×

AIG Sues to Avoid Paying Disney $25 Million in ‘Pink Slime’ Settlement

AIG sued the Walt Disney Company on Thursday, seeking a declaration that it does not have to pay a $25 million insurance claim arising from the “pink slime” defamation case.

Beef Products Inc. filed a multibillion defamation claim in South Dakota following a series of ABC News reports on lean beef trimmings, otherwise known as pink slime. Partway through the trial in June, Disney settled the case. The terms were confidential, but in August, the company disclosed a legal expense of $177 million, most of which was attributed to the settlement.

Since then, AIG and Disney have been fighting over whether the settlement should be covered by Disney’s $25 million insurance policy. Last week, Disney sued AIG in federal court, seeking to force the insurer into arbitration in Los Angeles.

On Thursday, AIG laid out some of its argument as to why the claim should not be paid. According to the suit, the policy requires that ABC obtain written approval from outside counsel before broadcasting its report.

“The reason for this is obvious,” argues AIG’s attorney, Michael J. Bowe of Kasowitz Benson Torres LLP. “If an insured consults outside counsel concerning potentially defamatory statements prior to making them, the insured will be less likely to engage in conduct that gives rise to liability.”

Though some portions of the complaint are blacked out, it appears that AIG’s contention is that ABC did not get the required advance blessing from its attorneys. It appears that Disney’s counter-argument is that it was not “commercially reasonable” or normal industry practice to obtain written permission from outside lawyers.

A Disney spokesman said, “Rather than honor the terms of the insurance policy it sold us, AIG has chosen instead to evade those terms and attack its customer. We will vigorously pursue our right to recover.”

More TV

  • Jason Mitchell

    Jason Mitchell Dropped From 'The Chi' Season 3, Netflix Film

    Jason Mitchell is being dropped from a number of his current and upcoming projects. Variety has confirmed that the up and coming actor will not return for “The Chi’s” already announced third season, with Season 2 of the show currently airing on Showtime. In addition, Mitchell will no longer be starring in the Netflix film “Desperados,” in [...]

  • Maisie Williams

    TV News Roundup: Maisie Williams to Guest Judge 'RuPaul's Drag Race UK'

    In today’s roundup, Maisie Williams will guest judge on “RuPaul’s Drag Race UK” and “Drunk History” will return with eight new episodes to Comedy Central.  DATES Comedy Central‘s “Drunk History” will return with eight new episodes beginning with “Derek Waters’ Believe It or Not” Tuesday, June 18 at 10 p.m. The series premiere of “Alternatino [...]

  • Lisa Kudrow

    Lisa Kudrow Joins Lee Daniels-Whitney Cummings Comedy Pilot 'Good People' at Amazon

    Lisa Kudrow has signed on to star in and executive produce the comedy pilot “Good People” currently in the works at Amazon, Variety has learned. The half-hour project hails from writers and executive producers Whitney Cummings and Lee Daniels, with Cummings also set to star. It centers on three generations of women working in the [...]

  • 'Game of Thrones' Series Finale: Much

    'Game of Thrones' Series Finale: A Lot of 'Love' Despite Much-Criticized Ending

    Spoiler alert: Do not read until you’ve watched “The Iron Throne,” the series finale of HBO’s “Game of Thrones,” aka season 8, episode 6. Bran Stark may have a perpetual poker face, but “Game of Thrones” fans certainly had a lot of feelings about him Sunday night. The stony faced character was the No. 1 [...]

  • Naomi Watts Game of Thrones

    Everything We Know About the 'Game of Thrones' Prequels (So Far)

    Prequels are coming. Fans looking for their next fix after “Game of Thrones,” rest assured, plans are already in the works to cash in on George R.R. Martin’s expansive fantasy universe. HBO has been tight-lipped about details, but at least one prequel series has already been ordered with four others in development. Ancient History The [...]

  • 'Game of Thrones' Finale: Burning Questions

    'Game of Thrones': Burning Questions (and Some Answers) After the Series Finale

    [SPOILER ALERT: Do not read ahead if you have not seen the series finale of “Game of Thrones.”] All told, “Game of Thrones” got a pretty tidy ending. Daenerys (Emilia Clarke) is dead, the Starks have all embarked on different paths, and there’s a new king in town with a different council. However, with all [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content