficiaries (followed by employees on active payroll, then vendors), these are preceded by a long list of government uses for the funds — foremost being compensation to the investigative units and enforcement branches that brought the offender to justice.

All of which means that the ticket purchasers who have filed class-action lawsuits — who do not fall into any of the above-described categories — are unlikely to be the beneficiaries of forfeiture funds, except possibly as part of ticketing firm Vendor-1’s $2 million claim, which merited a fraud count all its own (though many customers purchased directly through Fyre Festival LLC).

“Going forward, this judgment will haunt Mr. McFarland for at least 20 years,” says Loyola Law School professor Dan Schechter, explaining that the initial forfeiture judgment runs for 10 years and is renewable for an additional 10 (in other words, he’ll be paying it off for 20 years). “But there’s not a lot that can be done. It’s not a typical situation where a business can be rehabilitated; his company was basically a Ponzi scheme used to defraud people. The forfeiture orders him to turn over the money, and I’m sure to the extent that he can, he will. But the problem is he’s probably spent it and doesn’t have to give back, and he isn’t in a position to earn it back.”

McFarland and his legal team, led by Boies Schiller & Flexner’s Randall Jackson, a former assistant U.S. attorney, have managed to keep financial documents shared in the criminal investigation under seal even as the would-be festival mogul has cultivated an image of destitution. Which leaves many wondering, “Where did the money go?”

McFarland collected tens of millions from wealthy stakeholders, largely by falsifying bank records and stock certificates in order to appear successful, according to government charges. Yet he had trouble hiring a criminal defense attorney (appearing with a public defender at one hearing) and has yet to respond to the dozens of civil lawsuits that have piled up, resulting in defaults that mean certain victory for his pursuers. But how much does any of it matter if he’s unlikely to be able to repay?

While the company’s financials will surely be made public as part of the involuntary Chapter 7 bankruptcy against Fyre Festival LLC initiated in July, those proceedings were put on hold until the criminal investigation concludes. The class-action suits, too, are marching along. Geragos & Geragos attorney Ben Meiselas is looking past McFarland’s turned-out pockets. “The law imposes a duty not to aid or abet others in the commission of criminal conduct. Those who aided and abetted this fraudulent enterprise will be financially liable to victims, as we predicted from the outset,” he tells Variety, referencing some of Fyre’s investors.

The most high-profile of those is McFarland’s business partner, Jeffrey Atkins  — a.k.a. Ja Rule. New York attorney Stacey Richman, who is representing Atkins in the civil suits (he has not been charged criminally), says some of those cases have fallen away with the realization that McFarland is broke. “My client would like to believe the best about Mr. McFarland, and does not think he would do this intentionally but that he got in too deep,” Richman tells Variety. “He is having a hard time wrapping his head around any other possibility and is beyond disappointed.”

And while headlines roared that McFarland was looking at a possible 40 years in prison — via two fraud counts each carrying a maximum sentence of 20 years — it is unlikely he will get anything close to that; the 8-10 years prosecutors and defense attorneys agreed upon as part of his plea deal amount to a recommendation. Sentencing, which occurs June 21, will be at the discretion of Judge Buchwald.

“I don’t expect him to get a particularly harsh sentence if it’s just the two counts of fraud,” Loyola criminal law professor Laurie Levenson tells Variety, noting that youth and inexperience should work in McFarland’s favor. “He was, what, 24 or 25 when he committed these crimes? That’s practically a kid.”

Ellis says McFarland and his legal team were smart to take the plea, because by the time a case progresses to an indictment the government is confident it has assembled enough evidence to win. “In federal court, 97% of those charged plead guilty,” he says. “Of the three percent that go to trial, the government wins anywhere from two-thirds to three-quarters of the cases. So if you’re indicted by the feds, you have a 99% chance of winding up in front of a sentencing judge, and an 86% chance of going to prison.”

Even “Pharma Bro” Martin Shkreli, who went to trial and was sentenced this month for securities fraud, only received seven years when the guidelines suggested a minimum of 15. It’s even possible that a Pharma-Fyre meeting could take place at one of the East Coast’s minimum security “prison camps,” which include a facility in Canaan, Pennsylvania (which Shkreli has requested) and the dorm-like institution in Otisville, New York, where inmates can qualify for weekend leave. With good behavior, McFarland can have 15 percent of his sentence shaved off.

What will help his case? When it comes to sentencing, “the name of the game these days is humanizing your client,” says Ellis. “If he donated to the Make a Wish Foundation, that’s great, but if he shoveled snow for his elderly neighbor, that’s even better.” Between now and the sentencing hearing, Jackson and second chair Karen Chesley will be working up a portrait of McFarland as a wayward and over-ambitious young man and assembling a list of mitigating factors. Schechter framed the main question the judge will be asking as she decides his fate: “Is he a good person who made a mistake — or a bad person who got caught?”

More Music

  • Spice Girls Open Reunion Tour in

    Spice Girls Open European Reunion Tour With Inclusivity Proclamations, Sound Issues

    Posh Spice chose not to be included, but there was a lot of other inclusivity to go around as the four other Spice Girls opened their reunion tour in Dublin Friday night. “We welcome all ages, all races, all gender identifies, all countries of origin, all sexual orientations, all religions and beliefs, all abilities,” they [...]

  • Moby attends the LA premiere of

    Moby Apologizes to Natalie Portman Over Book Controversy

    Moby has issued an apology of sorts after writing in his recently published memoir “Then It Fell Apart” that he dated Natalie Portman when she was 20 — a claim the actress refuted. “As some time has passed I’ve realized that many of the criticisms leveled at me regarding my inclusion of Natalie in Then [...]

  • Billie Eilish

    Billie Eilish Fans to Receive Perks Due to Chicago Venue Change

    Billie Eilish and her music agents at Paradigm are experiencing what most would call a first class problem. The demand to see the 17-year-old singer live has prompted a change of venue for her June 9 show in Chicago — from the 5,000-capacity Aragon Ballroom to the 20,000-plus-seat United Center arena. The last-minute venue change [...]

  • Moby Natalie Portman

    Moby Accuses Natalie Portman of Lying as the Two Spar Over Dating Claims

    In what’s become a he said/she said spat in multiple mediums, Moby, the elder statesman of electronic music, is now accusing actress Natalie Portman of lying and pleading to those on social media for his safety as “physical threats from complete strangers” emerge. To recap: this month, Moby released a new book, “Then It All [...]

  • Ellen DeGeneres Buys Adam Levine’s Beverly

    Adam Levine Cashes in on Sale of Max Mutchnick’s Former Mansion to Ellen DeGeneres

    Adam Levine and Behati Prinsloo have sold a baronial Beverly Hills mansion with an illustrious chain of ownership for a reported $45 million to Ellen DeGeneres and Portia de Rossi. The mainstream radio rock star, who, it was announced Friday, will not to return as a coach on “The Voice,” and the Namibian-born Victoria’s Secret [...]

  • Kanye West Shares a Memory of

    Kanye West Shares a Touching Memory of His Mother in Letterman Interview

    In a preview of David Letterman’s interview with Kanye West, which begins streaming next Friday, May 31, the musician’s wife Kim Kardashian West, tweeted a clip of him sharing a touching memory of his mother, Donda, who died in 2007 after a surgical procedure. While his wife looks on smiling, West answers Letterman’s question about [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content