Pre-Broadway Review: Jimmy Buffett Musical ‘Escape to Margaritaville’

Paul Alexander Nolan, Alison Luff, Lisa Howard, Eric Petersen, Rema Webb, Don Sparks, Andre Ward, Ian Michael Stuart. With: Matt Allen, Tessa Alves, Sara Andreas, Samantha Farrow, Steven Good, Angela Grovey, Albert Guerzon, Autumn Guzzardi, Keely Hutton, Mike Millan, Justin Mortelliti, Ryann Redmond, Julius Anthony Rubio, Brett Thiele

2 hours, 20 mins

You know what you’re ordering with a musical comedy based on the music of Jimmy Buffett, an artist whose beach bum persona and preference for Hawaiian shirts and flip-flops contribute as much to his success as his formidable songwriting skills. “Escape to Margaritaville,” now in Chicago as the last stop on a pre-Broadway mini-tour, successfully pulls off the laid-back attitude while delivering a paint-by-numbers, frequently goofy romantic comedy replete with many of Buffett’s most popular tunes. This show is superficial but enjoyable, a happy-go-lucky entertainment that, much like its namesake beverage, goes down easy, tastes good, and leaves you with a pleasant feeling and a sudden urge to plan a vacation.

Book writers from the TV world, Greg Garcia (“My Name Is Earl”) and Mike O’Malley (“Shameless”), shape their formulaic fictional tale around singer-songwriter Tully (Paul Alexander Nolan). He entertains at a run-down but fun-loving resort (named “Margaritaville” of course) on a Caribbean island, enjoying endless opportunities for affairs as the tourists arrive, live a little, and depart. Enter vacationer Rachel (Alison Luff), much Tully’s opposite as an ambitious environmental scientist with dreams of saving the planet with potatoes. It turns out he’s pretty smart, she’s pretty funny, soon they’re in bed, and suddenly Tully’s in love.

Meanwhile, Rachel’s friend Tammy (Lisa Howard), engaged to her boorish high school sweetheart who insists she diet aggressively to fit a smaller size wedding dress, flirts with the resort’s airheaded but likeable bartender Brick (Eric Petersen).

Director Christopher Ashley (“Come From Away”) mixes spurts of over-the-top wackiness and showmanship with sedated moments of genuine feeling, and it’s his knowing when to restrain and when to let loose that makes “Escape to Margaritaville” ultimately work.

Don’t misunderstand: this is a goofy show. Sometimes, the characters talk to the audience as if we were vacationers, even encouraging us to sing along to “Why Don’t We Get Drunk” (this is a show, by the way, where audience members often sing along in a whisper). And when Brick sings about drug flashbacks, figures don’t just peek out from behind the tropical shrubs, they actually emerge as the folkloric insurance salesmen buried by the last volcano eruption. Yes… they’re zombies, in ash-covered business suits, dancing. Have a good time, folks, and don’t forget to notice the offbeat details of Kelly Devine’s choreography.

But then there are quiet moments, such as after Rachel departs at the end of the first act, ready to get back to her busy life after her fun fling. Tully begins the title song about wasting away in Margaritaville, and it comes off, at least until others join in, as an honest and even moving expression of moderate regret.

The show never, ever gets heavy, and never even seems to exert itself on developing themes or conflicts very far. But slightness can betray plenty of underlying stagecraft. There are times when, as Buffett does, the show takes on the tacky. But it manages to do so with the right level of tastefulness.

Pre-Broadway Review: Jimmy Buffett Musical 'Escape to Margaritaville'

