You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Oscar Eligibility Decisions Give Musical Scores a Shot

Oscar’s disqualification of the original scores for “Arrival” and “Manchester by the Sea” have been much-debated in the music community in recent weeks. What has garnered considerably less attention, but may have a big impact on the music competition in years to come, is how the Academy music branch has treated this year’s musicals.

For the first time in many years, the branch executive committee has declared all of the year’s major year-end songfests – including “La La Land,” “Moana,” “Sing” and “Trolls” – eligible for the “original score” Academy Award.

This is a marked difference from previous years, when song-dominated films have been routinely disqualified from the score Oscar on the basis of a long-standing Oscar rule denying eligibility if “it has been diminished in impact by the predominant use of songs.”

Last year, for example, the dramatic score for “Straight Outta Compton” was declared ineligible under this rule, and in 2013, the score for “Frozen” was similarly barred from the competition — because there were songs in both. In earlier years, the background scores for such song-dominated films as “Enchanted” and “Happy Feet” were also declared ineligible.

So what’s changed? The rules remain the same, according to Academy officials. It is the interpretation of those rules that appears to be in flux.

This year, the Academy seems to have thrown the doors open wide, announcing that 145 original scores were eligible for 2016 films, a much higher total than in previous years (in 2015, there were 112; in 2014, there were 114; and in 2013, also 114).

The eyebrow-raisers were the inclusion of the scores for “La La Land” by Justin Hurwitz, “Moana” by Mark Mancina, “Sing” by Joby Talbot, and “Trolls” by Christophe Beck. “La La Land” and “Moana” each contain several original songs, and both “Sing” and “Trolls” feature numerous covers. (Beck was also the composer of “Frozen,” which the branch disqualified in 2013.)

Senior music-branch governor Charles Bernstein denies that any precedent is being broken, or newly established. “Each achievement is looked at,” he says. “If that achievement gets a bit of an advantage from the songs, would it be unfair to disqualify it? Each year the committee looks at each (entry) and comes to a conclusion. All of the scores stood on their own.”

Fellow governor Laura Karpman expressed similar thoughts: “Every single score was considered, and all the ramifications were considered with great, great care. Everybody is very diligent. It’s not about what happened 10 years ago. It’s about considering what we have in front of us, and what is going on in contemporary scoring.”

More Film

  • Li Shaohong

    Li Shaohong Revisits Macao and Chinese War Films

    Fifth generation director Li Shaohong’s career has spanned the entire length of the Chinese film market’s rise, from its days as a state-run industry churning out nothing but social realist films to its current stage of supporting ever more sophisticated and lucrative blockbusters and genre films. The current head of the China Film Directors’ Guild, [...]

  • Editorial use only. No book cover

    Johnny Ma on the Dynamics of New Era Film Production in China

    Shanghai-born Canadian filmmaker Johnny Ma says he’d planned to make three films in China before moving on to other things, but the current state of the Chinese industry has “forced his hand” and convinced him to move on early after two. Currently living in Mexico, his next project is actually in TV: a pilot for [...]

  • 'Wonder Woman 1984' Trailer: Gal Gadot

    'Wonder Woman 1984' Trailer: Gal Gadot Returns With Pedro Pascal, Kristen Wiig

    “Wonder Woman 1984” dropped its first trailer on Sunday, with Gal Gadot returning as the titular Amazonian goddess. The film is set, of course, in the 1980s in America, decades after the first film’s events. Kristen Wiig is playing Wonder Woman’s infamous comic-book nemesis Cheetah, while Chris Pine is returning for the sequel. It’s unclear, [...]

  • Over the Sea

    Macao Film Review: 'Over the Sea'

    The beginning is a fairy tale, or a nursery rhyme. A woman nurses her squalling baby in a house by an orchard near the sea. Sunlight slants in through the open windows, the mother hums a lullaby, and then brings her son outside and places him in a cot suspended from the apple-laden branches of [...]

  • CCA Film Nominations

    Critics' Choice: 'The Irishman,' 'Once Upon a Time in Hollywood' Lead Movie Nominations

    “The Irishman” has picked up the most film nominations for the 35th annual Critics’ Choice Awards. The Martin Scorsese gangster drama goes into the awards show with 14 noms, including best picture, director, acting ensemble as well as best actor (Robert De Niro) and supporting actor (Al Pacino and Joe Pesci), the Critics’ Choice Association [...]

  • Parasite

    'Parasite' Named Best Film of 2019 by L.A. Film Critics Association

    Hollywood’s hometown critics clearly aren’t afraid of subtitles. Members of the Los Angeles Film Critics Assn. met Sunday to vote on the year’s best cinema accomplishments. South Korean thriller “Parasite” fared the best, taking not only best picture, but also the group’s director prize for Bong Joon Ho and supporting actor for Song Kang Ho. [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content