You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Emmys 2017: Noms Span Extreme Edges of Drama Spectrum

With five debut series cracking what is arguably the most venerated category at the Emmys, the Television Academy signaled a willingness to expand its definition of what makes an Emmy-worthy drama. By the numbers, it was an intriguing year: 180 series submitted for the category, the highest number ever. Four of the seven nominees are on streaming services; three of the seven are science-fiction shows; and three are led by ensembles anchored by women. Statistically, this is a magnificent array of shows — indicative of the changing nature of Hollywood and the breadth of options now available to viewers.

It’s baffling that voters overlooked “The Americans” just one year after ushering it into the drama series nominees — and it’s really disappointing, if not surprising, that “The Leftovers” failed to impress the Academy. There are a few other worthy shows floating around — “Halt and Catch Fire,” also on AMC, is one of my personal favorites, and Showtime’s “Penny Dreadful” has been totally underrated by the Emmys. And as the Academy is often politically minded — “Veep’s” long-running winning streak speaks to Emmy voters’ feelings on Washington, and Alec Baldwin this year has a nom for his performance as the president — it seems significant that of the seven nominated shows, only two are in the present day. One of those, “This Is Us,” is so warm it’s gooey. The other is the reliably chilly “House of Cards.” Perhaps, in the tumultuous landscape of 2017, only extreme optimism or extreme pessimism can be tolerated.

In a way, that’s the story of the five shows that aren’t set in the present-day, too. “Stranger Things,” a sleeper hit for Netflix, is also comfortable, with a nostalgic narrative arc that references a whole decade of filmmaking and stars a whole crew of charming kids. “The Crown,” a masterfully rendered period piece about the young Queen Elizabeth II, presents geopolitics as a world run by dignified, self-sacrificing adults. On the other hand, “Better Call Saul” depicts a character inching closer toward being a villain, in a denouement we already know is pretty pathetic; and “The Handmaid’s Tale” is, well, “The Handmaid’s Tale.”

“Perhaps, in the tumultuous landscape of 2017, only extreme optimism or pessimism can be tolerated.”

With so many new shows, it feels especially difficult to try to name a favorite. “Better Call Saul” certainly has a shot at the statue because it’s been nominated so many times. “Game of Thrones’” win last year could signify a warmth toward genre shows that lays the groundwork for “Westworld,” a daring and adventurous show with a sprawling range of thematic implications about consciousness, creation, and storytelling. (That it plays with and tweaks the Hollywood standard of the Western in its production design surely can’t hurt it.) But at the same time, that political spirit could rally around “The Handmaid’s Tale” or even longtime nominee “House of Cards.” If the message is for pure escapism, maybe the sumptuous drama “The Crown,” which lays out civilized British nobility with refined flair, will seize the Academy’s fancy.

Whatever the Academy’s choice, it’s almost a guarantee that it will be a provocative one. Voters have an opportunity to cast ballots for dystopia, spinoffs, history and science-fiction; each nominated show is so wildly different from the others that whatever the Academy coalesces on will be an interesting snapshot into the industry’s psyche. What does a “Stranger Things” drama series win look like? Even choosing “House of Cards,” which is probably the least interesting show here, would be a shocking and fascinating statement.

Drama is in a little bit of a soul-searching moment in a general sense, beyond just this Emmy category. So much of the innovation in television has decamped from dramas to half-hours and anthology series that dramas seem to be degrading from one season to the next faster than ever. To wit, “UnReal” and “Mr. Robot,” two exciting shows from the 2016 race, dropped off dramatically in quality — and the nominations reflected that. The Academy likes to set off a debut show on a reign of glory, as it did with “Mad Men” and “The Sopranos.” That requires envisioning where these shows are going — a second season that will have the seal of the Academy’s honor branded on it.

It feels very 2017 for the Academy to be sifting through several different possible visions for how to move forward — whether that is outright dystopia, a paralyzing slide into obsolescence, a leaf from the British handbook, the comfortable citadel of cynicism, or something else entirely. These candidates for Academy honors have a lot of new blood in the mix, making for a surprising array of intriguing options.

More TV

  • Outlander 406

    'Outlander' Recap: Jamie Encounters William Again in 'Blood of My Blood'

    SPOILER ALERT: Do not read if you have not yet watched “Blood Of My Blood,” the sixth episode of “Outlander” Season 4. The action in “Blood of My Blood” picked up almost immediately after the previous week’s episode, as evidenced by the fact that Murtagh (Duncan Lacroix) was still staying with Claire (Caitriona Balfe) and [...]

  • The Flash -- "Elseworlds, Part 1"

    'Elseworlds, Part 1' Recap: Barry Allen and Oliver Queen Swap Skills, Visit Superman

    SPOILER ALERT: Do not read if you have not yet watched “Elseworlds, Part 1,” the first part of the 2018 “Arrowverse” crossover, which aired Dec. 9. After past crossovers that introduced beloved characters’ doppelgangers, a wedding and death, “Elseworlds,” the fifth annual “Arrowverse” event, had a lot to which to live up. Unlike previous years, [...]

  • Stranger Things

    'Stranger Things' Season 3 Teaser Reveals Episode Titles, 2019 Release

    Netflix dropped a new teaser for the upcoming third season of “Stranger Things” Sunday, confirming that it will land on the streamer in 2019. The teaser also revealed the episode titles for the third season, which are as follows: “Suzie, Do You Copy?,” “The Mall Rats,” “The Case of the Missing Lifeguard,” “The Sauna Test,” [...]

  • Kyzza Terrazas Joins Garcia Bernal, Diego

    Kyzza Terrazas Joins Gael Garcia Bernal, Diego Luna’s La Corriente del Golfo (EXCLUSIVE)

    BUENOS AIRES — Launching their new production house, La Corriente de Golfo, last April, Gael García Bernal and Diego Luna have tapped Mexican writer-director Kyzza Terrazas as the company’s head of development. The appointment will certainly help build the company appointing an old-rounder capable of overseeing and implementing development, writing and directing, and a longtime [...]

  • Michael Che Defends Kevin Hart on

    Michael Che Ribs Academy Over Kevin Hart Controversy on 'SNL'

    Kevin Hart may have alienated some in Hollywood over his recently resurfaced homophobic tweets, but that didn’t stop “Weekend Update” co-host Michael Che from cracking some jokes in support of Hart on Dec. 8’s “Saturday Night Live.” After briefly recapping that Hart stepped down from hosting the Oscars after the 2011 tweets came to light, [...]


    'The Umbrella Academy' Superheroes Series Premiere Date Set on Netflix

    The dysfunctional-family superheroes of “The Umbrella Academy” are landing on Netflix worldwide on Feb. 15, 2019. The live-action series is based on the “Umbrella Academy” comic books created and written by Gerard Way and illustrated by Gabriel Bá, published by Dark Horse Comics. The Netflix original series comprises 10 one-hour episodes. Related Top TV Salaries [...]

  • SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE -- "Jason Momoa"

    Robert De Niro Appears as Robert Mueller in 'Saturday Night Live' Cold Open

    Robert De Niro made a surprise appearance as special counsel Robert Mueller in “Saturday Night Live’s” cold open. De Niro popped out of a closet in a sketch that skewered President Donald Trump and the mounting legal pressure Mueller’s investigation has put on many of Trump’s associates. Alex Moffatt played Eric Trump in a bedtime-story [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content