×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Film Review: ‘Santoalla’

An evocative doc investigating the disappearance of Martin Verfondern from his adopted home, a remote, near-abandoned village in Galicia.

Director:
Andrew Becker, Daniel Mehrer
With:
(Gallego, English dialogue)

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt5816712/

One morning in 1997 after a two-year-long sojourn around Europe in a camper van, Dutch couple Martin Verfondern and Margo Pool woke up on a hillside in Galicia, in northern Spain and decided they’d found home. The village — little more than a collection of abandoned tumbledown structures clinging to the side of a mountain — was called Santa Eulalia, though even its name seemed to have collapsed in on itself, being more often referred to as Santoalla. Part of the attraction for the young couple, making a new, hippy-tinged, self-sufficient life for themselves, was its isolation. Not even the mailman delivered out there, so it’s hard to imagine how directing team Andrew Becker and Daniel Mehrer found their way. But in their debut documentary feature, this tiny hidden hamlet, and the even tinier human tragedy that unfolded within it, is brought to wider attention. While “Santoalla” is a small story, its poignancy resonates, like an echo finding its way through the peaks and valleys of this windswept, eternal landscape.

Unfolding in a chronologically shifting collage of interviews, imagery of the ruined village and its environs, and found footage — much of it shot by Martin himself over the years — the film is far from the most formally daring documentary of the year. But the undemonstrative classicism of the approach feels appropriate to a tale of bad blood, mistrust of outsiders, land and greed that is nearly as old as the hills in which it takes place. The story of Martin Verfondern’s 2010 disappearance (the film is a kind of true-crime éxposé, though the mystery’s solution is more prosaic than revelatory) is full of peculiar, lonely pathos: This was a power play that happened over an all-but-disregarded patch of land, between the only two families on earth who loved it.

Martin and Margo’s neighbors in Santoalla — its only other residents — were the Rodriguez family: Mother Jovita, a wizened elder, interviewed often in the village church that she has all to herself; hard-working son Julio and his slow-witted brother Carlos; and patriarch Manolo, the de facto lord of this crumbling domain. Julio was at first friendly with the ponytailed, guitar-playing Martin, who had dreams not just of running a self-sufficient farm, but of improving and repairing this wild little corner of Eden, of arresting its decline and seeing it thrive. But as Martin came up with more schemes for village improvement and development, Manolo and the Rodriguezes found increasingly belligerent ways to block them, even issuing vague threats, such as sending one of Martin’s goats home to him wearing Julio’s jacket with a bullet in the pocket.

Tellingly, the only time we hear Manolo speak is in footage from the court case that Martin brought against him, accusing his neighbors of pocketing money meant for the upkeep of the village. (And certainly the overgrown paths and derelict houses, windows black and gaping like slack, incurious mouths, show no sign of care.) But the lack of direct input from Manolo does contribute to a feeling of imbalance. Margo’s point of view is favored, and though she is an eminently credible witness and does not present her vanished husband as some sort of saint, there’s still no attempt to view their arrival/intrusion through the neighbors’ eyes. Even Margo admits that Martin’s personality changed, he became “more serious” and more obsessed with documenting the Rodriguezes’ transgressions, but we’re left to imagine how that, coupled with their blow-in, know-nothing status, could have been quite a reasonable irritant to the long-established farming family.

One small detail is of note in that regard: Margo and Martin first fell in love in the Netherlands, where they were both passionately involved in protesting a local council’s development plans. But neither Margo nor the film’s directors make much of the irony that though they were therefore presumably committed anti-gentrification, Martin’s plans for Santoalla could be viewed as encroaching on local turf and customs in a similar way.

Absent that side of the story, “Santoalla” is primarily a touching portrait of sunny idealism turned dark and a micro-study in souring rural politics, where isolation and neglect has led to a crippling fear of change, especially among those who need to play emperor, even if their empire is nothing but dirt and stones and decline. Indeed, the most haunting presence in “Santoalla” is Santoalla itself. Little more than a ruin now, its indifference to the fate of its inhabitants feels almost malevolent. You can see why Martin loved it, but sometimes, the thing you love can kill you, and the piles of stones that once were houses being gradually reclaimed by the wild suggest the folly of trying to challenge the unconquerable entropy of this lonely, strange place.

Film Review: 'Santoalla'

Reviewed online, Berlin, July 22, 2017. (Also in Edinburgh, IDFA film festivals). Running time: 82 MIN.

Production: (Spain-U.S. — Documentary) An Oscilloscope Laboratories release of a What Delicate Pictures production, in association with Radical Media. (International sales: What Delicate Pictures, New York.) Producers: Cristina De La Torre, Andrew Becker, Daniel Mehrer. Executive Producers: Dave O'Connor, Justin Wilkes.

Crew: Directors: Andrew Becker, Daniel Mehrer. Camera (color): Becker, Mehrer. Editor: Becker. Music: Becker.

With: (Gallego, English dialogue)

More Film

  • The Favourite

    Breaking Down 'The Favourite's' Insane, Royal Dance Battle (Watch)

    We’ll go out on a limb and say no scene in this year’s crop of awards films was more WTF? than the absurd and delightful royal dance moment in “The Favourite.” Debuting early on in Yorgos Lanthimos’ female love-triangle drama, the dance serves as wonderful reminder that, even when dressed like Merchant Ivory and full [...]

  • Aquaman 2018

    'Aquaman' Reviews: What the Critics Are Saying

    Reviews of DC’s “Aquaman” vary between feelings of surprise and disappointment. Some critics are applauding director James Wan’s strong re-imagining of a previously stale character, while others are harping on DC’s inability to stack up against rival Marvel — but most are just relieved the film isn’t an all-out flop. There are virtually no qualms about [...]

  • Black Panther

    'Black Panther' Named Top Movie of 2018 by African American Film Critics Assn.

    Ryan Coogler’s “Black Panther” has won three awards from members of the African American Film Critics Association, taking the trophies for best film, director, and song for “All the Stars.” The AAFCA made the announcement Tuesday and will present the awards in ceremonies on Feb. 6 at the Taglyan Complex in Los Angeles. More Reviews [...]

  • IFFAM: Shekhar Kapur Plans Raft of

    IFFAM: Shekhar Kapur Plans New 'Elisabeth' Film (EXCLUSIVE)

    Shekhar Kapur, best known outside India for “Elizabeth,” his 1998 biopic about the 16th Century British queen, is readying a new “Elisabeth” film. Based on a musical about one of the most famous members of the Austrian royal family, the film is to be shot in German. Together with Michael Kunze and Sylvester Levay, Kapur [...]

  • Vasan Bala Sets ‘Till The Last

    Vasan Bala Takes ‘Last Breath’ Back to Ronnie Screwvala's RSVP (EXCLUSIVE)

    Vasan Bala, director of the International Film Festival & Awards Macao’s Indian competition title “The Man Who Feels No Pain” (aka “Mard Ko Dard Nahin Hota”), will next direct “Till The Last Breath” (“Marte Dum Tak”). As with “No Pain,” former Disney India managing director Ronnie Screwvala will produce through his RSVP production outfit. “No [...]

  • IFFAM: Nicolas Cage Talks Asian Cinema,

    IFFAM: Nicolas Cage Talks Asian Cinema, Chinese Money

    Nicolas Cage, the Oscar-winning actor and International Film Festival & Awards Macao talent ambassador, reckons he is no stranger to the Asian brand of cinema. He has worked with the likes of John Woo (“Face/Off”,) the Pang Brothers (“Bangkok Dangerous” remake) and Sion Sono on upcoming English-language film “Prisoners of the Ghostland.” Addressing a press [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content