You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Cannes Film Review: ‘They’

A 14-year-old’s gender-identity struggles are portrayed with persistent affectation by Anahita Ghazvinizadeh’s indie drama.

Anahita Ghazvinizadeh
Rhys Fehrenbacher, Koohyar Hosseini, Nicole Coffineau. (English, Farsi dialogue)

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5873216/?ref_=fn_al_tt_2

J (Rhys Fehrenbacher) is a Chicago teen struggling with gender identity in “They,” a film that, like its protagonist is a work of severe uncertainty. Caught between laid-back naturalism and aggravating affection, writer-director Anahita Ghazvinizadeh’s feature debut shows promise when simply coexisting with its many characters in easygoing situations. Those moments, however, are rare and fleeting, and can’t compensate for the filmmaker’s rambling storytelling and insistent aesthetic flourishes. Though its subject matter is timely and its sensitivity is palpable, the movie is far too airless and artificial to make much theatrical headway after its Cannes premiere.

Taking hormone blockers in order to delay the onset of puberty, the better to afford more time for contemplating whether to live an adult life as a male or a female, 14-year-old J — who chooses to be referred to by the pronoun “they” — lives in a state of suspended animation. If that weren’t clear enough from the basic facts of J’s condition, Ghazvinizadeh visualizes it in an endless array of fuzzy compositions that hammer home, in an ever-more-thudding manner, the character’s confusion during this period of self-definition. Those gimmicky shots are accompanied by frequent cutaways to flowers, which suggest J’s process of blossoming into their next phase — images that are often set to toy piano-style twinkling on the soundtrack.

Featuring a doggedly pretentious style, “They” also includes clunky scripting, with every conversational exchange coming across as a didactic information dump recited by actors rather than a natural chat between actual people. That this dialogue has been recorded in post-production further enhances its gracelessness. While one would like to give the film the benefit of the doubt and say that the audio/video disconnect is another reflection of J’s internal divide, it mostly feels like a technical miscalculation — one that’s exacerbated by the decision to have many lines spoken while characters’ faces and mouths are obscured if not outright off-camera.

Ghazvinizadeh’s story, as it were, concerns J being cared for by the character’s visiting sister, Lauren (Nicole Coffineau), and Lauren’s Iranian boyfriend, Araz (Koohyar Hosseini), who eventually take J to Araz’s relatives’ house for a get-together. Yet aside from a prolonged dinner-table sequence that boasts an unhurried and inviting flow that’s absent from the rest of the proceedings, “They” is merely a collection of stilted discussions designed to create thematic parallels with J’s plight. Thus, Lauren is some sort of experimental artist whose work focuses on “displacement and instability.” And Azaz, longing to see his parents — who can’t visit from Iran, and don’t want their son returning home lest he never get back to the States — is a man trapped between two cultures and countries, which he outright articulates for those who may have missed it: “I’m stuck in limbo with no clear choice.”

The performances are as wooden as the dialogue, with only Hosseini expressing anything other than flat, blank indecision and unhappiness. While Ghazvinizadeh (who studied film in both Iran and Chicago) is determined to attune her material to J’s stuck-in-the-middle unease, the lengths to which the director goes to evoke that state of being are so precious — replete with J spending copious time muttering poetry under her breath in hushed narration — that her film prevents any empathetic engagement with her protagonist’s dilemma.

Cannes Film Review: ‘They’

Reviewed at Magno Screening Room, New York, May 11, 2017. (In Cannes Film Festival — Special Screenings.) Running time: 80 MIN.

Production: A Mass Ornament Films presentation. (International sales: Luxbox, Paris.) Producers: Zoe Sua Cho, Simone Ling.

Crew: Director, writer: Anahita Ghazvinizadeh. Camera (color, widescreen, HD): Carolina Costa. Editors: Ghazvinizadeh, Dean Gonzalez. Music: Vincent Gillioz.

With: Rhys Fehrenbacher, Koohyar Hosseini, Nicole Coffineau. (English, Farsi dialogue)

More Film

  • 'The Pledge' Review

    Film Review: 'Pledge'

    “Privilege comes with sacrifice” says one character to another in “Pledge” — exactly the kind of noble sentiment authority figures always voice to hush the protests of those about to be sacrificed. This third feature for director Daniel Robbins is no delicate flower of cinematic art, but a lean and mean shocker that tells its [...]

  • John Lithgow

    John Lithgow-Blythe Danner's 'Tomorrow Man' Bought Ahead of Sundance Premiere

    In one of the first deals for the upcoming Sundance Film Festival, Bleecker Street has acquired North American rights to the John Lithgow-Blythe Danner romance “The Tomorrow Man.” The movie will hold its world premiere at the fest, which opens on Jan. 24 in Park City, Utah. The distributor is planning a May 17 release. [...]

  • Dragon Ball Super Broly

    'Dragon Ball Super: Broly' Scores Big First Day With $7 Million

    Funimation Films’ Japanese anime movie “Dragon Ball Super: Broly” has opened impressively with a dominant first-day total of $7 million at 1,260 North American locations on Wednesday. The English-language version of “Dragon Ball Super: Broly,” which screened at 180 Imax and Cinemark XD premium large format screens, generated by far the best per-screen average among [...]

  • Shoplifters Cannes

    Box Office: 'Shoplifters' Hits $2 Million to Become One of 2018's Highest-Grossing Foreign Films

    Hirokazu Kore-eda’s “Shoplifters” has become an unexpected box office success. The Japanese drama about a petty thief who adopts a young girl has earned critical raves and picked up the Palme d’Or at last year’s Cannes Film Festival. That translated into commercial success for Magnolia, the indie distributor that’s been overseeing the film’s rollout. “Shoplifters” [...]

  • C'est La Vie TIFF

    French Films' Overseas Box Office Revenue Drops 51% in 2018

    After bouncing back in 2017, the overseas box office revenue of French movies plummeted by 51% to 237 million euros ($270 million) with 40 million admissions sold, a 52% year-on drop, in 2018. The provisional box office figures were unveiled by UniFrance during a reception hosted at France’s culture minister during which Eric Toledano and [...]

  • Isabela Moner Shameik Moore Kiernan Shipka

    Netflix Casts Starry Ensemble for Adaptation of John Green's 'Let It Snow'

    “Dora the Explorer’s” Isabela Moner, “Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse’s” Shameik Moore, “Chilling Adventures of Sabrina’s” Kiernan Shipka, “Lady Bird’s” Odeya Rush, Jacob Batalon, Miles Robbins, Mitchell Hope, Liv Hewson, Anna Akana, and Joan Cusack are set to star in the Netflix pic “Let It Snow.” The film is based on the New York Times bestselling [...]

  • Brian Tyree Henry Playback Podcast If

    Listen: From 'Beale Street' to 'Spider-Verse,' Brian Tyree Henry Was Your 2018 MVP

    Welcome to “Playback,” a Variety / iHeartRadio podcast bringing you exclusive conversations with the talents behind many of today’s hottest films. Emmy- and Tony-nominated actor Brian Tyree Henry is coming off a sensational year. A second, acclaimed season of FX’s “Atlanta” sent him headlong into a fall movie season that saw featured roles in Yann [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content