×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

What We Learned From the First Day of the AT&T-Time Warner Antitrust Trial

WASHINGTON — Monday was the first day of the antitrust trial over AT&T’s proposed merger with Time Warner, and it was hardly an explosive day of testimony.

Actually, the proceedings were really evidentiary hearings, in which the judge heard from both sides on what emails and documents they thought should be allowed to be admitted as evidence in the trial. Opening arguments won’t be until Wednesday, so this was really a prelude, to decide what gets to be talked about when things really get up and running.

That said, there were still moments that offered a glimpse of what is to come over the next few weeks:

AT&T and Time Warner rivals may testify on why they don’t like the merger. Part of Monday was devoted to the question of how to handle documents from third-party witnesses when they testify in the case. The companies are rivals to AT&T and Time Warner, and want the court to keep most of their information confidential. Judge Richard Leon is grappling with how to handle situations when they take the witness stand and are questioned about the documents — i.e. does he clear the courtroom and make their testimony private?

So far, he’s asked the lawyers to try to work it out among themselves. But it raises the very real possibility that the trial will show which companies have been expressing their concerns about the merger to the Justice Department, something that is usually kept in confidence in past transaction reviews. The DOJ sees their testimony as important to show how their bargaining will change for the worse if AT&T-Time Warner gains increased leverage and are able to demand higher prices for content. Among those expected: an executive from Google talking about YouTube TV and the importance of its “virtual” multichannel platform in obtaining the Turner networks.

Daniel Petrocelli, the lead counsel for AT&T-Time Warner, told the court that the rival companies have been “working very closely with the government and have met many, many times.” He suggested that they would offer testimony warning of the increased leverage of a combined AT&T-Time Warner, but argued that it would be “all speculation about what could happen.”

Leon acknowledged that such third-party competitors “are afraid … that if this goes through, they are in a worse position than they are in now.” But he also expressed concern that too much was being kept from public view. “There’s no way all this stuff should be confidential,” he said.

The Justice Department says emails contain “startling statements.” Eric Welsh, one of the Antitrust Division lawyers, argued for the admission of a trove emails from AT&T and Time Warner employees, and at one point said the court “will see some startling statements from these individuals.”

In many cases, AT&T-Time Warner is objecting to the admission of many of the emails unless they are connected to witness testimony. Petrocelli argued that in some instances, the emails are from lower-level employees who don’t have authority over merger decisions, and he pointed out that the government is seeking to enter 18 exhibits into evidence that come from one person just out of business school.

He also downplayed what evidence the government does have, calling their strategy the “incredible shrinking case.” He suggested that the government lacks a smoking gun document, like one where an executive comes out and says that the merger will allow them to raise prices. “You will see none of those,” he said.

AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson and Time Warner CEO Jeff Bewkes are expected to testify, and will attend opening arguments on Wednesday.

Welsh said the DOJ would be adding witnesses to address some of the documents.

The DOJ is determined to use AT&T’s own words against it. The Justice Department wants to admit past filings that AT&T has submitted to the FCC in some of its public proceedings, including Charter’s proposed acquisition of Time Warner Cable in 2016, AT&T’s merger with DirecTV in 2015, and a programming carriage proceeding in 2012.

Welsh said such past statements are important to show that the company recognized the value of so-called “must have” content for multichannel platforms — a key argument in its case — and how vertical integration could have an impact on leverage in the marketplace. “Now today they are coming into court saying, ‘Don’t worry because it’s not going to be an issue,'” he said.

Petrocelli, though, said that what the company said in past FCC proceedings shouldn’t have a bearing on the present case because so much has changed in the intervening years. “The government cannot prove its case … with respect to another issue in another matter.”

There looks to be a long trial ahead. Leon is concerned about the volume of exhibits the parties are trying to admit. He several times expressed hesitation about including as evidence slide decks, or the PowerPoint presentations that are ever more common in corporate America, unless the relevance can be established.

The proceedings are expected to last six weeks at a minimum, Leon said. As high as the stakes are, not every moment will be earth shattering. That was evident after the court was about to return from its first break on Monday morning. One of the U.S. marshals warned those watching, “Do not nod off,” or he’d give them a tap on the shoulder.

More Biz

  • BMI’s Charlie Feldman Retiring After 31

    BMI’s Charlie Feldman Retiring After 31 Years With Company

    Charlie Feldman, BMI’s Vice President of Creative in New York, announced today that he will retire from the company at the end of the year. A 31-year veteran of BMI, Feldman will continue to consult for the company in the new year, according to the announcement. Mike O’Neill, President and CEO of BMI, said, “I [...]

  • Chuck Lorre, Scott Stuber to Keynote

    Chuck Lorre, Scott Stuber to Keynote Variety Innovate Summit

    “The Big Bang Theory” co-creator and TV producer Chuck Lorre and the head of Netflix Films Scott Stuber will keynote Variety’s Innovate Summit presented by PwC on Dec. 5 in Los Angeles. Lorre will share the career experiences that lead to his co-creating and executive producing “The Big Bang Theory,” “Young Sheldon” and “Mom.” Lorre’s extensive [...]

  • Adele Haenel Adèle Haenel

    Accusations Against Roman Polanski, Other Filmmakers Propel #MeToo in France

    When the Harvey Weinstein scandal broke two years ago, the news was mostly met in France with a Gallic shrug. Screen icon Catherine Deneuve even denounced the #MeToo movement as creating a “totalitarian” environment. But bombshell accusations this month from actors Adèle Haenel and Valentine Monnier may finally have turned the tide in the local film [...]

  • Subhash Chandra Chairman of the Zee

    Another 16% Slice of India’s Zee to be Sold by Essel

    The Essel Group is to sell a further 16.5% stake in Zee Entertainment Enterprise Limited, India’s largest private sector broadcast group. The debt-reduction move comes just months after Essel auctioned off an 11% tranche of ZEEL. “The Group seeks to sell up to 16.5% stake in ZEEL to financial investors, in order to repay loan [...]

  • Frank Cicha

    Listen: Why Fox Television Stations Embraced Trial and Error in Daytime

    Frank Cicha, head of programming for Fox Television Stations, saw the future coming nearly a decade ago when Fox’s TV station group committed many millions to land syndication rights to “The Big Bang Theory” back in 2010. Even then, it was clear that big hits on the scale of “Big Bang” were going to be [...]

  • Jussie Smollett

    Jussie Smollett Files Malicious Prosecution Counterclaim Against City of Chicago

    Jussie Smollett has filed a counterclaim against the city of Chicago, several Chicago Police Department officers, and brothers Abimbola Osundairo and Olabinjo Osundairo claiming that he was the victim of a malicious prosecution that caused him “humiliation, mental anguish and extreme emotional distress.” The filing document, obtained by Variety, alleges that the Chicago P.D. “obtained false and [...]

  • Anna-Kendrick-Frito-Lay-ad

    Christmas Crunch: Frito-Lay Bets on Anna Kendrick to Catch Holiday Snackers

    Anna Kendrick’s newest role puts her through what may be some of the most delicious torture of her career. Kendrick, known for films like “Up In The Air” and “Pitch Perfect,” recently found herself on the set of a three-day shoot surrounded by bowls, bowls and bowls of chips, popcorn and other salty snacks that [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content