You will be redirected back to your article in seconds

VidAngel Urges 9th Circuit to Lift Injunction Barring Filtering Service

Attorneys for the VidAngel filtering service urged a three-judge panel on Thursday to lift an injunction that has kept the service off-line for the last five months.

In December, U.S. District Judge Andre Birotte granted the injunction at the request of Disney, 20th Century Fox, and Warner Bros., who have argued that VidAngel is pirating their content. VidAngel buys DVDs of major studio releases and then “rents” them online to its customers, with offensive language and sexual content edited out. Though it does so without a license, VidAngel contends that its service does not violate copyright law, and is expressly permitted by the federal Family Movie Act.

In the 40-minute argument at the 9th Circuit Court of Appeal in Pasadena, Calif., the judges did not seem sympathetic with VidAngel’s position. As the judges called the VidAngel case, having just dealt with complex arguments over a police search, Judge Carlos Bea turned to his colleague, Judge Andrew Hurwitz, and audibly whispered: “I think this one’s a lot easier.”

Hurwitz responded: “Me too.”

This was not taken as an encouraging sign for VidAngel. The company’s attorney, Peter Stris, faced pointed questioning from Hurwitz about VidAngel’s practice of decrypting DVDs in order to filter out offensive content. At one point, Hurwitz referred to VidAngel’s use of “what appears to be illegal software.”

Stris argued that VidAngel is tantamount to Redbox DVD rentals, and argued that its streaming of filtered movies qualifies as private home viewing, and is not a public performance of the films.

The studios retained Donald Verrilli, the former solicitor general most famous his Supreme Court arguments on behalf of gay marriage and the Affordable Care Act. Verrilli, now a partner at Munger, Tolles & Olson, was blistering in his attack on VidAngel.

“It’s an unlicensed on-demand streaming service that lacks any legal justification and is totally unfair to us and to licensed streaming services,” he argued.

Verrilli noted that VidAngel advertised that it had movies that were unavailable on Netflix, making it clear that it was competing unlawfully with licensed services.

“They’re saying, ‘If we filter, we can stream without a license,'” Verrilli said. To interpret the law that way, he said, “would effect a massive transfer of economic value from copyright owners who made the works to somebody who streams without a license.”

Hurwitz’s questions of Verrilli were few and generally deferential.

Following the arguments, VidAngel CEO Neal Harmon praised Stris for doing a “masterful job” of arguing for the injunction to be overturned.

“Regardless of the outcome of this stage, we believe, when all is said and done, that the Family Movie Act of 2005 will prevail and VidAngel will be able to provide filtering to customers on modern streaming devices,” Harmon said in a statement.

More Digital

  • Chinese Tech Firm Huawei Seeks Content

    Beleaguered Chinese Tech Firm Huawei Seeks Content for Expansion Into Southeast Asia

    One of the most surprising first-time attendees at FilMart is Chinese tech giant Huawei, which has come to Hong Kong to acquire the video content it needs to support its strategy of expansion into Southeast Asia. The company is currently embroiled in a PR nightmare as it defends itself against accusations that its equipment could [...]

  • Canadian Animation Shop Guru Studio Makes

    Canadian Animation Shop Guru Studio Makes Moves in China

    Guru Studio, an award-winning Canadian animation studio, is exploring the possibility of opening an office in Hong Kong or mainland China. The Toronto-based company is keen to get a slice of China’s animation market, which has been growing quickly. Louise Jones, Guru vice president of finance and business affairs, said at a FilMart panel discussion [...]

  • Netflix's Newest Interactive Animated Kids Show

    Netflix Announces New Interactive Animated Kids Show 'Battle Kitty'

    Netflix is doubling down on interactive content for kids. The streaming service announced a new interactive animated show on Tuesday dubbed “Battle Kitty” from Matt Layzell. The company didn’t share a premiere date for the show yet. “Netflix has given me the incredible opportunity to help change how young people see themselves,” said Layzell. “Like [...]

  • stream march madness 2019 online free

    NCAA Tournament: How to Stream March Madness Online

    The rankings are in, and the 68-team field is set. March Madness is officially upon us, and if you want to catch the action from home, from the office, or on-the-go, there are a couple ways to stream March Madness online for free. The first game kicks off today, and the tournament runs until April [...]

  • Google Stream Detailed, Named Stadia

    Google's Stadia Aims to Turn Any Screen Into a Powerful Gaming Console

    Stadia is Google’s game streaming service that is designed to let you play high-end games on most modern screens — be they phone, laptop, tablet, computer or TV — with very little download time and no loss of fidelity, the company announced Tuesday at the Game Developers Conference. The service is launching in 2019. Cost [...]

  • Amazon Focused on Building the Game

    Amazon Focused on Building the Game Industry's Digital Infrastructure

    While most of the discussion around Amazon’s presence in the game industry revolves around their scattershot game projects and rumored cloud gaming platform, the tech giant has been far more involved in building the backend infrastructure for major games. Companies like Square Enix and Zynga both use Amazon Games Tech, Amazon’s portfolio of services that [...]

  • patreon logo

    Patreon Launches Tiered Pricing for Creators, Introduces Rates for Micropayments

    Membership services platform Patreon is growing up: The company announced Tuesday that it is moving away from its one-size-fits-all pricing model for creators, introducing two new tiers in the process. In addition, Patreon is also standardizing its payment processing fees, and introducing a new dedicated rate for small-donor transactions. Patreon’s cut of the membership fees [...]

More From Our Brands

Access exclusive content