You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

What It’s Like to Hope For Emmy Miracles

Great acting conjures worlds. We are living in a golden age of magical special effects, on large and small screens. But smart writers know that the skills of the very best actors can transport and move viewers like nothing else.

An actor locked into a career-making performance can simply tell a story, and even if we can’t necessarily see what they’re describing, we are right there with them — imagining, remembering, under their spells. Carrie Coon and Aisha Hinds were in very different shows this year, but they both provided more than ample proof of this very point. Emmy voters would do well to remember Coon’s brilliant performance as a lead actress in HBO’s “The Leftovers,” and in the guest actress in a drama category, Aisha Hinds’ name should appear for her transfixing performance as Harriet Tubman in “Underground.”

Both of these potential nominations might be seen as the longest of long shots. But it’s worth reminding Emmy voters of their own willingness, especially in recent years, to shake things up and reward newcomers, or to honor performances and shows that most observers thought were unlikely to ever receive Emmy love.

Emmy miracles can happen; we’ve seen ample proof of that. “Orphan Black” debuted on BBC America in early 2013 to very little notice, but soon became a pop-culture juggernaut, in large part thanks to the jaw-dropping work of Tatiana Maslany, who played several roles on the show. Emmy voters rewarded her with a lead drama actress nomination in 2015, and she won in 2016. Voters were even quicker off the mark with Rami Malek: “Mr. Robot” premiered in 2015 and he won his first dramatic-actor Emmy the next year.

“The Americans” is probably the most famous recent case of incredibly deserving actors finally receiving nominations several years into the show’s run. Did many TV lovers wish Keri Russell and Matthew Rhys had been recognized as soon as humanly possible after the show’s 2013 debut? Sure. That doesn’t mean their 2016 nominations were any less welcome. Another cherished example of Emmy voters doing right by an actor and a show comes courtesy of “Friday Night Lights”: The drama and leads Kyle Chandler and Connie Britton received nominations in 2011, and mere months after the show had ended, Chandler walked off with a lead actor Emmy.

Emmy voters can do the right thing, because I’ve seen them do it. So before you fill out your ballot, do two things: Watch the series finale of “The Leftovers,” “The Book of Nora,” and “Minty,” a season-two episode of “Underground.” They’re spectacular showcases for each of these actresses.

WGN pulled the plug on “Underground,” and thus a full Emmy campaign for the show — let alone for Hinds, a guest actress — appears unlikely. But her exceptional performance in “Minty,” a standalone installment featuring Hinds as Harriet Tubman, is one of the most worthy on the entire TV landscape. What’s most impressive is the modulation of Hinds’ work in the episode, which consists of a speech Tubman gives to abolitionists. Hinds gives impassioned energy to every moment of the speech, in which Tubman describes her relationship with God, her efforts to free herself and other slaves, and the physical and psychological abuse she suffered at the hands of slave masters. Hinds has the acting equivalent of perfect pitch: She takes you through every peak and valley of Tubman’s journey with intention, specificity and attention to detail. Tubman is quietly recalling her mother one moment, burning with anger at the injustice of beatings the next. Every transition is flawless, every emotional element is honest. Hinds has been a talent to watch for some time — just this year, she was also terrific in Fox’s “Shots Fired” — but her Tubman performance was a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, and she did not waste it.

“The Leftovers” deserves a best drama nomination — its final season was a rich, bittersweet, gorgeous wonder — but whether or not that happens, Coon undoubtedly deserves an Emmy nomination for her performance as Nora Durst. One of the core accomplishments of “The Leftovers” was its ability to send its characters — and the audience — to difficult, harrowing or surreal places, but it was never manipulative in its attempts to elicit emotions. That’s partly due to the exceptional writing, but none of that would have worked had its cast been unable to bring raw, unflinching honesty and transparency to their work.

All did, especially Coon, whose character became the beating heart of the show. Nora lost her whole family — her husband and two kids — to the Sudden Departure, and there was no road map for her grief. She was lost, prickly, determined and underneath it all, terrified by how undone she was by her grief. Coon had to depict all those layers, along with Nora’s watchful, sarcastic intelligence. She did all that with brilliant ease (and her work was matched by that of her stellar co-star, Justin Theroux). To take viewers on Nora’s journey toward resolution and peace — which may or may not have involved a trip that she talks about in “The Book of Nora” — director Mimi Leder often focused on Coon’s face. It was impossible to look away from Nora as she talked about her pain and the truths she’d arrived at. Here was another instance of an actor merely telling a story — as Hinds did — and making that story the most important thing on Earth. That’s acting.

More TV

  • Stephen Colbert

    Stephen Colbert Mocks Former CBS Chief Leslie Moonves on 'Late Show'

    Leslie Moonves was known to take an active dislike of David Letterman making fun of him during that host’s tenure on CBS’ “The Late Show.” He probably isn’t enjoying being mentioned by Stephen Colbert either. Colbert used his monologue on Tuesday’s broadcast to poke fun at the former CBS Corp. CEO, who yesterday learned that [...]

  • Ruth Wilson and Idris Elba'Luther Series

    'Luther' Creator Neil Cross Working on Show's Movie Version, Idris Elba Says

    A movie version of crime series “Luther” is moving forward, with writer-creator Neil Cross working on the script, the show’s star Idris Elba confirmed at the launch of Season 5 in London. “We are really advancing on getting a movie version [of the show] up on the screen,” Elba said. “Neil is beavering away on [...]

  • THE VOICE -- "Blind Auditions" --

    TV News Roundup: NBC Announces Midseason Premiere Dates

    In today’s roundup, NBC reveals midseason premiere dates for six shows, including “The Voice.” DATES  NBC has announced midseason premiere dates for four returning and two new series. “The Voice” will air Feb. 25 at 8 p.m. ET/PT, Feb. 26 at 8 p.m., and March 5 at 8 p.m. It will return April 23 at 8 [...]

  • David Rhodes CBS News

    CBS News Faces New Challenges in Weeks Ahead

    At CBS News, President David Rhodes has a series of important decisions to make that could affect the trajectories of some of TV’s best-known news programs. As its parent company seeks to move forward from recent seismic events – the ouster of its former CEO, Leslie Moonves; a corporate probe into its workplace culture; and [...]

  • European Union Placeholder

    Europe, Hollywood Hail Landmark E.U. Territorial Licensing Agreement

    Industry organizations and major companies in Europe and Hollywood welcomed Tuesday a high-level European Union agreement that in large part preserves producers’ ability to sell movies and TV shows on an exclusive territory-by-territory basis. Territorial licensing is a financial backbone of the film and TV business in Europe. Recognition of such licensing came last Thursday in [...]

  • Queer as Folk UK Version

    'Queer as Folk' Reboot in Development at Bravo (EXCLUSIVE)

    In a competitive situation, Bravo is developing a new version of “Queer as Folk,” Variety has learned exclusively. Russell T. Davies, the creator of the original UK series, is onboard the new project as an executive producer. Stephen Dunn is attached to write, direct, and executive produce. Nicola Shindler of Red Productions, who executive produced the [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content