You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Surviving Peace’

A documentary about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict dares to pose a tough question about the two-state solution: Does Israel really want it?

Josef Avesar, Charles Fredricks
Josef Avesar, Mohammed Al Madani, Bernard Avishai, Uri Avnery, Sam Bahour, Omer Bar Lev, Yossi Beilin, Avraham Burg, Munther Dajani, Michael Dukakis, Saeb Erekat, Galia Golan, Jeff Halper, John Mearsheimer, Natan Ophir, Mazim Qumsiyeh, Efraim Sneh, Elias Zananiri.
Release Date:
Oct 13, 2017

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt4975304/

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict is a morass, but that doesn’t mean a documentary about it can afford to be. It shouldn’t oversimplify, but it should shine a light through the darkness, which is what several key documentaries out of Israel have recently done. “The Gatekeepers” offered the startling vision of six former leaders of the Shin Bet — Israel’s internal security service — testifying to the self-destructive nature of current Israeli policy; it was the hawks from the trenches calling out the armchair warriors. And earlier this year, “The Settlers” was a masterly piece of history: In letting us glimpse the invisible organic design of the Israeli settlement movement, almost as if by time-lapse photography, it revealed the insidious life-of-its-own dynamic that has rendered that movement more powerful, even, than Israel’s supreme leaders.

Surviving Peace” isn’t as good a film (it’s more of a personalized ramble), yet it dares to frame the issues in a way the mainstream news media doesn’t, and so it passes the test of an urgent and bold one. By the time it’s over, you see the old conflicts with new eyes.

The film’s co-director, interviewer, and political-spiritual explorer, Josef Avesar, is a 64-year-old personal-injury attorney based in Los Angeles, but he was born in Israel to Zionist parents who emigrated from Iraq, where they mostly spoke Arabic. Avesar’s grand thesis is that the two-state solution, with a Jewish State and a Palestinian State living side by side, separate but equal, has been the stated goal of negotiations for 70 years, but that the chief reason the dream has never taken hold is that the Israelis, in their bones, don’t really want it.

A figure like Jimmy Carter, of course, would vehemently disagree with that. He would say, “No, in 1978, we were this close.” Yet for those who have followed the conflict for decades that feel like centuries, and who have come to view the notion that “we were this close” as a reflexive mythology that’s really a canard, many of the thoughts voiced in “Surviving Peace” make a cathartic kind of sense.

Avesar speaks to current and former members of the Knesset (the Israeli parliament), and since he purposefully chose figures who tilt toward the progressive side of things, the interviews illustrate his point in a dramatic fashion: If these people think that the two-state solution is a charade, then who is there left to believe in it? A Knesset member named Avraham Burg poses the bald question, “Can the Jewish people survive without an external enemy?” He describes Israel as “the biggest shtetl ever created,” invoking a ghetto-fortress psychology that, he says, is more potent than any desire for peace.

There are other dynamics at play. Israel has its own military-industrial complex, with a defense industry that props up the economy; the conflict-without-end between Israel and the Palestinians is the engine of that complex. Avesar also speaks to eloquent leaders, academics, and negotiators from the Palestinian community, like the entrepreneur Sam Bahour and the Al Quds Bard Honors College dean Munther Dajani, who are far more drawn, intellectually and spiritually, to a one-state solution — as many Palestinians are, since it would likely mean a demographically shared Palestine phasing out a domineering Jewish State. It’s no big surprise that the Israelis interviewed by Avesar reject this notion as unthinkable.

But if the Israelis don’t want a one-state solution, and if the two-state solution is the perpetually dangling carrot — the Holy Grail no one can get to — that they have semi-consciously undermined, then what do they want? “Surviving Peace” dares to argue that a policy of perpetual embattlement and apartheid suits Israel, even many of its liberals, just fine. Yet several of them confess that they think the region is doomed to collapse. Avesar isn’t afraid of being a noodge (that’s why he’s a good journalist-documentarian), and over and over he asks members of the Knesset a third-rail question: How is it possible that Israel can call itself a Jewish State and a democracy at the same time? The answers are intensely revealing, not because they’re good answers (they’re hazy and waffling), but because they dramatize the layers of denial behind that contradiction.

Avesar raises, but still underplays, a factor that has wedged the Jews and Palestinians apart from the beginning: the rejection — first by the Arabs in 1947, then by the Zionists — of a divided Jerusalem. And he leaves one crucial issue totally off the table: the fact that Israel has always been, in essence, a military colony of the United States. But that’s another documentary entirely — one that I hope, in this era of greater truth-telling about Israel, will now be made.

