Film Review: ‘The Butterfly Tree’

Australian writer-director Priscilla Cameron's Toronto-bound debut melds dark melodrama and quirky kitsch to most peculiar effect.

Priscilla Cameron
Melissa George, Ed Oxenbould, Ewen Leslie, Sophie Lowe.

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3719948/

There are manic pixie dream girls, there are hypermanic pixie dream girls, and then there is Evelyn Grey, the roller-skating, flower-selling, burlesque-dancing object of male fixation in “The Butterfly Tree.” Played with good grace and an impressively straight face by Melissa George, she’s the swirling spirit animal for this spangly, eccentric Australian tale of growing up and grief management, with a glittery side interest in lepidopterology. As brazen as it is uneven, Priscilla Cameron’s debut feature embraces high kitsch as a form of earnest therapeutic release — an approach to which viewers will find themselves either dreamily susceptible or violently allergic. In the film’s era-fudging, magical-realist world, all menfolk fall into the former column when it comes to Evelyn herself; the shared crush of a small-town college teacher and his adolescent son drives Cameron’s unabashed melodrama to quasi-Oedipal extremes it can’t quite control.

From its world premiere at the Melbourne Film Festival, “The Butterfly Tree” will flit to a slot in Toronto’s Discovery program — an apt placement for a work that, for better or worse, sometimes feels beamed in from another dimension entirely. From the opening credits, which find George performing a rhythmic striptease in monarch butterfly robes to the woozy strains of Belgian trip-hoppers Hooverphonic, Cameron trades in scenes, sounds and images that you’re unlikely to see anywhere else: By the halfway mark, a berserk digression into the supposed magnetism between scarab beetles and male nipples seems positively par for the course. Whether such novelty can pique the curiosity of international distributors remains to be seen; either way, the film’s fragrant whiff of camp could gradually earn it a following in ancillary.

Not that “The Butterfly Tree” has been made in a spirit of lurid provocation: The heart-in-hand sincerity of its worldview is what makes the film endearing and aggravating by turns. Cameron, who has ambitiously cited the likes of “Amelie” and “Pan’s Labyrinth” as influences on her debut’s dizzily heightened mise en scène, largely co-opts the naive, wonderstruck perspective of 13-year-old Fin (Ed Oxenbould), a sensitive, seemingly friendless soul who, following his mother’s recent death, is hungry for whatever semblance of beauty and magic he can find in Down Under suburbia.

Popular on Variety

Notwithstanding his butterfly collecting hobby — which allows for plentiful, near-fluorescent daydream sequences of the gaudily digitized insects in enchanting flight — most of that magic comes in the practically glowing form of Evelyn, a kindly, kooky florist and former exotic dancer newly arrived in town on a cloud of lilac perfume and wafty backstory. (The random, unresolved appearance of an abusive ex-husband in one scene fills only a couple of blanks.) In the same afternoon, she separately befriends both Fin and his disconsolate dad Al (Ewen Leslie), who has lately been channeling his widower’s grief into an illicit affair with one of his creative writing students (Sophie Lowe, projecting some foxy slyness into a barely-there character). That neither father nor son knows of the other’s acquaintance with Evelyn is a slightly wobbly contrivance; once the secret’s out, the film and characters alike lose their brightly colored marbles, with familial and romantic tensions blooming and blurring in the film’s emotional hothouse.

No one’s doing things by halves in this wilfully humidified affair: Cameron commits to her ripe aesthetic with gusto, while her skilled actors lean fully and without irony into the lathery soap-opera dramatics. That doesn’t make “The Butterfly Tree” a particularly unified or cohesive exercise at script level. In particular, the ambiguous, tenderly played relationship between Evelyn and Fin, wherein puppy-love desire and maternal yearning cross over to tricky effect, isn’t best served by the film’s simultaneous fascination with George as a fantastical goddess of quirk — accessorized equally with sparkles and Kleenex. (Her 1950s hipster-girlie look of ornately rolled updos, floral tea dresses and rollerskates doesn’t seem too anachronistic in a cellphone-free milieu that is deliberately hard to place.) The gradual, solemn exposure of Fin’s dark family history, meanwhile, is awkwardly nested in the zanier present-tense storytelling.

