Watching National Anthem Pageantry as Closely as We Watch the Game (Column)

Over the past three days, Americans have been put in the surprising position of analyzing body language in order to understand politics. Since Saturday night, National Football League players have responded to President Donald Trump’s unhinged tirade against quarterback Colin Kaepernick — a tirade that called the player a “son of a b—tch” — by adopting various permutations of kneeling, linking arms, or sitting out the traditional singing of the National Anthem that opens each game.

With Puerto Rico in shambles, health care under debate, and North Korea threatening war, the stance that men who play with a pointy ball do or do not take toward a rectangle of fabric should not be such a major news story. And yet it has dominated the news, and Trump’s own thoughts. (Since Saturday morning, Trump has tweeted 17 times about professional sports and/or what he deems a lack of respect for the flag. This does not include three retweets, including one that exploits the death of army ranger and NFL player Pat Tillman.) Don Lemon turned over the entirety of his show, from 10 p.m. to midnight, to the NFL teams’ demonstrations; MSNBC anchor Chris Hayes asked his guest Hillary Clinton about it.

Some of the team’s statements have been quite clear: More and more players have chosen to kneel, often linking arms or holding hands with their teammates who have chosen to stand; nearly the entirety of the Oakland Raiders stayed on the bench for the anthem. Others have been, fascinatingly, a bit more open to interpretation. The Pittsburgh Steelers, Seattle Seahawks, and Tennessee Titans all opted to stay off the field for the National Anthem — a strong but ambiguous statement that almost reads as avoiding the issue entirely. Several other teams, such as the Arizona Cardinals, opted for linking arms during the anthem — which was interpreted by some, including Trump himself, as an expression that was critical of kneeling. And then on Monday night, the Dallas Cowboys — along with owner and Trump supporter Jerry Jones — opted to “pre-kneel”: taking a seconds-long knee before the flag was unfurled, and then standing to link arms in solidarity as the anthem was sung.

These gestures mean something, but it’s hard to tell what. Kaepernick began to sit out the anthem as a protest of how unfairly black people are treated by the police in America. Critics responded that disrespecting the flag was disrespecting the armed forces. Trump, characteristically, has inflated the issue to be both much bigger and much less meaningful. Now, the demonstrations from NFL players have gone beyond what Kaepernick first intended, to a muddled hash where linking arms either means unity or protesting kneelers or supporting the flag, and kneeling means protesting Trump or showing solidarity to players of color or genuflecting to the flag.

Kudos to the president for making medieval symbolic pageantry vital and relevant again; we are trying to measure meaning through ceremonial gesture. The situation is so heated that Alejandro Villanueva, a Steelers player who stood and observed the flag from the tunnel leading to the locker rooms, held a press conference to explain how his exact movements neither disrespected the flag nor repudiated his teammates’ expressions of peaceful protest. CNN devoted an entire segment to breaking down the logistics of the Steelers’ protest, in an unconscious parody of the way a sports commentator might break down the mechanics of a defensive play. 

We have been reduced, as a nation, to a game of patriotic charades. It would be absurd if it were not otherwise so vital.

It’s difficult to sum up all of the ways in which Trump has mangled public debate in his racially inflected sports tirade, but at the very least, his divisive flag-waving praises loyalty to America’s symbols without any understanding of what the symbols really mean. He has singled out Kaepernick and his fellow protestors just weeks after dismissing neo-Nazis waving Confederate flags as not all bad.

Which is why it is those very symbols that need defining, or redefining, now. We are not, as a nation, equipped to handle the biggest issues confronting us, because we are stuck on these most basic ones: The flag. The anthem. The sport. The role of the player in the game. The role of the protester in the country. The competing narratives of America are being forced to confront each other, and unlike political debates (which are both rare and no fun at all) and awards shows (which require a strong stomach for grandstanding) the live and on-the-field drama of football is the whole reason to tune in. Now, though, the tactical game has extended to a few minutes before kickoff. 

It’s been said before that Trump is the reality television president, a soundbite-spouting provocateur whose policy proposals are all punctuated with exclamation points. It seems as if the Trump era requires us all to be television critics — close watchers of the people on screen, and what their actions signify, and what those gestures mean in relation to the symbols they are interacting with. We are watching National Anthems like we are reading tea leaves. Donald Trump is not much of a uniter, except perhaps when it comes to bringing together those who oppose him. But because he came from TV, and watches so much of it, he has unerringly pointed us toward what really unites us.

Popular on Variety

More Politics

  • Queen Elizabeth

    Queen Elizabeth's Footman Diagnosed with Coronavirus (Report)

    Coronavirus remains firmly in the royal orbit as one of Queen Elizabeth’s footmen has reportedly tested positive for COVID-19. The royal footman, who regularly walks the Queen’s dogs and was in regular contact with the monarch, is now in self-isolation after falling ill with coronavirus, according to British tabloid The Sun. The revelation comes just [...]

  • House Speaker Nancy Pelosi

    House Passes $2 Trillion Coronavirus Bill as Lawmakers Promise Additional Aid

    The House of Representatives passed the $2 trillion stimulus package on Friday, even as lawmakers said another rescue package would be needed. The bill passed on a voice vote. President Donald Trump signed the measure on Friday afternoon in the Oval Office. Most Americans will receive a one-time payment of $1,200 plus $500 per child. [...]

  • Chuck Schumer

    Senate Approves Massive $2 Trillion Coronavirus Stimulus Bill

    The Senate voted on Wednesday to approve a $2 trillion bill to cushion the economic fallout of the coronavirus pandemic, including hundreds of billions for companies and a massive expansion of unemployment benefits. The Senate voted 96-0 to approve the measure, after two votes earlier in week failed along party lines. The House of Representatives [...]

  • Mitch McConnell

    Senate Leaders Reach Deal on $2 Trillion Coronavirus Bill

    Senate leaders and the White House have reached a deal on a $2 trillion stimulus package, which includes a large increase in unemployment insurance and hundreds of billions of dollars to aid companies harmed by the coronavirus pandemic. Shortly before 2 a.m. on Wednesday morning, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell announced on the Senate floor [...]

  • Coronavirus India lockdown

    India's Prime Minister Orders Lockdown of Country of 1.3 Billion People for 21 Days

    Prime Minister Narendra Modi of India announced a sweeping, nationwide lockdown on Tuesday, declaring citizens across the country of 1.3 billion must stay at home for the next three weeks. Addressing the country for the second time in a week, the prime minister said the decree, which takes effect at midnight Tuesday, was a necessary [...]

  • White House Shutterstock

    White House Reporter Believed to Have Coronavirus

    A reporter who works at the White House is believed to have the novel coronavirus, the White House Correspondents’ Association said on Monday. In a memo to its members, the WHCA said the reporter was at the White House four times in the last two weeks: on March 9, 11, 16 and 18. “We encourage [...]

  • Coronavirus UK

    U.K. Declares Partial Coronavirus Lockdown, Bans Gatherings of More Than Two People

    U.K. prime minister Boris Johnson has declared a partial lockdown of the country, effective immediately. In an address broadcast to the nation on Monday evening, Johnson urged Britons to stay home to save lives. The prime minister forbade leaving home for anything apart from shopping for basic necessities like food and medicines, medical needs, one [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content