×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Karlovy Vary Review: ‘Breaking News’

A TV reporter undergoes a crisis of conscience in Iulia Rugină's honest and low-key, if a bit diffuse, Romanian drama.

With:
Andi Vasluianu, Voica Oltean, Ioana Flora, Oxana Moravec (Romanian dialogue)

A compellingly well-made if minor addition to a major canon, Romanian director Iulia Rugină’s “Breaking News” bears many of the impressive hallmarks of her nation’s New Wave: emotional maturity; a restrained, naturalistic performance and shooting style; and an eye for the intimate moral conundrum that comments on a broader sphere of experience. But its conclusion lacks the devastating precision attack of the movement’s greatest works, as well as a sense, most recently felt in Cristian Mungiu’s “Graduation,” of allegorical importance: the feeling that the ripples and quakes of the story are only the most visible effects of tectonic plates of social anxiety shifting far below. Instead of sharpening the focus as the film progresses, Rugină, who enjoyed considerable commercial success at home with 2013’s “Love Building” and its 2014 sequel, gradually loosens her grip on the narrative after a tightly coiled set-up. The resulting diffusion may be true to the messiness and irresolution of real life, but it’s also slightly unsatisfying, making the story smaller and less impactful than it could have been.

“Breaking News” opens with a bang, however. In a blare of emergency sirens and shaky-cam footage we’re dropped into the middle of a crisis scene. A faulty boiler in an industrial plant has caused an explosion and, along with paramedics and firemen, telegenic TV reporter Alex Mazilu (Andi Vasluianu) and his cameraman Andrei Paraschiv (Dorin Androne) are first on the scene. Spotting an opportunity for a scoop, Alex urges a reluctant Andrei to ignore protocol and follow him into the unstable building, which makes him technically responsible when the roof the collapses in on them both, bruising and bloodying Alex, but killing Andrei.

His TV station bosses quickly establish that they’re not liable for the accident (Alex insists that going in was Andrei’s idea, not his) and their thoughts move to memorialization. They task Alex with the unenviable mission of getting Andrei’s reluctant relatives to speak on camera about the man they knew — there’s a tacit admission by the whole team, including Alex, that they themselves knew very little about their colleague. It’s just before Christmas, but Alex dutifully leaves his wife and son and travels to Andrei’s seaside home town, a location that lends the film much of its bleak, buffeted texture: Is there any place more melancholy and empty-feeling than a beach town closed up for the winter?

But Andrei’s relatives don’t open up to Alex, with Andrei’s semi-estranged teenage daughter Simona (impressive newcomer Voica Oltean) proving the most tight-lipped of all. And the more Alex discovers about Andrei, the more he realizes how little he knew him — perhaps how little we can know anybody — and how inadequate a brief, respectfully edited TV report is in encapsulating a life. Alex is caught between trying to rehabilitate Andrei in Simona’s eyes long after the fact, and manipulating her into giving him the interview he needs so that he can go home.

The personal moral dilemma is writ large, though the extent of Alex’s feelings of culpability is never made explicit. Yet the real missed opportunity in the film, economically scripted by Rugină, Ana Agopian and Oana Răsuceanu, is the lack of texture outside the central, simple conceit. The mechanics of an unfeeling, ratings-driven TV network intruding into the grief of private citizens take a back seat to Alex’s inner journey and his developing relationship with Simona.

While the act of piecing together a life from the fragments left behind — the photographs and birthday cards and scratchy home videos — is tantalizingly full of opportunities for revelation, Rugină’s rigorously anti-sensationalist perspective keeps things strictly low-key and conscientiously linear. Within that register, it’s important that her actors are as good as they are; though Vasluianu has a tricky, closed-off character to play, the scenes between him and Oltean’s Simona carry a prickly energy.

What they cannot do, however, is make the story more urgent, more resonant or more topical than it is. Rugină wrote the first draft a decade ago and the script has changed considerably since. Still, it does feel like the media landscape against which the movie is backdropped hails from a bygone era. That’s not to say that, in this time of fake news and mounting distrust of the media, everything has to address journalistic ethics head on. But in 2017, this sensitive and intelligent a tale of one reporter’s crisis of conscience, in contrast to its chyron-ready title, feels a little like yesterday’s news.

Karlovy Vary Review: 'Breaking News'

Reviewed at Karlovy Vary Film Festival (competing), July 6, 2017. Running time: 81 MIN.

Production: (Romania) A Hau-Hui Entertainment production in co-production with Libra Films Prods. Producers: Tudur Giugiu, Oana Giurgiu, Bogdan Crăciun.

Crew: Director: Iulia Rugină. Screenplay: Rugină, Ana Agopian, Oana Răsuceanu. Camera (color): Vivi Drăgan Vasile. Editor: Cătălin Cristuțiu.

With: Andi Vasluianu, Voica Oltean, Ioana Flora, Oxana Moravec (Romanian dialogue)

More Film

  • Vladimir Smutny The Painted Bird Cinematography

    Cinematographer's Craft Drives Tragicomic Story in Czech Film 'The Painted Bird'

    Czech indie producer director Vaclav Marhoul says he knew from the moment he got his hands on Jerzy Kosinski’s Holocaust novel “The Painted Bird” that he had to adapt it for the screen. More Reviews Off Broadway Review: 'The Jungle' Film Review: 'Bumblebee' Finding the book at all in Central Europe was not easy even [...]

  • Ryan Coogler Black Panther Variety Feature

    Ryan Coogler to Receive Directing Honor at Palm Springs Film Festival

    Variety will honor director Ryan Coogler at the Palm Springs International Film Festival on Jan. 4th as part of the annual 10 Directors to Watch Brunch at the Parker Palm Springs. The brunch is presented by AT&T. More Reviews Off Broadway Review: 'The Jungle' Film Review: 'Bumblebee' The “Black Panther” director will receive the annual [...]

  • Ventana Sur: 10 or So Takes

    Ventana Sur: Drilling Down on This Year’s Edition

    BUENOS AIRES —  11 takes on the biggest Ventana Sur yet, in initiatives and initial business announcements: More Reviews Off Broadway Review: 'The Jungle' Film Review: 'Bumblebee' 1.CANNES’ MOST DARING MOVE? Over the last decade, film festivals two biggest growth roadmaps have run through strengthening their industry heft, aiding an ever more challenged independent film [...]

  • Ian Schrager Ian Schrager, New York,

    Studio 54 Co-Creator Ian Schrager Wants to 'Set the Record Straight'

    In the 1970s, Studio 54 was the epicenter of New York nightlife. With wildly theatrical sets, a guest list of celebs, and jet-setters that included everyone from Andy Warhol to Grace Jones, and a pulsating disco beat, the nightclub helped define the Me Decade. But its reign was short lived. In 1980, founders Steve Rubell [...]

  • 'The Favourite,' 'Black Panther' Lead Critics'

    'The Favourite,' 'Black Panther,' 'First Man' Lead Critics' Choice Movie Nominations

    Fox Searchlight’s “The Favourite,” directed by rising art-house star Yorgos Lanthimos, led the field of film nominees for the 24th annual Critics’ Choice Awards, the Broadcast Film Critics Assn. announced Monday. The period comedy, a biting send-up of the court of Queen Anne, received 14 nominations including best picture, director, actress (Olivia Colman), supporting actress [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content