“Surviving Peace” is 90 minutes of talking heads, and that should prune its audience down to the most hardened of international political junkies. Yet the interviews, in all their candid paradox, allow us to take the temperature of the region, and to understand why things have regressed the way that they have. Avesar devotes the last part of his movie to a pie-in-the-sky plan: the idea of an Israeli-Palestinian “confederation” that would provide a pathway to peace. He’s trying to see his way out of the morass, but as his own film demonstrates, you may never be further from a “solution” to the Middle East crisis then when you’re sure you have one.

Film Review: 'Surviving Peace'

Reviewed online, Oct. 19, 2017. MPAA Rating: Not rated. Running time: 93 MIN.

Production: A Dancing Owl Media release. Producers: Josef Avesar, Charles Fredricks. Executive producer: Josef Avesar.

With: Josef Avesar, Mohammed Al Madani, Bernard Avishai, Uri Avnery, Sam Bahour, Omer Bar Lev, Yossi Beilin, Avraham Burg, Munther Dajani, Michael Dukakis, Saeb Erekat, Galia Golan, Jeff Halper, John Mearsheimer, Natan Ophir, Mazim Qumsiyeh, Efraim Sneh, Elias Zananiri.

More Film

  • Michael B. Jordan Jordan Vogt-Roberts

    Film News Roundup: Michael B. Jordan, Jordan Vogt-Roberts Team for Monster Movie

    In today’s film news roundup, Michael B. Jordan is producing a creature feature, billiards champ Cisero Murphy is getting a movie, the sixth Terminator movie gets a title, and Graham King receives an honor. PROJECT UNVEILED More Reviews Video Game Review: 'The Division 2' Off Broadway Review: John Guare's 'Nantucket Sleigh Ride' New Regency and [...]

  • Nicolas Cage

    Nicolas Cage to Star in Martial Arts Actioner 'Jiu Jitsu'

    Nicolas Cage will star in the martial arts actioner “Jiu Jitsu,” based on the comic book of the same name. The cast will also include Alain Moussi, who stars in the “Kickboxer” franchise. Dimitri Logothetis is producing with Martin Barab and directing from a script he wrote with Jim McGrath. Highland Film Group is handling [...]

  • Chinese success of Thai film "Bad

    Chinese, Thai Shingles Pact for Co-Production Fund at FilMart

    A deal to establish a 100 million yuan ($14.9 million) co-production fund between China and Thailand was struck at FilMart on Tuesday to help launch TV and film projects that will appeal to Chinese and Southeast Asian audience. The deal that was struck by China’s Poly Film Investment Co., TW Capital from Thailand and Thai [...]

  • Kevin Tsujihara

    Kevin Tsujihara's Ouster Kicks Off a Week of Major Disruption in the Media Business

    The sudden ouster of Warner Bros. Entertainment chief Kevin Tsujihara kicked off what is likely to go down as one of the most extraordinary weeks in Hollywood history, spelling enormous turmoil and transition across the media landscape. In addition to the news about Tsujihara, which comes amid a wider shake-up of leadership at AT&T’s WarnerMedia, [...]

  • Buddha in Africa

    More Than Half of Films at Hot Docs Film Festival Are Directed by Women

    More than half of the films playing at Hot Docs, North America’s largest documentary festival, are directed by women, the Canadian event said Tuesday. The festival’s 26th edition, which runs April 25-May 5, will screen 234 films, with 54% of the directors being women. In the competitive International Spectrum program, notable films receiving their world [...]

  • Korean Distributors Fight for Box Office

    Korean Distributors Fight for Box Office Market Share

    Korean distributors are having to fight ever harder for their share of Korea’s theatrical market share. Threats on the horizon include a slide in the performance of local movies, consolidation, the arrival of new players and the challenge from streaming services. South Korea’s theatrical box office is now bigger than that of France or Germany despite [...]

  • Korean Distributors Learn to Downsize in

    Korean Distributors Learn to Downsize in Saturated Market

    In 2018, the Korean film business stumbled, as local films made with blockbuster budgets and targeting the usual high seasons of Chuseok and Christmas last year failed to deliver blockbuster earnings.  So Korean distributors have embraced some tactics to enhance their bottom lines.  Genre films “Monstrum,” “Fengshui,” “The Negotiation,” “Take Point,” “Swing Kids” and “Drug King” [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content