Then again, such over-styling accounts for much of the wonky pleasure on offer here: If the film does end up finding the cult it seeks, the synthetic, iridescent work by costume designer Chrissy Flannery and production designer Charlie Shelley, captured by cinematographer Jason Hargreaves with a mixture of gauzy romanticism and garish distortion, will have a lot to do with it. David LaChapelle-meets-Baz Luhrmann images of Evelyn in a sequined, feather-lined bathrobe, tending to the fragile out-of-season flowers — poignant metaphor alert — in her spectacular glass greenhouse are the vivid, sticky takeaways from “The Butterfly Tree”; not all its deeper ideas, however, emerge from the chrysalis.

Film Review: 'The Butterfly Tree'

Reviewed at Melbourne Film Festival (Australian Films), Aug. 11, 2017. (Also at Toronto Film Festival — Discovery.) Running time: 96 MIN.

Production: (Australia) A Screen Queensland, Cowlick Entertainment Group presentation of a Midwinter Films production in association with Melbourne International Film Festival Premiere Fund, The Post Lounge, Vendetta Prods., Film Victoria. Producer: Bridget Callow-Wright. Executive producers: Michael Wrenn, Shaun Miller, Phil Bremner, Jill Macnab, Peter Drinkwater. Co-producers: Simon Callow-Wright, Jade Van Der Lei, Abi Tabone.

Crew: Director, screenplay: Priscilla Cameron. Camera (color, widescreen): Jason Hargreaves. Editor: Rodrigo Balart. Music: Caitlin Yeo.

With: Melissa George, Ed Oxenbould, Ewen Leslie, Sophie Lowe.

More Film

  • Running on Empty

    Berlin: Lisa Weber on Empathy and Courage in Her Panorama Doc 'Running on Empty'

    Nineteen-year-old Claudia lives with her mother, brother and four-year-old son in a public housing complex in Vienna, with no job, no prospects on the horizon, and the present slipping by in a series of uneventful days. But in “Running on Empty,” which premiered Feb. 25 in the Panorama section of the Berlin Film Festival, director Lisa [...]

  • Evgenia Markova

    Berlin: New Roskino CEO Evgenia Markova Moves to Boost Russian Film Biz

    With relations between Russia and the U.S. growing frostier amid renewed allegations of election interference by Moscow ahead of the 2020 presidential polls, the new head of Russian movie support agency Roskino is banking on a thaw, as the country unveils a host of measures to lure foreign productions and boost the growing Russian film [...]

  • Rob Schneider'The Week Of' film premiere,

    Rob Schneider To Star in and Direct Spanish-Language Comedy ‘Amor es Amor’ (EXCLUSIVE)

    BERLIN — Teaming two of the most energetic players on the new Spanish-language content scene, El Estudio and Infinity Hill are teaming to produce “Amor es Amor,” Rob Schneider’s Spanish-language movie debut as both an actor and director. A comedy, “Amor es Amor” turns on Enrique Juarez, an up-and-coming Mexican telenovela actor on the verge [...]

  • Pari

    Berlin: Siamak Etemadi on Finding His Path in Panorama Player 'Pari'

    Stunned to discover that her son has vanished while studying abroad in Athens, an Iranian woman sets off on a desperate search across the Greek capital to find him. Navigating a foreign and forbidding landscape, she’s forced to also travel deep within herself, uncovering buried truths and offering a chance for her own reinvention. “Pari” [...]

  • Cocoon of Stone

    Japan’s Wowow Makes Move Into Theatrical Releasing (EXCLUSIVE)

    Japanese pay-TV leader Wowow is to expand into theatrical releasing. The company made its theatrical buying debut this week at the Berlin Film Festival’s accompanying European Film Market. With linear channels and a movie-driven on-demand service, Wowow is already one of the leading consumers of movie content in Japan, and boasts 2.8 million subscribers. These [...]

  • Stormtroopers'Star Wars: The Last Jedi' film

    What Disney’s CEO Shake-Up Means for Its Movie Business

    After rocking a quiet Tuesday afternoon with news of leadership changes at the very top of the Walt Disney Corporation, attention has turned to respective divisions at the Hollywood superpower — and to what the side-stepping of Bob Iger and ascension of new CEO Bob Chapek might mean for the future. This includes Disney’s Goliath [...]

  • Jeremy Renner

    John Ottman Hosts Jeremy Renner, Michael Keaton, More at 'Aiding Australia' Benefit

    Film editor and composer John Ottman, who won an Oscar for “Bohemian Rhapsody” in 2019, hosted members of the film, television and music communities at the “Aiding Australia” charity dinner and concert held at his West Hollywood home on Sunday evening (Feb. 23). The benefit raised funds to help in the recovery of fire-ravaged Australia, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content