Leslie Moonves Explains Why CBS Passed on ‘American Idol’: ‘We Looked at it Very Seriously’

Before “American Idol” was revived at ABC, a sizable amount of speculation circulated regarding where the singing competition show would land, from ABC to NBC to its former home Fox — but one broadcaster was left out of the conversation: CBS.

Turns out, CBS was very much a part of the conversation to potentially bring “Idol” back to television.

“We were offered ‘American Idol’ at the time and we looked at it,” CBS Corp. chairman and CEO, Leslie Moonves, shared Wednesday morning at an annual press gathering, ahead of CBS’ Upfront presentation in New York City.

“We looked at it. We looked at it very seriously,” he admitted. “The economics just didn’t make sense for us; for them, it did,” he added, referring to ABC.

Moonves explained to reporters that CBS declined “Idol” because of the high cost, not having ownership of the series, which is produced by FremantleMedia and Core Media Group, plus the amount of real estate that the singing competition would take up on the CBS schedule — the most-watched broadcast network. On that note, during the breakfast, Moonves and his executive Kelly Kahl boasted about CBS — not NBC — defining “must-see-TV,” and proudly chatted about having the top comedy and drama in “The Big Bang Theory” and “Bull” with Kahl stating, “We launched the most watched drama on TV this year. It ain’t ‘This Is Us.’ It’s ‘Bull.'”

Speaking on “Idol,” Moonves said, “For a couple of reasons, we didn’t like it. For one, the price is so expensive. You need a 35 share to break even. So that’s not going to happen. Number two, the back-end of these shows is becoming more important or as important as the front end. We think that we are in a much stronger position that we wouldn’t want to take four hours of our schedule that we wouldn’t have any piece of selling any back-end.”

ABC’s “American Idol” move has been a top topic of conversation during this week’s Upfronts marathon with many network executives sharing their thoughts on the revival. ABC quickly touched on their excitement for “Idol” and announced that Katy Perry has signed on as the first judge. Meanwhile, Fox boss Dana Walden did not have minced words when reporters asked her on a Monday morning call about losing the show to ABC, saying, “It would be extremely fraudulent to bring the show back quickly…We felt that our fans would not appreciate being told one thing and then have the show brought back right away.”

“Idol” ran for 15 seasons on Fox, beginning in 2002. Before landing at ABC, Fremantle and Core pitched around town. At one point, NBC was in discussions, but insiders said the price-tag was too high for the network that already has their own successful singing competition series in “The Voice.” The production companies also re-pitched the show to Fox, which per Walden, turned down the offer.

More TV


    'The Orville' to Move From Fox to Hulu for Season 3

    Seth MacFarlane’s “The Orville” is on the move. MacFarlane announced Saturday at the show’s San Diego Comic-Con panel that Season 3 of the sci-fi series will air exclusively on Hulu rather than on Fox as it has for its first two seasons. According to an individual with knowledge of the situation, MacFarlane’s current workload and [...]

  • Westworld Season 3 Trailer

    Aaron Paul, Showrunners Unveil 'Westworld' Season 3 Trailer (Watch)

    Season 3 of “Westworld” is going to new worlds altogether. Unveiled during the show’s Comic-Con panel, the trailer teases Thandie Newton’s character Maeve entering a new world of hosts set during World War II. Meanwhile, in the human world, Dolores (Evan Rachel Wood) and her fellow hosts who escaped “Westworld” in season 2 are being [...]

  • Variety Cord Cutting Placeholder Cable

    Dish Faces Multiple Outages as Carriage Contracts Come Due

    Satellite-broadcaster Dish is known in the media industry as a hard bargainer when carriage contracts come up for renewal. HBO hasn’t been available on the service since November. Now, other TV networks face a similar prospect. Unless Dish and certain content suppliers reach new terms by Monday evening, subscribers who use several cable networks currently [...]

  • Patrick Stewart as Jean-Luc Picard of

    'Star Trek: Picard' to Feature Jonathan Frakes, Marina Sirtis, Brent Spiner, Jeri Ryan

    “Star Trek: Picard” is bringing back some familiar faces. During the show’s San Diego Comic-Con panel on Saturday, it was revealed that Brent Spiner, Jonathan Frakes, Marina Sirtis, and Jeri Ryan would reprising their roles from “Next Generation” and “Voyager” in Ryan’s case. Jonathan Del Arco will also appear, likely reprising his role as the [...]

  • The Simpsons Homer Live

    'The Simpsons' Will Finally Release Season 19 on DVD, Helping Out Purist Collectors

    “The Simpsons” DVD collectors who also happen to be obsessive-compulsive can rest a little easier: You’ll finally be able to fill in that missing Season 19. Executive producer Al Jean revealed on Saturday that 20th Century Fox Home Entertainment will finally release the 19th season of “The Simpsons” on DVD this December 3, two years [...]

  • Pictured: No'l Wells as Ensign Tendi;

    'Star Trek: Lower Decks' Sets Main Cast

    The upcoming animated series “Star Trek: Lower Decks” has announced its main voice cast. Tawny Newsome, Noël Wells, and Eugene Cordero will all star in the series. As Variety exclusively reported, Jack Quaid has also been cast as Ensign Brad Boimler. The Starfleet characters that comprise the ship’s bridge crew include Captain Carol Freeman, voiced by [...]

  • Jack Quaid

    'Star Trek: Lower Decks' Casts Jack Quaid (EXCLUSIVE)

    Jack Quaid has joined the voice cast of the upcoming animated series “Star Trek: Lower Decks” at CBS All Access, Variety has learned exclusively. As previously announced, the series will focus on the support crew serving on one of Starfleet’s least important ships. Quaid will voice the character of Ensign Brad Boimler. Described as a [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content