×

Brett Ratner’s Attorneys Seek to Limit Exposure of His Alleged Sexual Misconduct

As high-profile men toppled due to sexual harassment allegations over the couple of months, Brett Ratner was one of very few who fought back by taking his accuser to court. Ratner filed a libel suit on Nov. 1, accusing Melanie Kohler of damaging his reputation by writing a Facebook post in which she accused him of rape.

Now, his case is exposing the potential downside of that approach. In a legal filing last week, Ratner’s attorneys said they would seek to limit his accuser’s ability to probe into other allegations of sexual misconduct that have surfaced against the producer. Ratner has been accused of forcing women to perform oral sex and masturbating in front of women, as well as various forms of sexual harassment.

Attorney Eric Seitz said he would seek a protective order barring media disclosures in the case, and would also seek to limit the scope of discovery. In the filing, Seitz said he feared that Kohler’s “New York lawyers intend to try this case in the media and to depose and publicize any and all ‘bad acts’ allegedly committed by Plaintiff as a means to show that he likely committed the criminal misconduct she has falsely attributed to him.”

Kohler is being represented pro bono by a team of attorneys led by Roberta Kaplan, most famous for advocating on behalf of same sex marriage benefits in the Windsor case before the U.S. Supreme Court. In an earlier filing, her lawyers indicated they plan to take extensive depositions on the issue of Ratner’s professional reputation, in order to establish to what extent that reputation has been harmed. The attorneys also took note of “reports that he has had dozens of allegations similar to Defendant’s leveled against him.”

In a filing on Friday, Kohler’s attorney Nicholas Monlux argued that Ratner’s request to limit discovery should be denied.

“If Ratner does not want his relevant ‘bad acts’ discovered by Kohler or made part of his public lawsuit, then the solution is not to launch baseless attacks against Kohler or her attorneys,” he wrote. “Rather, the solution is for him to dismiss his meritless lawsuit.”

Ratner’s lawyer also expressed concern that Kohler “is being supported financially by persons and/or entities with unlimited funding” — in essence worrying that Kohler will be able to pursue an extensive fishing expedition against him.

In his reply, Monlux said that concern is “unfounded and irrelevant.” He noted that Kohler and her husband operate a scuba business in Hawaii, and cannot hope to match Ratner’s reported $400 million net worth.

“There is nothing improper about a defendant receiving financial assistance to support her defense,” Monlux wrote. “Ratner may prefer to sue a victim who cannot afford to defend herself, but that preference is not his right, nor is it a basis for limiting discovery in this case.”

Monlux also noted the “hypocrisy” of Seitz’s concern about trying the case in the media.

“Kohler first learned of this case by means of an article published in TMZ, in which Ratner’s attorney apparently provided facts that were not included in the Complaint,” Monlux wrote.

Kohler’s attorneys are expected to file a motion to dismiss Ratner’s suit in the coming days.

More Biz

  • Jennifer Lawrence Harvey Weinstein

    Harvey Weinstein Bragged of Sex With Jennifer Lawrence, Lawsuit Claims

    Harvey Weinstein was hit with a lawsuit Friday from an actress who claims he forcibly performed oral sex on her, repeatedly masturbated in front of her, and threatened to harm her career if she objected. According to the suit, Weinstein pushed her to the ground during a meeting in his office in 2013. He then [...]

  • Times Up Hollywood

    Time's Up Entertainment Announces New Industry Mentoring Initiative

    Time’s Up Entertainment, an affiliate of the Time’s Up coalition of women across industries working to improve workplace safety, has announced the “Who’s in the Room” industry mentoring initiative. The program’s goal is to increase the presence of people of color from diverse backgrounds in the entertainment industry’s executive ranks. Funded by a $500,000 grant from [...]

  • Tom Cruise as Ethan Hunt in

    Paramount Inks Deal for Theme Park in South Korea

    Paramount Pictures has announced a deal to install a studio-branded theme park in an entertainment resort being developed in South Korea. The agreement was struck between Paramount and Mohegan Gaming & Entertainment, which owns the Inspire Integrated Entertainment Resort in the South Korean city of Incheon. Mohegan has invested KRW 2.8 trillion ($2.4 billion) in [...]

  • Davan Maharaj Mel Gibson

    L.A. Times Publisher's Lawyer Was Accused of Extorting Mel Gibson

    The attorney who negotiated a $2.5 million exit package for L.A. Times publisher Davan Maharaj was previously accused of using secret recordings to extort actor Mel Gibson. Surreptitious recordings also figure in the Maharaj case. NPR reported on Wednesday that Maharaj taped Tronc chairman Michael Ferro. According to the report, Ferro was heard on the [...]

  • 'Blurred Lines' Suit Ends With $5

    'Blurred Lines' Suit Ends With $5 Million Judgement Against Robin Thicke, Pharrell Williams

    After five years, the legal battle over the copyright of the Robin Thicke’s 2013 hit “Blurred Lines” has ended, with Marvin Gaye’s family being awarded a final judgment of nearly $5 million against the song’s primary writers, Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams, according to CNN and other reports. The pair were accused of copyright infringement [...]

  • WME Veteran Ari Greenburg Promoted to

    WME Veteran Ari Greenburg Promoted to President of Talent Agency

    WME veteran Ari Greenburg, one of the original Endeavor staffers who helped build the talent agency that became an industry powerhouse, has been promoted to president. Greenburg will oversee all daily operations across WME and its offices in Beverly Hills, New York, Nashville, London and Sydney. The promotion recognizes the role that Greenburg has played [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content