Troubling Beliefs Aren’t a Dealbreaker in the Case of ‘Judge Jeanine’ on Fox (Column)

Does Pirro's hiring indicate that mainstream entertainment is becoming more accepting of celebrities with reactionary views?

On the morning of March 25, President Donald Trump tweeted: “Watch @JudgeJeanine on @FoxNews tonight at 9:00 P.M.” Trump’s tweets are usually a bit punchier than this teasing logline, and at first it seemed like perhaps he was promising a guest appearance on the show.

Instead, viewers tuned in to hear a dressing-down for Speaker of the House Paul Ryan. Jeanine Pirro — host of “Justice with Judge Jeanine,” commentator on several Fox News shows, and celebrity judge-type extraordinaire — began her show by lambasting Ryan: “Speaker Ryan, you come in with all your swagger and experience and you sell ’em a bill of goods, which ends up a complete and total failure.”

“Folks, I want to be clear,” she says, folding her hands on her desk. “This is not on President Trump.”

This praise of the President — while laying the blame for his actions elsewhere — is not surprising from Pirro, a longtime Trump supporter who boosted him throughout the long 2016 election. But it throws into sharp relief what is surprising: Pirro is not just a Fox News commentator but now a broadcast game show host. The primetime show, “You the Jury,” will debut April 7 and present civil cases that the viewing audience can then vote on.

In the first two episodes released to critics, Pirro is not acting as a judge or lawyer on “You the Jury.” Instead she is a host — mediating between the audience and the “court proceedings” on stage, introducing the major players and transitioning between commercial breaks and the show’s different segments. She does not partake in the trial proceedings. The show gives the court-like staging the full Hollywood treatment, with dramatic music, game-show spotlights, and a live audience. Statements from the “prosecution” and “defense” get hoots and applause from the watching crowd.

As terrible as this is, it pales in comparison to how troubling it is that Pirro is about to get a showcase spot on a broadcast network. “Judge Jeanine” embodies every criticism made both narrowly about Fox News and more broadly about the conservative media ecosystem of the last 20 years: She is inflammatory, selectively truthful, and jingoistic.

What’s notable about Pirro’s hiring for “You the Jury” is not simply that she was tapped to host a legal show, but that her prior remarks did not immediately disqualify her for a role on the mainstream, broadcast, primetime stage. After all, there are any number of commentators in Hollywood with a legal mind who might have filled the role. Indeed, the legal mind is not even strictly necessary. As evidenced in the first two episodes, Pirro is not “Judge Jeanine” in “You the Jury” — she serves a Ryan Seacrest-like mediator. 

Does Pirro’s hiring indicate that mainstream entertainment is becoming more accepting of celebrities with reactionary views? There are exceptional examples of Pirro’s biases. In January 2015, following the Charlie Hebdo attacks in Paris, Pirro taped a segment that begins with the words “We need to kill them.” After a diatribe about Islamic terrorists, she begins to lay into Muslims of all stripes, using the phrase “Islamic cancer.”

“Muslim groups like CAIR and the Nation of Islam have been integrated into our society. Muslims were even invited to worship at the National Cathedral in Washington, D.C.,” she said. “They have conquered us through immigration. They have conquered us through interfaith dialogue.”

In the same segment, Pirro asserts that there is a Christian genocide (true) that has killed hundreds of thousands of innocents in the Middle East (not true) and that there will be American efforts to limit the First Amendment to “comply with Sharia blasphemy laws” (also not true). In that vein, Pirro goes on: “They can kill us, but we can’t hurt their feelings? I’m surprised there isn’t a new executive order that simply says ‘don’t offend Muslims.’”

As troubling as these statements may be, they have unfortunately become commonplace for commentators on cable news networks. This inflamed rhetoric has fueled ratings. But there’s a distinction between the bubble of cable news and broadcast television; broadcast TV is still held to the standard of serving the public interest, as stations rely on the public airwaves. Giving a voice in an entertainment setting to someone with such a volatile track record seems a questionable choice, at best.

I asked Fox if they were aware of Pirro’s past statements when they agreed to hire her — and how Muslim contestants and participants would be treated on “You the Jury.” Fox declined to comment. It does not appear that there are any Muslim contestants or participants in the first two episodes of “You the Jury,” which Fox released to critics.

The decision to hire Pirro indicates that the network is looking to capitalize on her following and is willing to risk turning off viewers who might be offended by her past statements on Fox News. To be sure, maybe Pirro has promised to be accepting and impartial on “You the Jury.” But on the other hand, that’s not what has made her famous. 

What’s particularly disappointing is that Fox has been one of the networks most committed to inclusive casting for its scripted shows. It has had great success with shows like “Brooklyn Nine-Nine” and “Empire,” both of which prominently feature underrepresented demographics.

“You the Jury” promises viewers that it will take on some of the most controversial issues of the day, like privacy online against internet trolls, and constitutional rights clashing with homophobia. It will also be asking viewers to judge whether or not Pirro is an acceptable host for a primetime show aimed at Americans of all stripes. In that sense, yes: We will have to be the jury.

More TV

  • beIN Orders First Turkish Original Drama

    beIN Orders First Turkish Original Drama 'The Choice'

    Miramax owner beIN Media is pushing into the competitive Turkish drama market. The beIN-owned Turkish pay-TV operator Digiturk has commissioned production company Ay Yapim to make drama series “The Choice” for its streaming platform, beIN Connect, in Turkey. “The Choice” marks the first original series for Digiturk since sports and entertainment group beIN Media acquired the [...]

  • Tekashi 6ix9ine Docuseries Coming From Showtime

    Tekashi 6ix9ine Docuseries Coming From Showtime and Rolling Stone

    Showtime Documentary Films today announced a new limited docuseries profiling controversial rapper Tekashi 6ix9ine. Titled “SuperVillain” and inspired by the Rolling Stone feature written by Stephen Witt, the three-part series will trace how a New York City deli clerk named Daniel Hernandez became superstar rapper Tekashi 6ix9ine — who racked up 2.6 billion streams and [...]

  • TV Ratings: 'The Masked Singer,' NBC's

    TV Ratings: 'The Masked Singer,' NBC's 'Chicago' Shows Tick Up

    One performer’s routine on “The Masked Singer” last night might have been a little too bare bones for the judges, however, the show’s ratings showed a lot more flesh. The Fox singing competition show ticked up from last week among adults 18-49 to a 2.1 rating, and gained around 100,000 total viewers to end up [...]

  • Megyn Kelly

    Megyn Kelly Makes Meandering Comeback Bid on Fox News (Column)

    Megyn Kelly made the first steps toward a TV comeback on Wednesday night, appearing on Fox News, the network that brought her to prominence, to decry NBC, the network from which she parted ways last year. It was a booking that had everything that has made Kelly a compelling figure for years — a sense [...]

  • Kane Brown CMT Artists of the

    Kane Brown Pays Tribute to Late Drummer Kenny Dixon in Tearful 'CMT Artists' Speech

    Country star Kane Brown, unabashedly distraught over the death of his touring drummer Kenny Dixon just four days earlier in a car accident, dedicated his “CMT Artists of the Year” award to Dixon in a heart-rending appearance on the telecast Wednesday night. Brown ceded the performance slot he would have been allowed to friend Chris [...]


    CBS-Viacom Merger Details Revealed, Shares to Trade on Nasdaq

    Negotiations between CBS and Viacom went down to the wire on the day the long-gestating transaction was finally sealed on Aug. 13. CBS Corp. and Viacom revealed the timeline of the merger talks in a Securities and Exchange Commission filing Thursday that runs more than 650 pages. Also Thursday, CBS and Viacom said the shares [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content