You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

San Sebastian Film Review: ‘A Fish Out of Water’

A young boy's inexplicable memories of a past family bring his present one into focus in Lai Kuo-An's enigmatic but warm-hearted debut.

Lai Kuo-An
Runyin Bai, Jen Shuo Cheng, Peggy Tseng

1 hour 30 minutes

Official Site: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt7297958

It’s one thing for your Uncle Boonmee to recall his past lives; when your kindergarten-age child starts doing it, however, it’s cause for active concern. Yet a serene, zen-like aversion to explanation is ultimately the making of “A Fish Out of Water,” a beguiling domestic fable in which real-world family strife is further complicated — but potentially healed — by the suggestion of a more tranquil parallel universe, as the young son of a separating couple embarks on a stubbornly enigmatic quest to locate his “past parents.” A loosely woven brain-teaser with a creepingly intense emotional undertow, this marks a confident, collected first foray into features directing for Taiwanese commercials veteran Lai Kuo-An.

Having premiered in Toronto’s Discovery program before landing a slot in San Sebastian’s New Directors competition, Lai’s elegantly teasing debut can expect to place in various other international showcases for fresh talent in the months to come. Modest international distribution could follow, on the strength of its intriguing premise and light-touch execution, but this is likely to remain a bigger “Fish” in the festival pond than in the arthouse ocean.

Opening somewhere towards the end of the narrative’s second act before looping back to the beginning, “A Fish Out of Water” justifies that recently fashionable structural ploy more than most: In a film where one character apparently has a different perception of space and time to the others, that introductory flash-forward gives them a kind of common temporal destination. Lai’s screenplay is in no great hurry to specify the condition that ails pre-schooler Yi-An (Run-yin Bai) and, by extension, his parents Haoteng (Jen Shuo Cheng) and Yaji (Peggy Tseng), though it appears all involved are at the end of their separate tethers. “I don’t want to see him disappointed every day,” Yaji sighs, a conclusion that spurs the family far from their Taiwan home to the prettily water-faded, wind-tousled Japanese fishing town of Toyama.

Answers, to a point, come when we rewind a year and observe the family’s gradually disrupted daily routine. Yaji and Haoteng are coming sadly but civilly apart, their relationship untenably burdened by the responsibility of caring for Haoteng’s severely incapacitated father (Akio Chen); finally, Yaji takes Yi-An and moves in with her sister. It’s to be expected that such upheaval would have an adverse psychological effect on a young child, though Yi-An’s symptoms of damage are somewhat unusual. When asked to draw a family picture by his teacher, the resulting, cloud-swirled portrait leaves out dad and adds a sister he doesn’t have — “I had one before,” is his curt explanation. He had other parents too, he says, and an idyllic house by the sea in distant Toyama: memories that are too vivid and strangely specific to be dismissed, yet don’t square with any aspect of his upbringing.

Lai has little interest in playing psychologist to his characters, giving the most confounding aspects of Yi-An’s thought process plenty of breathing room as viewers are invited to draw their own conclusions — or, as his parents increasingly decide, to hover between possibilities. These could be false memories, implanted by psychosis, or wishful projections induced by the trauma of his parents’ separation. Perhaps something delicately spiritual or supernatural is at play, with Yi-An unpeeling past incarnations or undergoing some manner of peaceful possession. Either way, the root of the boy’s alternative past proves less important than the impact — first alienating, then oddly unifying — it has on his family in their troubled present.

Lai, who has collaborated with Taiwanese titans Hou Hsiao-hsien and Chen Kuo-fu on non-feature projects, brings some of their airy, poetic humanism to proceedings. Even at its most uncanny, “A Fish Out of Water” is primarily preoccupied with fine-grained domestic details and tensions, observed with bittersweet precision: Such scenes as a doleful make-do attempt at a family birthday party with one parent absent, or a parent-teacher conference in which a Yaji’s most gnawing worries are gently confirmed, would quiver with heartache even in less extraordinary narrative circumstances. Cheng and Tseng, for their part, play even their most tear-stained scenes with restraint; seven-year-old Bai impressively navigates the prickliest aspects of Yi-An’s psychology, maintaining our sympathy without ever resorting to cutesy mugging.

