You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Oscar Eligibility Decisions Give Musical Scores a Shot

Oscar’s disqualification of the original scores for “Arrival” and “Manchester by the Sea” have been much-debated in the music community in recent weeks. What has garnered considerably less attention, but may have a big impact on the music competition in years to come, is how the Academy music branch has treated this year’s musicals.

For the first time in many years, the branch executive committee has declared all of the year’s major year-end songfests – including “La La Land,” “Moana,” “Sing” and “Trolls” – eligible for the “original score” Academy Award.

This is a marked difference from previous years, when song-dominated films have been routinely disqualified from the score Oscar on the basis of a long-standing Oscar rule denying eligibility if “it has been diminished in impact by the predominant use of songs.”

Last year, for example, the dramatic score for “Straight Outta Compton” was declared ineligible under this rule, and in 2013, the score for “Frozen” was similarly barred from the competition — because there were songs in both. In earlier years, the background scores for such song-dominated films as “Enchanted” and “Happy Feet” were also declared ineligible.

So what’s changed? The rules remain the same, according to Academy officials. It is the interpretation of those rules that appears to be in flux.

This year, the Academy seems to have thrown the doors open wide, announcing that 145 original scores were eligible for 2016 films, a much higher total than in previous years (in 2015, there were 112; in 2014, there were 114; and in 2013, also 114).

The eyebrow-raisers were the inclusion of the scores for “La La Land” by Justin Hurwitz, “Moana” by Mark Mancina, “Sing” by Joby Talbot, and “Trolls” by Christophe Beck. “La La Land” and “Moana” each contain several original songs, and both “Sing” and “Trolls” feature numerous covers. (Beck was also the composer of “Frozen,” which the branch disqualified in 2013.)

Senior music-branch governor Charles Bernstein denies that any precedent is being broken, or newly established. “Each achievement is looked at,” he says. “If that achievement gets a bit of an advantage from the songs, would it be unfair to disqualify it? Each year the committee looks at each (entry) and comes to a conclusion. All of the scores stood on their own.”

Fellow governor Laura Karpman expressed similar thoughts: “Every single score was considered, and all the ramifications were considered with great, great care. Everybody is very diligent. It’s not about what happened 10 years ago. It’s about considering what we have in front of us, and what is going on in contemporary scoring.”

More Film

  • Cats Movie

    'Cats' New Trailer Hits, Internet Sharpens Claws

    Universal Pictures debuted the full length trailer for “Cats” Tuesday, giving viewers another look at “digital fur technology” and attempting to answer what Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical is actually about. “Tonight is a magical night where I choose the cat that deserves a new life,” Judi Dench’s Old Deuteronomy narrates in the new footage. After [...]

  • Everybody Changes

    New Cadence Productions Acquires Domestic Rights to Panama's 'Everybody Changes'

    New Cadence Productions has acquired North American rights to the transgender family drama “Everybody Changes,” Panama’s official selection for the 92nd annual Academy Awards. The movie from writer-director Arturo Montenegro tells the true story of a Panamanian couple with three children who grapple with the father’s decision to come out as a transgender woman. “Everybody [...]

  • Apollo 11

    'American Factory,' 'Apollo 11' Receive PGA Documentary Nominations

    The Producers Guild of America has unveiled the nominations for its 2020 Documentary Motion Picture awards. “Advocate,” “American Factory,” “Apollo 11,” “The Cave,” “For Sama,” “Honeyland” and “One Child Nation” were nominated. The winner will be announced on Jan. 18 at the 31st Annual Producers Guild Awards at the Hollywood Palladium. The PGA said Tuesday [...]

  • Awkwafina Taron Egerton Variety Actors on

    Taron Egerton and Awkwafina Share a Love for Elton John, ‘My Vag’ and Miss Piggy

    Awkwafina (“The Farewell”) and Taron Egerton (“Rocketman”) sat down for a chat for “Variety Studio: Actors on Actors.” For more, click here. Taron Egerton’s portrayal of Elton John in “Rocketman” is both extravagant and humanizing, as he reinterprets John’s classic songs to tell the iconic singer’s life story. In “The Farewell,” Awkwafina plays Billi, a [...]

  • Roman Polanski

    French Guild Moves Closer to Sanctions on Members Accused of Sexual Misconduct

    France’s authors, directors and producers guild has moved a step closer to imposing sanctions on any member under investigation for or guilty of a sexual offense – a process that could result in the suspension of controversial director Roman Polanski. The board of the ARP voted Monday evening in favor of the policy, which now [...]

  • Jumanji The Next Level

    Hollywood Banks on 'Star Wars,' 'Jumanji 2' for Big Box Office Finish

    When exhibitor Jeff Logan talks to friends and customers about upcoming movies, he’s sometimes greeted with a shrug. “I’ll tell them there’s a new ‘Terminator’ and they’ve brought back Arnold and Linda Hamilton, and they don’t seem too excited about that,” says Logan. “Or there’s another ‘Rambo,’ and they’ll go, ‘Geez, isn’t he getting old?’ [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content