×
You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

YouTube Has 1 Billion Videos With Closed-Captioning, but Not All of Them Are Accurate

YouTube is boasting that a whopping 1 billion videos on the service now include closed-captioning for deaf and hearing-impaired users. That certainly sounds impressive — except when you realize that many of the site’s automatically generated captions aren’t completely right.

The Google-owned video giant first launched captions back in 2006, and three years later introduced automatic speech recognition to add closed-captioning to YouTube content. Today, YouTube users watch video with auto-generated captions more than 15 million times per day.

But the system is prone to errors. For example, the trailer for Amazon Studio’s Oscar-nominated “Manchester by the Sea” (at this link) includes numerous inaccuracies in the auto-transcribed captions, sometimes to hilarious — not to mention frustrating — effect.

“My heart was broken nose is broken too,” Michelle Williams’ character says to Casey Affleck’s, according to the YouTube captions. What she actually says is, “My heart was broken. I know yours is broken, too.”

YouTube recognizes the limits of the automatic closed-captioning. “A major goal for the team has been improving the accuracy of automatic captions — something that is not easy to do for a platform of YouTube’s size and diversity of content,” YouTube product manager Liat Kaver wrote in a blog post Thursday.

Since introducing auto-CC in 2009, YouTube claims it has boosted accuracy by 50% for videos in English by improving speech recognition and machine-learning algorithms, and expanding its training data. Ideally, according to Kaver, every video would have an automatic caption track generated by YouTube’s system that would then be reviewed and edited by the creator.

YouTube creators and publishers also can also submit their own closed-captions. When that’s not the case, YouTube captions all videos in 10 supported languages — English, Dutch, French, German, Italian, Japanese, Korean, Portuguese, Russian and Spanish — unless there’s poor sound quality or the system otherwise can’t detect the speech. Users have the option to remove the auto-generated captions, as well as enable community contributions to let viewers write the captions and/or translate the speech instead.

Meanwhile, the number also reveals that YouTube has at least 1 billion video clips. Google has never disclosed how many videos are hosted on the global network.

Pictured above: Amazon Studios’ “Manchester by the Sea” trailer on YouTube with automatic closed-captioning.

More Digital

  • No Merchandising. Editorial Use Only. No

    Google Plugs ‘Avengers: Endgame’ With Thanos Easter Egg

    As if “Avengers: Endgame” needed any more publicity: Google has added an easter egg to its search engine to further plug the latest Marvel flick that demonstrates just how destructive super-villain Thanos can be. To unlock the easter egg, you’ll just have to google Thanos, find the gauntlet icon hiding in the info sidebar (or [...]

  • Cinedigm-Comcast-X1-Contv-Docurama

    Comcast Xfinity X1 Adds Cinedigm's CONtv and Docurama to VOD Lineup

    Comcast’s Xfinity X1 now offers Cinedigm’s subscription-based video services CONtv and Docurama, continuing the expansion of the cable operator’s internet-delivered entertainment options. CONtv, priced at $4.99 per month, offers a selection of classic cult films and series, and Docurama ($2.99 per month) provides a library of documentaries. The two Cinedigm properties follow the launch of [...]

  • Sinemia

    Sinemia Shuts Down U.S. Movie-Ticket Subscription Service

    Sinemia, a would-be rival to MoviePass, is closing down its U.S. operations — telling customers it could not find “a path to sustainability” amid legal headaches, competitive pressures and the challenging economics of the business model. The company announced the shutdown in a notice on its website Thursday. “While we are proud to have created [...]

  • APOS: Asia Streamer Hooq Heads for

    APOS: Asia Streamer Hooq Heads for 100 Original Shows

    Asian video streaming service Hooq has committed itself to developing at least 100 original shows and films by the end of this year. They will be produced in Singapore, Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand and India, and range in genre terms from horror to comedy and from factual to lifestyle. The company has begun the immediate release [...]

  • APOS: Turner and Tencent Reteam on

    APOS: Turner and Tencent Reteam on Tuzki-Starring 'Second Time'

    Turner Asia Pacific and China’s Tencent are joining forces for “Second Time Around,” a Chinese drama that will air later this year. The series makes use of Tuzki, a Turner owned animated character that has become famous as an emoticon in Tencent’s WeChat universe. Turner is licensing the character and will invest in the series [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content