Oriental Theater, Chicago; 2,200 seats; $115 top

Production: A Broadway in Chicago, Frank Marshall, Rich Entertainment Group, Anita Waxman, Grove Entertainment, James L. Nederlander, Jeremiah J. Harris & Darren P. Deverna, Linda G. Scott, John H. Tyson, Shubert Organization, Lattitude Link, John Morgan, Roy Furman, Jeffrey A. Sine, AC Orange Entertainment, Arlen Scanlan & Witzend Productions, Terry Allen Kramer, Universal Music Group & Scott Landis, Kevin J. Kinsella, Independent Presenters Network & Al Nocciolino, Seahenry Productions & Skolnick-Dagen, Jam Theatricals, and La Jolla Playhouse presentation of a musical in two acts with music and lyrics by Jimmy Buffet; book by Greg Garcia and Mike O’Malley. Directed by Christopher Ashley. Choreography, Kelly Devine; music supervision, arrangements, and additional orchestrations, Christopher Jahnke. Set, Walt Spangler; costumes, Paul Tazewell; lighting, Howell Binkley; sound, Brian Ronan; wigs, hair and makeup, Leah J. Louklas; flight effects, Flying by Foy; orchestrations, Michael Utley; dance music arrangements, Gary Adler; music consultant, Mac McAnally; music coordinators, Michael Keller and Michael Aarons; production stage manager, Kim Vernace. Opened, reviewed Nov. 15, 2017; runs through Dec. 2.


Paul Alexander Nolan, Alison Luff, Lisa Howard, Eric Petersen, Rema Webb, Don Sparks, Andre Ward, Ian Michael Stuart. With: Matt Allen, Tessa Alves, Sara Andreas, Samantha Farrow, Steven Good, Angela Grovey, Albert Guerzon, Autumn Guzzardi, Keely Hutton, Mike Millan, Justin Mortelliti, Ryann Redmond, Julius Anthony Rubio, Brett Thiele

More Legit

  • Williamstown Theater Festival 2016 season

    Marisa Tomei Starring in Broadway Revival of 'The Rose Tattoo'

    Marisa Tomei will star in the Broadway revival of Tennessee Williams’ “The Rose Tattoo.” The Oscar-winning actress will play Serafina, a part previously performed by the likes of Maureen Stapleton and Anna Magnani. It’s also a role that Tomei is familiar with, having starred in a Williamstown Theatre Festival production in 2016. “The Rose Tattoo” [...]

  • White Pearl review

    London Theater Review: 'White Pearl'

    Playwright Anchuli Felicia King dismantles the Asian market in this misfiring satire at London’s Royal Court Theatre. “White Pearl” makes a case that those seeking to make inroads into the Far East, perceiving a new El Dorado, are no better that colonial conquistadors of an earlier age — and entirely unequipped to understand the specifics [...]

  • Signature Theatre Celebrates Millionth Subsidized Ticket

    Signature Theatre Offers $35 Subsidized Tickets, Celebrates Millionth Sold

    Just the other night, a Manhattan cab driver told Signature Theatre executive director Harold Wolpert that he couldn’t afford to take his girlfriend to a show. In response, Wolpert motioned to his theater, saying that they offer $35 subsidized tickets. The driver said he’d try it out. “It was a great moment,” Wolpert said. “We’re [...]

  • SOCRATES The Public Theater

    Tim Blake Nelson Waxes Philosophical on Writing a Play About Socrates

    Despite Tim Blake Nelson’s knack for playing folksy characters in films such as “The Ballad of Buster Scruggs,” in his soul lurks the heart of a classicist. Nelson, who stars in HBO’s “Watchmen” series this fall, has also penned the play “Socrates,” now running at New York’s Public Theater through June 2. Doug Hughes directs, [...]

  • TodayTix - Brian Fenty

    TodayTix Banks $73 Million to Boost Theater and Arts Ticketing App

    TodayTix, a Broadway-born mobile ticketing start-up, is looking to expand into a bigger global media and transaction enterprise with a capital infusion of $73 million led by private-equity firm Great Hill Partners. The investment brings TodayTix’s total capital raised to over $100 million, according to CEO and co-founder Brian Fenty. Part of the new funding [...]

  • Ethan Hawke, Bobby Cannavale and Griffin

    BAM Gala Marks Leadership Change, Celebrates Brooklyn as 'Cultural Center of New York'

    Wednesday’s annual gala celebrating the Brooklyn Academy of Music (BAM) served as a poignant moment of transition for the New York stalwart of contemporary performance. As long-time artistic director Joe Melillo, who along with Harvey Lichtenstein transformed BAM into a vanguard of progressive art, prepares to pass the torch to new leadership, gathered patrons and [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content