×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Fyre Festival Lawsuits Advance on Dual Civil, Criminal Tracks

A petition to consolidate civil class action lawsuits against Fyre Media and company co-founders Billy McFarland and Ja Rule will come before a panel of federal court judges in Los Angeles on July 27. Meanwhile, the criminal investigation continues, with grand jury subpoenas issued and involvement by U.S. attorneys in California.

Plaintiff litigators expect the Fyre defense team will, on or before that day, move to put the civil cases on hold pending the outcome of the criminal proceedings, still in the early stages but now active on both coasts, as assistant U.S. attorneys and FBI agents in New York, Florida, and California gather evidence.

In addition to the six federal and one state class action lawsuit, four individual lawsuits are also proceeding. These include complaints filed by lenders. McFarland’s attorneys agreed that by the close of business Friday they would deposit $240,000 into an escrow account on behalf of lender Oleg Itkin, who is owed $800,000. Itkin’s attorney, Caitlin Robin & Associates, has been very aggressive and is the first among 11 lawsuits filed to get a formal response from defendants McFarland and Fyre Media and force them before a judge. The matter is scheduled for hearing in a New York state court on May 31.

Meanwhile, anticipating bankruptcy or insolvency on the part of Fyre, the plaintiffs are maneuvering to keep deep-pocketed Fyre investors on the hook as defendants. Named defendants thus far include New York socialite Carola Jain and Robert Nemeth of the Connecticut-based Perkins Fund Marketing.

So far, Jain and Nemeth are named in one investor suit, although the $100 million class action suit filed April 30 by Geragos & Geragos was subsequently amended to attach them, while stopping short of formally naming them. While they are likely to be subpoenaed in the criminal investigation, it is unknown at this point whether they will be targets and whether they will be able to stay civil proceedings as a result.

As far as McFarland and Ja Rule go, the consensus is they will invoke their Fifth Amendment rights and avoid direct questioning in the civil matters pending resolution of the criminal investigation. Experts agree that while they might try, they will be unlikely to succeed in deferring the civil class action consolidation.

“When life and liberty is placed at risk, the courts put a high premium on deference to the integrity of federal criminal prosecutions,” said Ben Meiselas, an attorney with Geragos & Geragos. Meiselas said his firm’s suit, filed in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California, now has about 1,000 active plaintiff participants.

The U.S. Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation has set a June 10 deadline for written response to the multi-district consolidation request, which was initiated by Levi & Korsinsky, which filed suit in New York but is managing the case out of San Francisco, where lead attorney Rosemary Rivas had no comment.

Adam Zimmerman, a Loyola Law School professor specializing in complex civil litigation, said the fact that a criminal investigation is in progress would be enough to allow the defense to move for a stay, it is not necessary that they be formally indicted. But Zimmerman said he believes it likely the judicial council will still allow the civil class actions to move forward and be consolidated. “A pending indictment wouldn’t really impact the question of whether the civil cases warrant a transfer.  Once the cases are transferred to a single federal judge — and I would think the facts favor transfer — that judge could decide to stay the proceedings pending the outcome of the criminal case.  That is not uncommon.”

The MDL consolidation request has prompted jockeying for position among attorneys, as the panel will have the discretion to transfer the cases to a single judge who can certify a class action or assign a lead law firm to coordinate plaintiff activities. “Attorneys who take on the coordinating roles wind up very powerful, and those are lucrative positions as well,” Zimmerman said.

The likelihood is the judicial panel will consolidate in New York, where the defendants are based, and the U.S. Department of Justice is managing the criminal investigation out of its Manhattan office. Under MDL a single court would hear all pretrial motions and manage the class action cases, which would then go back to the venue where the case was filed for its hearing.

But most civil class actions – an estimated 90 percent – settle before going to trial. In the case of Fyre, settlement may be hampered if Fyre Media principals do not have the financial resources to offer compensation. In that case, the plaintiffs will push for incarceration while still pursuing financial restitution from others who may have liability and means is the consensus among those involved with the case.

Representatives from the U.S. attorney’s office and lawyers for McFarland and Fyre Media had no comment. Nemeth and Jain did not return calls. Stacey Richman, the lawyer representing Ja Rule, whose name is Jeffrey Atkins, issued a statement that states: “Mr. Atkins would never participate in anything fraudulent, it is simply not in his DNA. He is devastated at the aftermath of what he genuinely had hoped would be an incredible event for all.”

Popular on Variety

More Music

  • Ric Ocasek'The Imitation Game' film premiere,

    Ric Ocasek’s Cause of Death Revealed, Paulina Porizkova Posts Touching Note

    Cars frontman Ric Ocasek died of cardiovascular disease, according to an autopsy report released Monday by the New York City medical examiner’s office cited by Yahoo News and other outlets. More specifically, the cause was hypertensive and atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, also called atherosclerosis, which is an accumulation of plaque in the arteries that can weaken [...]

  • Megan Thee StallionMegan Thee Stallion in

    Megan Thee Stallion Confirms She's Collaborating With Kehlani on Next Album (EXCLUSIVE)

    Hip-hop’s It Girl of the summer, Megan Thee Stallion, has exclusively told Variety that she’s collaborating with Kehlani and a few other famous ladies on her next album. The rapper, who dropped a video for her song of the season “Hot Girl Summer” earlier this month, was asked by Variety on the red carpet at Rihanna’s annual [...]

  • Schoolboy Q

    ScHoolboy Q Reveals ‘CrasH’ Tour Dates

    Top Dawg Entertainment recording artist ScHoolboy Q today announced dates for his next jaunt across the country, the CrasH Tour 2019. Special guest NAV will join on select dates; dates appear in full below Produced by Live Nation, the 19-city tour will kick off November 4 in Houston and make stops in Atlanta, Brooklyn, Toronto, Chicago, and more [...]

  • United Talent Agency Reveals New Logo

    UTA Unveils New Logo, Corporate Image

    UTA raised the curtain Monday on a new corporate logo. The three-dimensional image is meant to emphasize the talent agency’s focus on uniting ideas, opportunities and talent. Building signage with the new logo will go up next month at UTA’s headquarters in Beverly Hills. “Our new identity captures the multiple facets and intersections of our [...]

  • Taylor SwiftMTV Video Music Awards, Arrivals,

    Taylor Swift Joins 'The Voice' Season 17 as a Mentor

    Taylor Swift is returning to “The Voice” as a mega mentor in the upcoming 17th season of the NBC singing competition series. The “Blank Space” singer will offer advice to each team of artists as they prepare for the knockout rounds in the show. Coaches John Legend and Blake Shelton took to Instagram to share [...]

  • Ric Ocasek and Alice Cooper 1989Ric

    Seven Times Ric Ocasek Surprised Us, From 'Hairspray' to Bad Brains

    In a universe of strong and eccentric personalities, Cars frontman Ric Ocasek, who died Sunday at the age of 75, was certainly – and happily – an odd bird. By most accounts he was quite friendly in person, yet Ocasek, 75, always seemed distant and aloof, as if he was as hermetically sealed off from [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content