You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

Franchise Report Card: From Marvel to DC to the Dark Universe, Grading Hollywood’s Big Series

In Hollywood, a studio is only as strong as its franchises. That’s bad news for a number of players. Recent months have not been kind to a number of major film series, as sequels to “Transformers,” “Pirates of the Caribbean,” and “Alien” have sputtered to the box office, and attempts to spawn new franchises, such as the Dark Universe, have collapsed. Some properties, particularly those in the DC Comics and Marvel realms, have emerged from the box office blood sports unscathed, but they remain exceptions to the rules.

Through the first half of 2017, here’s a look at which major series are still going strong and which franchises have spawned their last sequel.

State of the Franchise: After four decades and seven films, this extraterrestrial chiller may have offered up its last chestburster with “Alien: Convenant.” So far the film has earned a little more than half of what its predecessor, 2012’s “Prometheus,” racked up…and that film was considered a disappointment.
Grade: C

State of the Franchise: Christian Grey and Anastasia Steele are still smoldering. Many predicted that the guilty pleasure wouldn’t evoke the same kinky fun as the series progressed, but “Fifty Shades Darker,” the second chapter in the trilogy, earned an impressive $378.8 million globally. That’s a far cry from the first film’s $571 million haul, but stands as a solid result given the critical drubbing and the fact that, you know, these films are based on glorified “Twilight” fan fiction.
Grade: B

Popular on Variety

State of the Franchise: Time to put Captain Jack Sparrow in dry dock. “Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales” will be the lowest grossing film in the series since the the first film sailed into theaters 14 years ago. Worse, with a budget of $230 million, the franchise needs a lot of treasure to make it worth putting the Black Pearl on the high seas again. Oh, and Depp’s off-screen hijinks don’t make the idea of more Pirates films all that appealing for Disney, the studio behind the series.
Grade: C-

State of the Franchise: Thank God for China. The Middle Kingdom swung to the rescue last weekend after “Transformers: The Last Knight” stumbled to a $69.1 million domestic opening. In China, it was another story — the film’s massive $123 million launch is one of the country’s best ever. It could even ensure that we haven’t seen the last of Optimus Prime.
Grade: B-

State of the Franchise: In transition? Hugh Jackman ended his run as the man of adamantium on a high note; “Logan,” his bloody, R-rated sendoff  to the character that made him a star, earned raves and big box office. Fox would dearly love to see Jackman don the claws for another adventure. Otherwise some other up-and-coming up actor will have the unenviable task of trying to put their own spin on Wolvie.
Grade: A (if Jackman returns), B (if they have to reboot).

State of the Franchise: Remember the Hindenburg? It’s an apt visual metaphor for how “The Mummy” went over with summer crowds. The film’s failure puts the fate of Universal’s planned interconnected universe of monster movies in jeopardy.
Grade: D

State of the Franchise: Still the king. “Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2” might not have been as critically beloved as numero uno, but with $851.4 million and counting in global grosses, the superhero series is a juggernaut. Plus, “Spider-Man: Homecoming,” the first wall-crawler movie that Marvel has produced, is earning raves and looks like a winner. All that and there’s another Thor movie hitting theaters in November. Not bad. Not bad at all.
Grade: A

State of the Franchise: Nothing’s wrong under the engine. “Fate of the Furious” may not have equaled the grosses for “Furious 7,” but with more than $1 billion in ticket sales, Dom and the “family” are showing few signs of slowing down.
Grade: A-

Until about a week ago, “Lego Movie” creative duo Phil Lord and Christopher Miller were in about as enviable a position in Hollywood as anyone. But we live in a post-”Star Wars”-spinoff-drama world. “Lego Batman” earned less than the first movie, and time will tell if the coming installations will be able to recapture the madcap spark of the original.
Grade: B

“Cars” has never been the most box office-friendly of the Disney-Pixar franchises, but the latest release, “Cars 3,” saw the lowest opening of the series yet. A fourth installment has yet to be announced, suggesting that the studio is hitting the brakes on the ongoing saga of Lightning McQueen. Don’t count on the series being relegated to the scrapyard, however. Even a rough day out for Disney is better than most, and there are, after all, still toys to sell.
Grade: B-

Making money has never been an issue for DC Comics movies (thanks to a seemingly insatiable fanbase with … arguably too much loyalty). Yet, until “Wonder Woman” hit theaters in June,  the franchise couldn’t seem to find its creative footing. “Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice” was too dark, “Suicide Squad” was completely incoherent. The next few releases, a group that includes “Justice League” and “Aquaman,” will be crucial. If they build on”Wonder Woman’s” success, DC could rival Marvel. If they fail to capture the same spirit of adventure,  fanboys and fangirls may lose faith in these costumed heroes.
Grade: B+

More Film

  • Richard Jewell

    Box Office: Clint Eastwood Suffers Worst Opening in Four Decades With 'Richard Jewell'

    Clint Eastwood might end up with a lump of box office coal after “Richard Jewell” sputtered in its domestic debut. Despite critical acclaim, the drama about the security guard falsely accused by the media for playing a part in the 1996 Olympics bombing ignited with a dismal $5 million from 2,502 theaters. It’s a disappointing [...]

  • (from left) Tom (Henry Golding) and

    Emilia Clarke's 'Last Christmas' Crosses $100 Million at Global Box Office

    Universal’s “Last Christmas,” a romantic comedy starring Emilia Clarke and Henry Golding, surpassed $100 million in global ticket sales. The milestone is a win for original fare, one that is especially impressive considering the movie was skewered by critics for its wacky twist ending. After six weeks in theaters, “Last Christmas” has earned $34.4 million [...]

  • DSCF0855.RAF

    'Jumanji 2' Rules Overseas Box Office With $85 Million

    Sony’s “Jumanji: The Next Level” powered international box office charts, collecting $85 million from 34 markets over the weekend. The action-packed sequel kicked off in North America with $60 million for a global start of $145 million. “Jumanji: The Next Level” debuted in a handful of foreign territories last weekend, bringing box office receipts to [...]

  • Rey (Daisy Ridley) in STAR WARS:

    Disney Plus Signs Exclusive Distribution Deal With Canal Plus in France

    Ahead of its launch in France on March 31, 2020, Disney Plus has signed an exclusive distribution agreement with Canal Plus Group, the country’s leading pay-TV company. The deal, which was first reported in the French newspaper Les Echos and confirmed by Canal Plus Group CEO Maxime Saada on his Twitter account, marks a new [...]

  • French movie actress Anna Karina smiles

    Anna Karina, French New Wave Star and Jean-Luc Godard Collaborator, Dies at 79

    French New Wave star Anna Karina, who served as a muse for Jean-Luc Godard and appeared in eight of his films, has died. She was 79. France’s culture minister, Franck Reister, announced her death in a tweet, as did her agent, Laurent Balandras, who attributed the cause as cancer. “Her gaze was the gaze of [...]

  • Frozen 2

    'Frozen 2' Sets Record as Disney's Sixth Movie to Hit $1 Billion in 2019

    “Frozen 2” is the sixth Disney movie this year to hit $1 billion globally, strengthening the studio’s sheer dominance over the box office. Those ticket sales extend the benchmark Disney set over summer, with five other films — “Avengers: Endgame,” “Aladdin,” “Toy Story 4,” “The Lion King” and “Captain Marvel” — joining the billion-dollar club [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content