Technical credits are likewise low-key but evocative of deeper feeling beneath the surface. Hsu Chih-chun sharp, fluent lensing is rich in the colors of weather, shifting with the family’s general sense of well-being, and while the wistful piano lines of Ke Jhih-hao’s lovely score threatens sentimentality, a consistent, nervous tremble of metallic percussion keeps it softly at bay.

San Sebastian Film Review: 'A Fish Out of Water'

Reviewed at San Sebastian Film Festival (New Directors), Sept. 28, 2017. (Also in Toronto Film Festival — Discovery.)

Production: (Taiwan) A Swallow Wings production. (International sales: Charades, Paris.) Producers: Gene Yao, Jason Liao. Executive producers: Albert Yao, Hsu Chao-Jen.

CREW: Director, screenplay: Lai Kuo-An. Camera (color): Hsu Chih-Chun. Editors: Lai, Lin Zih-Sian, Gene Yao. Music: Ke Jhih-Hao.

With: Runyin Bai, Jen Shuo Cheng, Peggy Tseng, Han-Yi Yao, Akio Chen.

More Film

  • Midnight Traveler review

    Film Review: 'Midnight Traveler'

    Refugees rarely get to tell their own stories, which means their stories get told for them — often inaccurately and with undue hostility. Lack of resources is one issue, but a lack of stability is another: Asylum-seekers are in a frightening state of limbo, fleeing the imminent dangers of their native countries only to suffer [...]

  • WGA Authorizing Managers, Lawyers to Make

    WGA Authorizing Managers, Lawyers to Make Deals if Agents are Fired

    The Writers Guild of America has authorized managers and lawyers to negotiate deals for writers in place of agents — if the guild tells members to fire their agents on April 7. The guild’s negotiating committee notified members of the plans in a message Wednesday. The WGA and the Association of Talent Agents having made [...]

  • Gone With the Wind Screening

    Film News Roundup: 'Gone With the Wind' Sets Event Cinema Record

    In today’s film news roundup, “Gone with the Wind” sets a new record, “Fiddler: A Miracle of Miracles” is acquired, and Tracy Oliver signs with Topic Studios. EVENT CINEMA RECORD More Reviews Film Review: 'Midnight Traveler' Film Review: ‘Made in Abyss: Journey’s Dawn’ The 80th anniversary release of “Gone with the Wind” has grossed $2.23 [...]

  • Made in Abyss - Journey’s Dawn

    Film Review: ‘Made in Abyss: Journey’s Dawn’

    It’s a Herculean effort to take a multi-volume manga like author Akihito Tsukushi’s “Made in Abyss,” adapt it into a popular anime television series, and then compress the show into a coherent feature (technically, two movies), but the folks at Sentai Filmworks have done just that. Part one, “Made in Abyss: Journey’s Dawn,” will screen [...]

  • HAF: 'Assassination,' 'Apprenticeship' Named Project Market

    HAF: 'Assassination,' 'Apprenticeship' Named Project Market Winners

    Eighteen prizes were presented on Wednesday afternoon at the closing ceremony of the Hong Kong Asia Film Financing Forum. The project market sits alongside FilMart as part of the Entertainment Expo in Hong Kong. “Wong Tai Sin Assassination” to be directed by Wong Hoi and produced by Derek Kwok Tsz-kin, was named the winner of [...]

  • Contract Placeholder Business WGA ATA Agent

    Writers Guild Makes Concession on Film Financing in Agent Talks

    The Writers Guild of America has made a concession in film financing in its negotiations with Hollywood talent agents — the second in six weeks of talks. WGA West executive director David Young said Wednesday that it had made a “significant move” toward reaching a deal with the Association of Talent Agents for a revamped [...]

  • Noah Centineo He-Man

    Noah Centineo to Play He-Man in 'Masters of the Universe' Reboot

    From a boy (who’s loved) to He-Man. Noah Centineo is in talks to take on the superhero in Sony Pictures and Mattel Films’ “Masters of the Universe.” More Reviews Film Review: 'Midnight Traveler' Film Review: ‘Made in Abyss: Journey’s Dawn’ Brothers Adam and Aaron Nee are directing the reboot. Mattel Films is partnering with Sony [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content