You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Will ‘Legion’ Leave a Mark This Emmy Season?

FX is set to premiere “Legion” Wednesday night, a new series from the mind of showrunner Noah Hawley (“Fargo”) that could make a splash in Emmy season where countless comic book shows have previously failed.

While “Game of Thrones” has certainly found its stride, genre bias has nevertheless done its part over the years to hold programs like this back when it comes to awards. But on rare occasions, a comic book title has sparked in a major category: “Batman” landed a comedy series nomination and a mention for supporting actor Frank Gorshin in 1966. “Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman” was singled out for direction in 1994. Mariette Hartley even won the drama actress prize for “The Incredible Hulk” in 1979, beating out the likes of Rita Moreno (“The Rockford Files”) and Barbara Bel Geddes (“Dallas”).

The only superhero show to truly hit with the Television Academy was “Heroes,” but that was an original concept, not an adaptation of a pre-existing property. The NBC program landed a drama series nomination among others in 2007. Meanwhile, shows like “The Walking Dead,” “Gotham” and “Daredevil” have been relegated to below-the-line categories.

Legion” represents a new breed, however. It’s a psychedelic subversion of the genre that puts viewers inside the troubled head of David Haller, a mental patient who discovers the mania he thought was only in his mind is actually the manifestation of latent mutant superpowers. It’s also a big risk for Hawley, tackling a character peripherally associated with the X-Men universe while not depending on that association to drive interest. But he’s used to taking risks, having unflinchingly faced the challenge of turning a beloved Coen brothers film into a critically acclaimed, wildly successful anthology series.

Moreover, “Legion” is already acclaimed in its own right. “Those who are pulled into the surreal, jagged orbit of this distinctive drama are likely to stay there for the full eight-episode run,” Variety‘s Maureen Ryan wrote in her review. “It is, literally and figuratively, a trip — and it’s often an exhilarating one.”

Star Dan Stevens might be the best bet for an adventurous “Legion” nomination, if there is indeed one in the offing. He has the unenviable task of conveying a tormented persona while maintaining an affability that makes the character quite unique in the landscape.

Anything more beyond that could be a tall order but to be fair, there’s something of a new drama drought this year, as the hot programs everyone is talking about for awards tend to be limited series like “Big Little Lies,” “Feud,” “The Night Of” and “The Young Pope.” Shows like “This Is Us” and “Westworld” will probably be in the mix, and “The Crown” is no doubt the one to beat, but “Legion” stands out from that fray.

Otherwise, it’s hard not to consider it a strong player in categories like art direction, editing and special effects. The visual design of the show is eye-popping and detailed, while Hawley’s overall vision provides a rich opportunity to play with form in truly exciting ways.

So, can “Legion” make an Emmy dent on behalf of its comic book brethren? The season is right around the corner. We’ll see if it sticks for viewers over the next two months.

More TV

  • Good Omens

    Religious Group Mistakenly Petitions to Get Amazon Prime's 'Good Omens' Removed From Netflix

    Upwards of 20,000 Christians have signed a petition calling for Netflix to cancel the fantasy series “Good Omens.” But the TV series, adapted from Terry Pratchett and Neil Gaiman’s 1990 satirical sci-fi novel, is distributed by Amazon Prime, not Netflix. The petition was first launched by the Return to Order campaign, a Christian organization under [...]

  • Maura Tierney as Helen and Dominic

    TV News Roundup: Showtime Drops 'The Affair' Final Season Teaser (Watch)

    In today’s TV Roundup, Showtime drops a teaser for the fifth and final season of “The Affair,” and Kid Cudi and Big Boi join Shudder’s “Creepshow” anthology series.  FIRST LOOKS AMC has released the first trailer for its forthcoming anthology series “The Terror: Infamy.” Premiering August 2, the Ridley Scott-produced show features a cast and [...]

  • Bello Nock

    A&E Orders Stunt Series 'Impossible Live,' Special 'Volcano Walk Live'

    A&E Network has ordered a live stunt series titled “The Impossible Live.” The series, which hails from KEW Media Group’s Essential Media Group, will consist of five two-hour episodes featuring daredevils performing death-defying stunts such as parachute-less jump from a plane onto a speeding train, a motorcycle jump off a cliff in which the daredevil [...]

  • Monte Carlo TV Festival: Stars Mingle

    Monte Carlo TV Festival: Nominees, Jurors and Star Guests Mingle on Riviera

    The Monte Carlo Television Festival drew to a close Tuesday with “Escape at Dannemora” winning the Golden Nymph in the limited series and TV movie section, and “My Brilliant Friend” winning best drama series. “The festival is testament to the fact that as the industry adapts and evolves with the times, good storytelling never goes [...]


    PMK-BNC Executive Joy Fehily Resigns, Will Consult and Manage Seth MacFarlane (EXCLUSIVE)

    Top Hollywood publicist and executive Joy Fehily has resigned from her post at public relations firm PMK-BNC, individuals familiar with the move told Variety. Fehily steps down in the midst of a five-year deal with the show business institution, insiders said, which reps A-list actors and below-the-line talent as well as huge brands like American [...]

  • Schitt's Creek Wigs

    'Schitt's Creek': Inside Moira Rose's Iconic Wig Collection

    Moira Rose, the family matriarch of cult classic “Schitt’s Creek,” is known for several things: her pronunciation of the word “bebe,” her love for her TV family (and sometimes Alexis) and her countless vibrant wigs. Played by the always delightful Catherine O’Hara, each episode (and wig) is a joy to witness on screen. “I think [...]

  • Brandon Flynn

    Brandon Flynn on Hollywood Double Standards and Never Actually Coming Out

    Brandon Flynn has a flourishing Hollywood career. The 25-year-old quickly shot to social media superstardom on Netflix’s hit “13 Reasons Why” with millions of devoted followers and, shortly after, was cast on HBO’s “True Detective.” And yet, the rising star has received just as much attention for his personal life as his professional career. In [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content