×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

‘La La Land’: Why Exuberance Matters

The 'frontrunner backlash' is right on schedule as Damien Chazelle's musical takes the final turn

A few weeks ago, my father became gravely ill. After spending a few days with him in another state, I had to get back to Los Angeles. Before I left, I put in the screener of “La La Land” for him. It was the first time I’d seen him smile in days and I remember thinking that if this blissful expression was my last memory of him, it would be a good one. Don’t worry – he’s okay now, and I don’t tell you this to be maudlin, but to reiterate the power of film. And to offer some explanation as to why the recent “La La Land” backlash annoys me more than this annual tradition usually does.

It happens every year — the frontrunners that people adored in the fall suddenly don’t seem quite as wonderful, or worse, “important,” as the year goes on.  It’s as predictable a part of the season as awkward audience questions at Q&A sessions. But it’s perhaps exacerbated in a year where diversity is so at the forefront of the discussion; a film some have perceived as “white people with champagne problems” seems almost antagonistic in that context.

Plus, the best picture race this year is full of excellent films, from wonderfully told feel-good stories like “Hidden Figures” and “Lion” to the sublime filmmaking of “Moonlight” and daring storytelling of “Manchester by the Sea” and “Arrival.” So I’m not surprised people would feel so passionately about their top choice. But it isn’t necessary to tear one film down to elevate another. The fact that all of these films have had such success, both with audiences and critics, is a huge achievement on its own.

And don’t get me wrong; there are people I’ve spoken to who have genuine points about why they don’t like “La La Land” or any of the other nominated pictures or performances. Criticism is fine. Personal tastes are what they are. What gets my hackles up is when the out-sized passion of others somehow hampers appreciation of a film. It happens all the time. “The King’s Speech” was wonderful until it started beating “The Social Network.” “The Artist” was a blast until it wasn’t deep enough. “Argo” was universally appreciated, then labeled Hollywood navel gazing.

I understand the problem with hype, and I’m just as guilty of feeding the beast. It’s hard not to get my hopes up when a festival hit finally makes its way to me, and I’ve surely judged a film against its buzz rather than on its own merits. What strikes me as particularly odd about anti-“La La Land” sentiment is the fact that the movie itself is such a joy. How could anyone begrudge such pure, infectious exuberance?

There are those who would call the film calculated, as though it were designed to win awards. That’s odd, considering it was turned down by countless studios, and original musicals aren’t exactly guaranteed at the box office or awards shows. I recall hearing similar criticism about “Birdman” when it began its awards sweep. But in what world does a movie starring an actor who’s been off the grid for the better part of a decade, directed by a filmmaker known for art house fare, begin as Oscar bait?

Then there’s the Important with a capital “I” problem. “La La Land” can be brushed off by haters as fluff, a dessert at a time when people need a hearty meal. This is something else I’ve never understood. First of all, don’t undersell entertainment that makes you feel good – it’s difficult to do, and “La La Land” commits the sin of making it look easy. Also, it seems in direct conflict with another complaint I hear about the film: that the ending is a downer. Fluff has never been so melancholy. And finally, I don’t see how the story of love and the sacrifices we make for our dreams could be deemed lightweight.

Maybe it’s just that the film has become such a Goliath. The frontrunner always has a big bull’s-eye on its back. And in small circles like #FilmTwitter, this can take on a feeling that the balance may actually shift. But don’t count on it. With awards from PGA, DGA, Golden Globes and BAFTA already on “La La Land’s” mantle, anything else winning the top prize would be a shock for the ages.

More Film

  • Riverdale Alladin Avengers Endgame

    'Avengers: Endgame,' 'Riverdale,' 'Aladdin' Top 2019 Teen Choice Award Nominations

    The nominations for the 2019 Teen Choice Awards have been revealed, and voting has opened for the top movies, TV shows and music that has dominated the last year. “Avengers: Endgame” and “Aladdin” are the top contenders in the movie category with nine and five nods, respectively. In TV, “Riverdale,” “The Flash” and “Shadowhunters” each [...]

  • 'Toy Story 4' Box Office: Pixar

    Box Office: 'Toy Story 4' Building to $140 Million-Plus Debut

    After a lackluster few weeks at movie theaters, it’s Woody and Buzz Lightyear to the rescue. The dynamic duo is returning to multiplexes for Disney and Pixar’s “Toy Story 4.” The fourth installment in the CGI series is expected to earn north of $140 million when it opens in 4,500 theaters across North America. If [...]

  • Yu Dong, Andrew Lau, Han Han,

    Shanghai Party: Red Carpet Rolled out at Bona Film Group 20th Anniversary Event

    No deal announcements. No talk of the Chinese film industry’s ongoing winter of discontent. Instead the parade of talent on stage Wednesday night at Shanghai’s Wanda Reign hotel put their troubles aside for a moment and celebrated the 20th anniversary of producer-distributor-exhibition company Bona Film Group. At regular intervals, Bona’s founder and chairman Yu Dong [...]

  • Critics Groups Form Coalition For Diversity

    Film and TV Critics Announce Coalition to Increase Diversity in Entertainment Journalism (EXCLUSIVE)

    A coalition of film and television critics associations are teaming up help foster greater diversity in entertainment journalism. The new Critics Groups for Equality in Media (CGEM) is comprised of the African American Film Critics Association (AAFCA), the Features Forum of the Asian American Journalists Association (AAJA), GALECA: The Society of LGBTQ Entertainment Critics, the [...]

  • Leonardo DiCaprio Martin Scorsese

    Paramount Buys Martin Scorsese-Leonardo DiCaprio's Crime Thriller 'Killers of the Flower Moon'

    Paramount will finance and distribute the Martin Scorsese-Leonardo DiCaprio murder mystery movie, “Killers of the Flower Moon.” Paramount chief Jim Gianopolous announced the deal Wednesday at the studio’s CineEurope presentation in Barcelona. Scorsese will direct and DiCaprio is attached to star in the adaptation of David Grann’s non-fiction book. Eric Roth is writing the screenplay. [...]

  • Franco Zeffirelli Remembered

    Franco Zeffirelli: An Artist and a Paradox

    When popular artists pass on, it can often be a surprise to learn just how old they were. But the news of Franco Zeffirelli’s death, at 96, inspired a major double take. The extravagant Italian maestro of theater, opera and film lived to a vibrant old age. Yet for many of us, the name Zeffirelli [...]

  • Evan Tanner, Professional mixed martial arts

    UFC Fighter Evan Tanner Biopic ‘The Power of 1’ in the Works (EXCLUSIVE)

    Producers Christopher Scheimann and Olcun Tan have partnered with top sports director Bobby Razak on “The Power of 1,” a feature biopic of UFC fighter Evan Tanner. Co-written by Scheimann and Razak, the movie is slated to go into pre-production toward the end of this year, with principal photography planned for early next year. Tanner, [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content