Emmys 2017: Will Claire Foy or Elisabeth Moss Take the Lead Drama Actress Trophy?

A twenty-something queen, a president with blood on her hands, a powerful defense attorney and law professor, a volatile robot, a savvy Soviet spy and a Handmaid who refuses to allow her spirit to be crushed. That’s the tableau of characters played by the six contenders for lead drama actress. And that alone explains why actresses with Oscars and Tonys on their resumes are stampeding to television. The riches are so abundant that most TV fans can name at least a half-dozen more actresses who also deserve recognition. Emmy voters have an exceptionally tough call to make in this category.

The Odds
The frontrunners are Elisabeth Moss for Hulu’s “The Handmaid’s Tale” and Claire Foy for Netflix’s “The Crown.” In almost any other year, Foy would be the shoo-in for donning the robe and crown in a show that has Emmy bait in its royal DNA. But then Moss came along with a different kind of headgear and robe and made us alternately weep and cheer for the indomitable Offred. Foy has two big advantages in her corner, though: she’s already claimed Golden Globe and SAG awards for her work on the show, and it’s foolish to underestimate the TV Academy’s love for all things British.

The Case for Moss
Moss delivered a bravura performance in “Handmaid’s” first season. She communicated so much with her eyes, her facial expressions, her plodding gait and her flashes of anger. She made the world and the lexicon of Gilead entirely real, even as we see her in flashbacks to the beginning of the unraveling of America as we once knew her. Moss has collected seven Emmy nominations since 2009 (six for “Mad Men,” one for “Top of the Lake”) but no wins. Offred’s harrowing journey could be the path that leads her to the promised land, at long last.

The Case for Foy
Foy was the brightest jewel in this crown. So much of the show rested on the slender shoulders of its star, who brought a mix of majesty and vulnerability to her portrayal of young Queen Elizabeth II caught up in a whirlwind of world events. And yet she was anything but showy in the role. With a look here and a gesture there, Foy essayed beautifully Elizabeth’s transformation from a mere mortal to the divine status that comes with her title and how that changes her as a woman, wife and mother. Foy demonstrated skill well beyond her years in taking this throne.

The Competition
Viola Davis (“How to Get Away With Murder”): Davis commands virtually every frame of ABC’s “How to Get Away With Murder” as Annalise Keating. She could keep us riveted simply by reading selections from California’s criminal law code.

Keri Russell (“The Americans”): She’s the wild card. Don’t be shocked if Elizabeth Jennings of FX’s “The Americans” pulls off a covert operation to take home the trophy.

Evan Rachel Wood (“Westworld”): She made us fall for Dolores in HBO’s “Westwood” even though we knew she wasn’t flesh and blood. And then she really surprised us with that killer twist.

Robin Wright (“House of Cards”): Wright has grabbed five consecutive noms for her work as the amoral Claire Underwood. Her power grab of the presidency in season five — on the heels of her first murder — could impress voters.

More TV

  • Pennyworth

    TV Review: 'Pennyworth'

    Is there a law that says there must always be a certain number of Batman properties on air at all times? Just as Christopher Nolan’s “Dark Knight” films germinated a fandom that seemed to demand not merely a Ben Affleck Batman but also two different Joker-based franchise, so too did the conclusion of Fox’s “Gotham” [...]

  • She's Gotta Have It Review

    'She's Gotta Have It' Canceled After Two Seasons at Netflix

    Netflix has canceled Spike Lee’s series adaptation of “She’s Gotta Have It.” The show ran for two seasons at the streamer. Lee is expected to shop the series to other outlets. The news comes less than two months after the release of Season 2 back in May. “Spike Lee is one of the greatest filmmakers [...]

  • David Benioff and D.B. Weiss

    'Game of Thrones' Showrunners Will No Longer Attend Comic-Con Panel

    “Game of Thrones” showrunners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss, along with some beloved “Thrones” actors, have canceled their scheduled appearances at San Diego International Comic-Con. Actors Iain Glen (Jorah Mormont), Nathalie Emmanuel (Missandei of Naath), director Miguel Sapochnik, and dual writer-producers Benioff and Weiss are no longer attending, HBO revealed in a revised panel lineup [...]

  • TV News Roundup: 'Mr. Robot' Drops

    TV News Roundup: 'Mr. Robot' Drops Season 4 Trailer (Watch)

    In today’s roundup, USA releases a trailer for the final season of “Mr. Robot,” Apple plans a “Snoopy in Space” series and Variety has an exclusive clip from Season 3 of Netflix’s “The Epic Tale of Captain Underpants.” CASTING Golden Globe-winner Ian McShane will guest star in the season premiere of “Law & Order: SVU.” [...]

  • Elisabeth Moss Handmaid's Tale

    Why Elisabeth Moss Deserves More than 'The Handmaid's Tale' (Column)

    Elisabeth Moss has a long talk with a somewhat less-than-present conversation partner, to which Moss herself brings a certain wired tension. Her physical posture, upright even as her voice frays with exhaustion, indicates as much as do her words a new resolve to do better than she’s done as a caretaker. Having run out of [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content